Grapple Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??

   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #21  
I wonder how it will hold up to rough digging and grubbing with my heavy machine? It would be a shame to bend up a new grapple! I'll look into it some more and thanks for the info. I liked how you said it weighed 1200lbs but then i noticed that must have been a mistake, and it weighs in at 800lbs.

No mistake, the Monster weighs 1200 pounds, the smaller opening Standard is 800 pounds.

My V417 weighs almost 11,000, I will have to measure the curl force, lift force over 5K, Boom breakout force 6700 pounds, drawbar pull 7K. I have stressed the Monster Grapple to the max, and have not bent it. Very few companies make their grapple tines with 1/2" thick steel.

What will be the main use for your grapple?
 
Last edited:
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #22  
A heavy load would be the the maximum curl force of your curl cylinders, plus the lift force of the loader, plus the drawbar pull rating of your tractor. Think trying to remove a stump while curling, lifting and spinning your wheels.

I have bent those 1/4" top plates on two different fork frames, with just the curl force with the V417.

If you are going to modify to pin on, they might work.
Hmm.. I see what you mean.. Seems there are a lot of grapples with those same plates and no bracing.

However, I am in 'beach sand' land and can push over a 4" tree with just my Simplicity 7016 :D. Kinda why I need the grapple now - a TON of fallen trees.. :mad:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #23  
This is what happens to a 1/4 inch thick attachment plate that is made with no bracing, when there is too much lifting force on it.

I put a straight edge on it, so you can see the streched metal
P6060006.JPG P6060001.JPG P6060003.JPG

This is the attachment area for the Monster Grapple. It is made with 1/2 inch thick steel.
P6060022.JPG P6060019.JPG P6060020.JPG

And braced with a 5/8 inch thick plate. It is not likely to bend from a heavy load.
P6060023.JPG P6060024.JPG
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #24  
This is what happens to a 1/4 inch thick attachment plate that is made with no bracing, when there is too much lifting force on it.
Thanks :thumbsup: I see the problem..

Welding on brackets for pins would prolly eliminate this issue.. maybe with a doubling plate welded on first..?

I do believe the OP is not set on a certain method of attachment, only thinking about a QA adaptor, so prolly doesnt matter anyway, but its always good to have all the info you can to make a good decision. He might very well need a substantially heavier grapple where he lives. I know I am now gonna be looking more closely and maybe go get some scrap steel ;)
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #25  
BTW - is that one of yours that got bent?
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #26  
BTW - is that one of yours that got bent?

Yep, light duty pallet fork frame. Had used it on the V417 to load 2 3/8 tubing on a friend's trailer, hauled to his place to unload, forks are 42 inches long, put them too far under, when I curled up, it raised about 4 inches, bent and fell down on to the trailer.

Here is the other one. 1/4 inch SSQA plate, 3/8 x 2 inch bar across the top. Was using it on the V417, trying to pop a dead tree out of the ground, when it broke.

P6060008.JPG P6060010.JPG P6060014.JPG P6060015.JPG

I knew it needed bracing added, just never got a roundtuit, now I need a fixittuit! :laughing:


I always wanted to be a procrastinator, I just never got a round to it.
 
Last edited:
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #27  
I wonder how it will hold up to rough digging and grubbing with my heavy machine? It would be a shame to bend up a new grapple! I'll look into it some more and thanks for the info. I liked how you said it weighed 1200lbs .....................................

I could not find any documentation on the weight of the Monster Grapple, I was going by what the eBay seller told me.

Got out the crane scales.
P6060034.JPG P6060035.JPG P6060036.JPG

Pretty close?
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #28  
Very few companies make their grapple tines with 1/2" thick steel.

I would agree to this statement because so many grapples are made very flimsy.
Both Anbo GRSH and especially the Borgford BoDozer are have tines that are more than 1/2" thick.
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??
  • Thread Starter
#29  
I could not find any documentation on the weight of the Monster Grapple, I was going by what the eBay seller told me.

If this the same "Monster Grapple" manufactured by Loflin Fabrication, its weight is not posted in the Grapple Specs chart on their web site. I have emailed them several times regarding their Standard Root Grapple and Mike Atwell has always promptly replied.

On a different subject, is anyone familiar with North American Implements and United Fabrication (both also located in Denton, NC)? They both offer "heavy duty" grapples, with 1/2" steel tines, that appear to have good features. I have communicated with United Fabrication regarding a skid steer conversion unit, but have not discussed their grapple with them.

