Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL?

   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #1  

BadDecisions

Silver Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
142
Location
Wittmann, AZ
Tractor
Ford 8N
Been searching for an upgrade to my Craftsman lawn tractor on and off for a few years now with a (probably too) low budget. Ideally I've wanted to stay below $5,000, and have been limiting my search to tractors with a FEL. I live outside Phoenix, AZ in a rural open desert. I have ZERO plans/intentions/desires to do _any_ type of farming/gardening/etc so I'll never own a plow or other "ground engaging implements"..at least I think, anyways. I'm still trying to make sense of all the terminology, lol.

My primary intentions for the tractor is land clearing, and again - desert environment - I'm not going to be attempting to push over massive oak trees here, lol. I have just over an acre that's been well overgrown with weeds and small brushy plants, up to about 1/2" diameter trunks at most. A circular saw blade on the weed trimmer cuts them down like butter, but they still come back. I've been slowly working with vegetation killer, which works, but it still leaves dead plants behind, which I'm still dealing with clean up, and it seems like it grows faster than I have time to go back and clean up. Then I'm still left with very uneven ground from years of these things growing up in different places.

My thinking/plan there was either a grader blade, or what I believe is called a gannon box? Use either to just basically scrape the top layer off, hopefully taking much of the weed growth with it.

Secondary, I need to move heavy things around. Like steel tube and sheet for various other projects from the truck/trailer to the shop, and various heavy car parts - axles, engines, etc. I'd like to buy things like softener salt more in bulk, like perhaps by the pallet load rather than one bag at a time from the grocery store. I had to remove the center section from the rear axle of my 2.5 ton truck last year for repairs, and getting it back in was an adventure since it's parked on dirt, and it wouldn't fit in the shop to use a jack on concrete. Ended up making a makeshift "crane" from multiple ratchet straps fed in from the top of the flatbed.

The most weight in parts I can think of that I'd be lifting is 1,000 pounds, though I understand a full pallet of salt is around 2500 pounds.

I can certainly see a use for a FEL, especially in times of say, doing some landscaping and wanting to move dirt and rocks around. But it would be rather infrequent, and lifting/moving those heavy things would be FAR more frequent for me. So now I'm wondering if trying to hold out for a tractor with a FEL that falls within my budget is really the best idea? Might I better off doing something like hanging an engine hoist off a 3 point, and using that for lifting duties anyways? I've seen quite a few larger tractors selling for well within my budget without the FEL, but tractors with a FEL are a rare one, and usually end up being a non-runner or in need in major amounts of repairs. Having never owned a tractor like this before, I'm hesitant to buy one without a FEL to try to add one later, as being my first "real" tractor, concern that I'll just have to buy another one later when I learn that whatever I bought really wouldn't work with a FEL anyways.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #2  
Shame when you have a budget, buy the wrong thing and have to start again, sometimes loosing time and money in the process.

You are asking alot for your price range. You could probably buy a good used fork lift for cheaper than a hefty tractor. Sounds like you want to do a lot of lifiting. Purpose built stuff always works bettter. A tractor can do a lot of things but doesn't tend to do any of them really well.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #3  
For what it's worth, the following 3 implements can be used on the 3pt. Boom pole (engine hoist), dirt scoop (poor mans fel/bucket), Box Blade for land leveling. Even harder to find is used 3pt forklift (not forks, something that lifts). A FEL with forks requires one of the larger compact tractors. Or one of the "regular" tractors from the 60-80's era before they started making them lightweight. Kubota loaders use a numbering system where # is approximate lifting power at the curling pin in kilograms. ex. LA545 should be around 500k or 1100 lbs at curl pin, subtract weight of forks, distance from curl pin, around 700lbs estimate on usable lifting weight.

An 50 year old tractor should handle your needs nicely Tractor House website or magazines will help you decide what you need and approximate selling prices. Tractordata.com will allow you to research the tractor/fel specs. Good luck on your search.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #4  
Dynalift On Farm June 16 1991 B.jpg

We had the Tractor on the Left as our only machine for Decades with no FEL. Then upgraded to the machine on the right. lol 8000# Lift.

We used a Boom Pole a lot on the tractor, but of course it is no good for pallets.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #5  
The most weight in parts I can think of that I'd be lifting is 1,000 pounds, though I understand a full pallet of salt is around 2500 pounds.
I think you're gona have a hard time finding a tractor that'll competently do that kind of lifting for that kind of money. Best bet, as someone already pointed out, is probably a forklift. That'll get you the most lift capacity for the money. Not gonna help with the grading/scraping type work, but you can get an old tractor from the 50's-70's for a song that'll do that sort of thing. Look for a decent used forklift and then save your pennies and buy an 8N or similar for $2000 later.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #6  
You sometimes see 3ph forklift masts for sale. Except for having to be turned around, this is the natural choice. It's where a tractor should be carrying the weight anyways. On the heavy rear axle, and the robust driven one on a 2WD.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #7  
You sometimes see 3ph forklift masts for sale. Except for having to be turned around, this is the natural choice. It's where a tractor should be carrying the weight anyways. On the heavy rear axle, and the robust driven one on a 2WD.

