s219
Super Member
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2011
- Messages
- 8,548
- Location
- Virginia USA
- Tractor
- Kubota L3200, Deere X380, Kubota RTV-X
Not so much ironic as consistent design. Everybody knows how the levers work. And by knows I mean knows without thinking about it. There have been a handful of incidents & deaths from people being killed or injured due to fancy but unintuitive new shifter designs. New might be better, but it can also be just plain confusing.
That is a good point and I remember some of those incidents.
My wife's Honda Pilot (which we traded in) had a push button shifter and neither one of us liked it. Too easy to hit a button down on the console when you didn't mean to. It would ignore most of the inputs when moving at speed, except there were quite a few times it got toggled into sport mode or snow mode unintentionally.
One time when backing out of the garage at idle, our dog brushed the buttons with her paw and I went from low-speed reverse to low-speed forward in a blink. That confused my brain and eyeballs (looking in the mirrors) until I realized what happened. Could have damaged the garage door or house if the timing was just a little bit different or my reaction was slower.
While I never saw the point of those buttons, I think they would have been a lot better if they were moved to the dashboard instead of the console. A lever with detents works down on the console, big flat buttons don't (nor do they need to be there).
BMW has done a pretty good job with their shifter, which still looks like a lever but is just a big switch. It works well and does things a traditional shifter could not. However it is not intuitive at all. You have to learn how to use it and most new BMW drivers can't figure it out without some instructions. I'd call that a failure overall.
I feel thankful to still have a car with manual transmission. Before long those will go away. Very few sports cars still come with manual transmission these days, I bet it's down to less than 10-12 cars at this point, at least mass market. Camaro, Mustang, Miata, 380Z, 2-3 BMW M models, Subaru WRX and STi, .... ??