The search continues!:D
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #30  
If this the same "Monster Grapple" manufactured by Loflin Fabrication, its weight is not posted in the Grapple Specs chart on their web site. I have emailed them several times regarding their Standard Root Grapple and Mike Atwell has always promptly replied.

.........

The search continues!:D

Yep, same one. It was recommended to me by the local Bobcat dealer, when I told him I was looking for a grapple with a large opening.

Well I now know mine weighs almost 1200 pounds, and is very well built! :D:thumbsup:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??
  • Thread Starter
#31  
Well I now know mine weighs almost 1200 pounds, and is very well built! :D:thumbsup:

If my tractor were large enough to handle the Monster it would be at the top of my list. I've narrowed the list down to three models and Loflins Standard model is near the top. Good to hear you are pleased with yours!:thumbsup:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #32  
WJB,
Regarding the heavy duty SS adapter for your loader, you might want to try to get in touch with Eddiewalker. He went through essentially the same thing you are trying to do, and might have some helpful tips/insight. You can read his thread on adding a grapple to his Ford/NH 555E here: Grapple for 555E There are some good pics in that thread as well..


Regarding the hydraulics required to operate the thumb, it really shouldn't be too difficult to do, with a little patience. There are three ways to do this, but the general consensus on here, is that 2 of the 3 ways really are "best".
Note: Skip over the next 3 paragraphs to avoid falling asleep...

1. 3rd function electric over hydraulic valve-This will be an additional valve (not to be confused with valve "handle") in your FEL system, operated by a 3 position rocker switch mounted on your FEL joystick, that will allow you to raise/lower the loader, curl/dump the bucket, and open/close the grapple all at the same time. The 3 positions of the rocker switch are either open grapple, close grapple, or no action. You would press and hold the rocker switch to open or close the grapple, then when you release, it springs back to neutral position.
The WR Long 3rd function valve is what I have, and am very happy with it. It was extremely simple to install (even with no prior hydraulic experience) and Nelson Long is a member on here, and very, very helpful. He spent a lot of time on the phone with me explaining how the valve works, and answered my very basic questions.

2. Selector vavle (aka diverter valve)- This is a valve (again, not operated by a "handle") you install on your tractor FEL system, that is operated by a push button on your FEL joystick handle. It ties in to either your up/down circuit, or your curl circuit (I believe you can choose whichever you prefer). With this valve, you can NOT operate all 3 functions at once, which may or may not matter to you.
Let's say you tie it into your curl circuit.....Normal operation would be to dump your bucket when you push your joystick to the right, however, if you wanted to close your grapple, you would push the button on your FEL joystick (which would then "divert" the flow of hydraulic fluid to your grapple cylinder) and then push your joystick to the right, so instead of dumping your bucket, you would be closing your grapple. You would not be able to curl/dump your bucket, at the same time you open/close your grapple, but you could still raise/lower your loader arms while simultaneously opening/closing the grapple. You can only use 2 functions at one time, not 3 like the other kit.

Generally, the electric over hydraulic 3rd function valve is considered "better" than the selector valve. However, it's not necessarily "better" in every way. One advantage of the selector valve, is that when you divert the flow to the grapple cylinder, you can then operate your FEL joystick with a feathering motion, so you can either close your grapple very slowly and controlled, or you can close it as fast as your system would allow, with fully open on your joystick valve. This could be handy in some situations. I've never felt the "need" for it, but I can see where it would be nice, and I may even use this type on the next tractor I buy. The 3rd function valve is one speed, and can only be adjusted with a flow restrictor (permanently).
As an added bonus, it is slightly cheaper than option 1, and may even be easier to install??? It's really personal preference. :thumbsup:

I purchased a WR Long kit, which came with everything I needed, including directions, and mounts specific to my tractor model. I recommend WR Long if you want to do it the "easiest" way. You can purchase parts separately and make up your own brackets and mounts for cheaper, but not as simple. Valve Kits I'm sure there are many others but this is the only "kit" I have experience with.



Do you have a manual for your tractor? From what I found, it was made between 1984-1987, and is an open center hydraulic system like most of ours, so adding the hydraulics would be pretty straight forward and not too expensive (I think my kit cost right around $700 give or take 50) (relative to a closed center system, although I don't have a good grasp on closed center systems).

