Roger,
Tell me if this is correct. From my looking at the components,
The engine drove a belt to the blower with similar diameters pulleys and then the gear box reduced the speed by .53 ( 15 to 28 teeth gears) . That shaft drove the blower impeller and beyond. So I think the normal gasoline engine speed maximizes at about 3600 rpm.
So on your original setup the blower impeller would be turning about 1800-1900 rpm. or tip speed of 6594 ft / min
If this is correct , you could remove the speed reducing gear box and drive from your 2500 pto and reduce engine rpm or reverse the gear box and feed from 1000 pto.
Example of typical tip speed: rear TPO at 540 rpm turning a 24" impeller = 3390 tip speed
From reading various threads on the web, tip speed is varies from 3000 to 5000 feet per minute.
rob