Lifting that kind of weight off the back especially with minimal front ballast will still take no slouch of a tractor.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #8  
Rigging that up with a quick attach could make it quite handy. I am no fan of AG loaders and would consider that if I was in that position. I lift and carry way more stuff than I ever use or need a bucket for.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #9  
I can see a use for a FEL, especially in times of say, doing some landscaping and wanting to move dirt and rocks around. But it would be rather infrequent, and lifting/moving those heavy things would be FAR more frequent for me. The most weight in parts I can think of that I'd be lifting is 1,000 pounds, though I understand a full pallet of salt is around 2500 pounds.

So now I'm wondering if trying to hold out for a tractor with a FEL that falls within my budget is really the best idea? I've seen quite a few larger tractors selling for well within my $5,000 budget without the FEL, but tractors with a FEL are a rare one, and usually end up being a non-runner or in need in major amounts of repairs.

One of the older, heavier tractors with a $350 Three Point Hitch boom pole might serve you well for your primary lifting task.

VIDEO: tractor boom pole - YouTube



A Three Point Hitch dirt scoop will move occasional dirt and rocks.

VIDEO: tractor bucket scoop - YouTube


Both these attachments carry the weight over the wide, heavy rear axle for reasonable stability.


You contradict yourself in your post:

I have ZERO plans/intentions/desires to do _any_ type of farming/gardening/etc so I'll never own "ground engaging implements". My thinking/plan there was either a grader blade, or a box blade? Gannon is a brand of box blade.

VIDEO: tractor box blade - YouTube
 
Last edited:
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #10  
I live on just over an acre of Phoenix, Arizona desert land. .

Rent a tractor for a 3-day weekend.

My wife would never let me display an ugly old tractor plus attachments on one acre.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #11  
Rent a tractor for a 3-day weekend.

My wife would never let me display an ugly old tractor plus attachments on one acre.

We have a loader tractor on an acre, and use it at least several times a week.

for 5 grand, you could probably do without a loader. finding something under 7 or 8 with a loader that will be reliable will be difficult. It sounds like you could a pole for most of the lifting. getting a tractor that will lift a full pallet of anything will cost 3x your budget. cheaper end tractors loose very little in value after the first 10 years or so. a 6-8k tractor with a loader that is mechanically sound will be worth that much until it dies.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL?
  • Thread Starter
#12  
You could probably buy a good used fork lift for cheaper than a hefty tractor.

I've thought about that for a while, and I still can not even begin to fathom how a fork lift is going to do anything but lifting thing. Plus, I would need an all terrain one, and even the "cheap" versions of those are anything but cheap. I already know that a typical warehouse surplus lift is going to be a royal pain in the backside on a dirt lot, meaning I'll be spending more time getting it unstuck than actually using it, and refueling is gonna be a pain as the local propane places won't fill anything but a 20lb BBQ tank. They won't even touch my camper tanks.

One of the older, heavier tractors with a $350 Three Point Hitch boom pole might serve you well for your primary lifting task.

You contradict yourself in your post:

I have ZERO plans/intentions/desires to do _any_ type of farming/gardening/etc so I'll never own "ground engaging implements". My thinking/plan there was either a grader blade, or a box blade? Gannon is a brand of box blade.

My understanding was ground engaging was things like plows that go deep into the ground, whereas box blades ride on top of the ground? Though I'm really beginning to understand why my neighbor got so frustrated, and eventually just said screw it, went to the dealer, told them what he was doing, and brought home a new $25K Asian import tractor...that broke 3 times in the first year, followed by the dealer telling him that the tractor wasn't designed to carry the backhoe that they sold him with it as a package. For him though, $25K wasn't really a big amount to throw down, nor was the $60K he dropped on a new truck, then a 2nd new one 4 months later when he didn't like the 1st one. Me..I've never spent more than $3500 on any vehicle I've ever owned in my entire life, and a brand new car is never going to happen.

Rent a tractor for a 3-day weekend.

My wife would never let me display an ugly old tractor plus attachments on one acre.

Well, seeing as how I'm not married to your wife, which is likely a good thing...she would likely have an aneurysm if she saw the collection of old stuff here.

When my wife was still alive, she brought home more "ugly old stuff" than I did.

Renting really wouldn't be feasible for me. That too would get expensive to rent one every time I needed it at around $1000/each time, highly inconvenient given that the nearest rental place is nearly an hour away, and a 3 day weekend isn't a guaranteed 3 days for me as I'm on call for work 24/7/365.