It appears your loader has a 2,800lb lift capacity, and a WHOPPING 21.5gpm hydraulic flow??? :eek: If I'm reading that correctly, that is a LOT compared to almost all our tractors on here! You could probably even run low flow skidsteer implements off your FEL! Most of ours are somewhere between 8-12 with the utility tractors closer to 14-16gpm. I don't know if the 3rd function valve that I linked to, can accommodate that much flow? I seem to remember it being somewhere near 10gpm max. I imagine in this case you would certainly want a selector valve, as full flow to the grapple cylinder would slam it shut before you could even let off the button! :laughing:

With 2,800lb lift capacity (if you have the loader referenced in the below sales brochure) you shouldn't have a problem with bending/breaking a standard grapple. I wouldn't go with a light duty one like I have, but you don't need a monster that would take the abuse of 5k lb+ lift capacity either (or the associated cost to go along with it).

This may be a little too much information and make for a boring post to read, but I think a lot of people can benefit from the "basics" sometimes. I apologize if you already know all this info and had to read through my nonsense without learning anything you didn't already know. :D

Is this the tractor you have in the pics below? (I hope so, or forget everything I just said:laughing:)
1.JPG 2.JPG 3.JPG
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #34  
Did you see these guys already? Forget.. In your area..

Grapple Rake
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #35  
It completely slipped my mind that a member here can probably set you up with one of his kits. He wasn't doing valve kits when I ordered my Top N Tilt from him or I would have gone through him. He may be an excellent source for information on what you would need.
Brian is very helpful and talk about customer service, he's one of the best I've dealt with. If you've read any of my posts regarding the Top N Tilt kit you would see how happy I am with everything.

http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/members/mtnviewranch.html
His company name is FitRite Hydraulics

I'm sure anyone on here who has dealt with him would be more than happy to recommend him, not just me. :thumbsup:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??
  • Thread Starter
#36  
WJB,
Regarding the heavy duty SS adapter for your loader, you might want to try to get in touch with Eddiewalker. He went through essentially the same thing you are trying to do, and might have some helpful tips/insight. You can read his thread on adding a grapple to his Ford/NH 555E here: Grapple for 555E There are some good pics in that thread as well..

Thanks, I will read Eddie's thread after completing this post.

Regarding the hydraulics required to operate the thumb, it really shouldn't be too difficult to do, with a little patience. There are three ways to do this, but the general consensus on here, is that 2 of the 3 ways really are "best".
Note: Skip over the next 3 paragraphs to avoid falling asleep...

Wow! Great information . . . I like some of the features of the "selector valve" and may go that way if not too complicated; my decision may be dictated by the high hydraulic flow rate the 340B has.

Do you have a manual for your tractor? From what I found, it was made between 1984-1987, and is an open center hydraulic system like most of ours, so adding the hydraulics would be pretty straight forward and not too expensive . . .

Yes, I have the manual for my tractor, although I use TractorData for quick reference on the specs. The serial number of my tractor shows it to be a 1985 model.

It appears your loader has a 2,800lb lift capacity, and a WHOPPING 21.5gpm hydraulic flow??? :eek:

Yes, 2,800 lb. is confirmed in my manual and by TractorData. Only for my general knowledge, what is the normal lift capacity of compact and newer utility tractors?

This may be a little too much information and make for a boring post to read, but I think a lot of people can benefit from the "basics" sometimes. I apologize if you already know all this info and had to read through my nonsense without learning anything you didn't already know. :D

You know what they say, "Knowledge is power!" Seriously, thanks for taking the time to explain what I need to know about grapple hydraulics.:thumbsup:
Is this the tractor you have in the pics below? (I hope so, or forget everything I just said:laughing:)
View attachment 321484 View attachment 321485 View attachment 321486

Yes. It is my understanding that I have the factory installed model 745 loader.


I saw this grapple but do not think it would be heavy enough for my loader. Thanks.

Did you see these guys already? Forget.. In your area..

Grapple Rake

Yes, I am interested in this grapple and have emailed CID Attachments requesting more information. They are one of the five(?) grapple fabricators in the Denton area. Is Denton, NC the "Grapple Capital of the USA?" :)

It completely slipped my mind that a member here can probably set you up with one of his kits. He wasn't doing valve kits when I ordered my Top N Tilt from him or I would have gone through him. He may be an excellent source for information on what you would need.
Brian is very helpful and talk about customer service, he's one of the best I've dealt with. If you've read any of my posts regarding the Top N Tilt kit you would see how happy I am with everything.

I will read this thread and thanks for the additional resource. I will first have rest my eyes (and brain) after consuming so much information!:laughing:

Many, many thanks to all who have provided information and advice for this project. I am certain others will benefit from this thread!:thumbsup:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??
  • Thread Starter
#37  
Decision Made!!

Okay - here goes! I finally made a decision on which grapple and SS conversion unit to buy!:cool2:

After reading all the recommendations and studying the specs I am going to order the Unlimited Fabrication Heavy Duty Root Grapple and their Skid Steer Conversion.

After talking with the owner, Roger, of Unlimited Fabrication this afternoon I am confident that their product is the best for my needs. In addition to the features noted on their web site, their grapples are powder coated in your choice of black, dark gray, JD green, Cat yellow and orange.

Now, on to working out the hydraulics.:confused:
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #38  
Okay - here goes! I finally made a decision on which grapple and SS conversion unit to buy!:cool2:

After reading all the recommendations and studying the specs I am going to order the Unlimited Fabrication Heavy Duty Root Grapple and their Skid Steer Conversion.

After talking with the owner, Roger, of Unlimited Fabrication this afternoon I am confident that their product is the best for my needs. In addition to the features noted on their web site, their grapples are powder coated in your choice of black, dark gray, JD green, Cat yellow and orange.

Now, on to working out the hydraulics.:confused:

WAHOOOOOOO!

Way to go Barry! I think you'll find that the hydraulics are a lot more intimidating than they need to be. Once you dive in a little more it will all start to make sense. By all means keep asking questions after you get some more reading in...your certainly not the only one learning from this thread!

Can you share some specs on the grapple and skid steer quick attach plate?
Do you have a link to which ones your purchasing?

I'm curious about the weight of the grapple, what size loader capacity it's rated for, and the same info for the skid steer quick attach plate. I'm mainly interested because I'm curious if the setup your purchasing would work on my backhoe/loader.

Thanks for keeping us posted.
-Matt
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader??
  • Thread Starter
#39  
Can you share some specs on the grapple and skid steer quick attach plate?
Do you have a link to which ones your purchasing?

I'm curious about the weight of the grapple, what size loader capacity it's rated for, and the same info for the skid steer quick attach plate. I'm mainly interested because I'm curious if the setup your purchasing would work on my backhoe/loader.

Thanks for keeping us posted.
-Matt

Ultimate Fab 72" HD Root Grapple

  • Cylinders-2" bore and a 10" stroke
  • Opening - 36" H x 38" D
  • Steel - 1/2" Grade 50, 3" square tubing, 3" pipe
  • Line routing - Enclosed
  • Weight - 750 lb.
  • Tooth spacing - 9"
  • Recessed grease fittings -
  • Option - Cylinder rod covers
  • Colors - Black, dk. gray, JD green, Cat yellow, orange
  • If I recall correctly, this grapple is rated for 40 hp - 55 or 60 hp. That info is not published on the web site, but I asked him and failed to make note of it.:ashamed:
  • Price - $1769.00

Skid Steer Conversion - No specs stated, will take about three weeks to fabricate. This one is about $225.00 less than a similar unit offered by another nearby fabricator.

BTW, I contacted Brian at Fit Rite Hydraulics and he has two diverter valve kits. That conversation is in this thread: Has anyone used Unlimited Fabrications?

Hope this helps!
 
   / Quick Attach and Grapple for Industrial Tractor\Loader?? #40  
Cool! :thumbsup:

I found a 55" one locally for $250.. little beat up and rusty, and might be a little on the light side and I will need to beef it up some, but for only $250... well.... It does have a newer cylinder :thumbsup:

Post what you do for the hydraulics.. I'm finding my controls really cramped with the power beyond blocked by bracing. The return is part of the loader frame as well meaning its not gonna be easy to move them or buy a generic 3 spool valve.
 
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

1996 FORD F-SERIES FLATBED TRUCK (A52706)
1996 FORD F-SERIES...
Tafe 45DI (A60462)
Tafe 45DI (A60462)
UNUSED FUTURE FT-RR78 - 78" HYD ROCK RAKE (A52706)
UNUSED FUTURE...
2013 Godwin Dri-Prime CD103M Towable Trash Pump (A59228)
2013 Godwin...
2015 Chevrolet Tahoe, 192,897 Miles, Decommissioned Law Enforcement Vehicle (A56438)
2015 Chevrolet...
2007 Ford F-150 4x4 Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A59230)
2007 Ford F-150...
 
Top