End story of all this is that I'm still really just guessing at what I need, and I just keep confusing myself more and more. I never really have been able to find any decent source that will lay out capabilities of different things beyond WIDE generalities, which doesn't really help those who really have no idea of what they're getting in to. Guess I'm just going to have to risk a few bad financial decisions, lol.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #13  
I never worked any Arizona desert before, but have done a lot of work clearing here in Central Texas brush country both with and without tractors. Your budget of $5000 is seriously restrictive, and doubt it can be done by purchasing a reliable FEL tractor and box blade implement within that budget.

It may be most simple and best to just hire local land clearing labor and clear by hand. They can go through first pass with chainsaws, and cut most everything to ground level. Then put all that into a burn pile, and burn it under close supervision, on a non-windy day. If it's just 1 acre, they may do that all that cutting and burning in about 3 days work.

Follow up with rental of a tractor/box blade and spend about 2 days just working the box blade with its rippers down 4 inches into the soil, and that loosens and tears the vegetation and turns the soil over. Followed up with a good day of leveling work with box blade. Ideally, your weeds and brush will stay away a lot longer doing this....but should allow your lawn mower to handle everything from this point foward.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #14  
I have zero desert knowledge, but have heard that when camping there one should look in his boots in the morning before slipping them on.


I do have experience with a boom pole and dirt scoop on a small tractor. The boom pole is not very useful on a small tractor. Picking anything heavy would bring the front wheels off the ground. Scoop did the same when I managed to get it full. It even had a couple suitcase weights on the front.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #15  
An older tractor like a Ferguson, Ford or International would probably suit your needs and come in under your budget. You can do quite a bit with these older tractors. They are decent at pulling and ground work especially compared to new compact tractors. I grew up running old TO30s and Ford 8Ns. You learn to use boom poles and other 3pt implements to move and lift things. They work well for “mowing” too.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #16  
I would hire out a contractor to do the initial land clearing, and any grading you want done. Then buy a small old tractor minus FEL with a brush hog 3 pt rotary mower to stay on top of it all after that.

Everyone has a budget they have to stick to. I get it. But realistically, you're not going to be able to touch the equipment you need for $5K. The ground there is like iron, and to get a tractor big enough to be able to scrape and grade that cast iron soil is going to be big. Like utility tractor sized big, or bigger.

Once you get the initial clearing done, and get the grade the way you want it, it will be much easier to manage. That part you should be able to realistically do with a SCUT sized or older CUT sized tractor. Heck, even a garden tractor would be able to manage, you'll just have to do something to the tires (foam them or find solid ones) to stop the tire punctures that are going to be likely. Even the grass there has spikes and thorns, and I doubt you have any grass. :D
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #17  
I'm still guessing at what I need, and I just keep confusing myself more and more. I never really have been able to find any decent source that will lay out capabilities of different things beyond WIDE generalities, which doesn't really help those who really have no idea of what they're getting in to. Guess I'm just going to have to risk a bad financial decision.

U-Tube videos should give you some idea of tractor weight/size capability. A little "more" tractor is much better than "not enough" tractor. Within your $5,000 budget you will not have a multitude of choices.

Probably 2/3 of first time new tractor buyers wish they had purchased a heavier tractor than the one they have, within two years.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #18  
Lifting that kind of weight off the back especially with minimal front ballast will still take no slouch of a tractor.

I guess some of that is dependent on how much you need to lift and the size of your tractor;
I consider my IH 574 to be a light weight tractor in that it is a utility with a "small" frame.
Here she is with 1200 pounds on the forks, the front end is light but still on the ground.
removing weights 4.jpgremoving weights 3.jpgremoving weights 2.jpgremoving weights 1.jpg
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #19  
The garden type tractor may not be built sturdily enough for either serious bucket or Three point lifting and weight transportation.

It may be advisable to look for a twenty HP and up diesel tractor.

As a side note a Kubota B7100 would work for your situation. 16 HP.
 
   / Lifting via FEL vs 3 point? Maybe I've looking at it wrong thinking I NEED a FEL? #20  
I壇 break what you need into two tools. One being an engine hoist or some kind of overhead crane. The other being a used compact tractor. Lifting something like 2500 pound pallets is going to take a big machine so probably not going to happen. A 1000 pounds is possible. Maybe add a little to your budget and get a tractor that will do everything you want say a FEL and brush cutter box blade and a set of forks.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Lee Boy 250 Gal Tack Distributor (A53317)
Lee Boy 250 Gal...
Massey Ferguson 1745 Hesston series (A53317)
Massey Ferguson...
Year: 2019 Make: Nissan Model: NV200 Vehicle Type: Van Mileage: 88,557 Plate: Body Type: 4 Door Van (A55853)
Year: 2019 Make...
TANK MANIFOLD (A58214)
TANK MANIFOLD (A58214)
2013 Dodge Charger Sedan (A55973)
2013 Dodge Charger...
(APPROX. 26) 4' X 8' X 3/4" OSB SHEETS (A52706)
(APPROX. 26) 4' X...
 
Top