Pick WinterDeere's next truck

/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #41  
Lots of talk about eight speed and 10 speed autos, as if I don't already own three (yes.: three!) ZF8’s. They are indeed great transmissions, but I still hate driving auto, especially on snow or ice.

I'll buy auto if it's the only option, my current half ton has a ZF8. But if manual is an option, I will almost always ignore almost every other pro/con, and choose the manual over anything with auto.

And I've also owned diesels, and have zero interest in ever owning another. Slow, slow, slow. I'm not putting enough miles on this vehicle, or hauling anything heavy enough frequently enough, to ever see any advantage to diesel. Also, half our stations around here don't even carry diesel, what a stupid hassle to sign yourself up for that, if you're not hauling heavy trailers everyday.

If I could design my own truck, it would be a 1/2 ton 4x4 with beefed up rear suspension, 6.4L Hemi, manual transmission, and 4:1 diff's. But no one is making that! :ROFLMAO:
Auto trans is the only option these days on NEW. None of the makers offer a 1/2 ton or HD truck with a manual.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck
  • Thread Starter
#42  
Good responses! I'll try to hit the main points of contention or interest...

Newer gas V8 engines are posting similar stats as diesel engines available in the same vehicle. The Ford Godzilla V8 is a work engine designed for Ford trucks all the way up to the F550.
Exactly. And especially one who's traveling unladened more often than loaded, and never seeing more than a 7k# trailer, the gasser is always going to win out on 1) performance, 2) convenience, and 3) cost.

I've had my stock Chevy K1500 in several parking garages with 7' limits; kinda makes me nervous but never scraped the roof yet. All parking garages have a height bar prior to the entrance anyway.
Philly is a very old city, and has a very large fraction of old garges with 6' 0" to 6' 6" max clearance. The two worst are PHL airport and CHOP, both of which I've hit my 1500 roof in. CHOP is labeled higher than it really is, with a roof clearance test pipe that must be hung 4" higher than the signage inside the garage.

PHL is actually marked at the right height, I hit my roof on the pipe that told me I was too tall. But it's a "no abort" situation, once you do hit your roof on their "if you hit this you're too tall" pipe. You can't back out, must only go forward, already knowing you're too tall. :rolleyes: I think the garage was originally laid out to allow too-tall vehicles to exit striaght thru the first floor, no problem, but the traffic pattern was subsequently changed to eliminate that abort path. Only airport service trucks are allowed to use that path, now.

Then you are SOL, right?
re: manual... yes, I probably am! It seemed they kept the Richmond 6sp manual option on the HD trucks longer than the 1/2 tons, but now even those are gone.


Even high-outputs?
I would think you’d get crushed by any of the high outputs.
For you, pulling your heavy trailers, yes... diesel wins. But not for the guy driving the thing unladened most of the time, or with much lighter trailers.

I pull 1500# trailers every weekend, and I barely even feel them behind my 400hp/400ft-lb gasser. When I hook on my 7k# trailer, I obviously know it's there, but I still have plenty of power for as fast as I want to go with that thing.

If stepping up from 6500 lb. 1/2 ton to 8500 lb. 3/4 ton, I'd want an increase in horsepower and torque commensurate with that increase in weight, to maintain similar unladened performance. But I don't see much use in having 1600 ft-lb of torque from an HO diesel, for what I'm doing.

I realize that, I'm curios about how the steel frame holds up to the salt for those who don't always rinse it off.
I've never had a frame rust out on any pickup, it's only ever the body that fails. Frames are much thicker, coated on all sides, exposed to air that dries them out quickly after bad weather... all factors that make them much less susceptible to the rust that eats holes in the body after 10 - 12 years.

A lot of poeple swear by spraying product under the truck, but I don't think that would help at all, for the type of rust I see. The rust that eats my trucks always starts inside of doors, inside of tailgate, or between the walls of the bed. Nothing sprayed under the truck would ever reach any of these areas.

I grew to really hate the Ford trucks in the early 2000's, and wasn't very impressed with the interior of a friend's ca.2018 F150 (backup cam screen was quality and size of a ca.1993 graphing calculator :ROFLMAO:), but I'll admit the aluminum body is probably what I should be considering first.

Bronco has a 7 spd manual, no clue what the tow rating is or engine options are.
Listening...

I had a 1978 Bronco, which was basically an F150 with a bed-integrated cab. F150 and Bronco shared nearly everything in 1978 and 1979. I used to tow a lot with that vehicle, but would not want to tow an 88" wide trailer with any modern/narrowbody Bronco, due to visibility alone.

Let’s get technical for a second. The Bronco’s manual is a seven-speed Getrag MTI550, and it’s paired exclusively with the 2.3-liter EcoBoost turbocharged four-cylinder. That’s 300 horsepower and 325 lb-ft of torque on premium fuel — plenty of grunt to make a stick shift fun again.
Lovin the manual transmission option, but that's pretty low on horsepower and torque, a huge step down from the 400/410 I'm driving today.

I have to smile when I see people talking about "wimpy" 6 cylinder engines.

You know if you buy an F150 with the max tow package you'll be getting the 3.5 Ecoboost V6? It puts out much more torque than the 5.0 V8, and it does it at a lower rpm.
Yeah... I know the 3.5L EcoBoost is a good option. I have a budy who traded his old Ford 351 cid v8 for a 3.5 EcoBoost, and can't say enough good stuff about it, pulling his 13k# camper trailer all over the country.

Likewise with the Hurricane, assuming it proves as reliable in HO configurations.

But if looking at F250's, the standard engine is a 6.8L V8, and I can upgrade that to a 7.3L for a mere $1500. You just know that's what I would be buying, if I went Ford. "Go big or go home," has always been my guiding principle, sometimes to my own detriment. :D

But again, if you want extended cab only Ford makes one.
Sorry, I was using "extended" in the most generic term... anything with a back seat. Having owned every combination of extended, quad, and crew cabs, I see the pros and cons in each, and will probably end up waffling on this decision awhile. I know I could get everything if I stepped up to the 160" wheelbase, but damn... that's awful tough for getting around tight city parking, etc.

My current truck is 150" wheelbase, with Crew Cab and shortie (5.6 ft.) bed, and that suits me really well about 364 days out of every year. For the odd time it doesn't, I just settle for hooking up my 16' landscape trailer, and hauling long stuff in that. A 6.6 ft or even 8 ft bed would be great, but not at the expense of giving up cab space or having to park a 175" wheelbase truck the rest of the year.

I frequently use my back seat space for cargo, hauling boxes of parts to/from vendors and customers, it's not just about making passengers comfortable. For this, the Crew Cab has been ideal, but I could make Quad Cab work if needed.

Godzilla puts out 485 lb-ft of torque at 4000 rpm. The diesel puts out 1200 lb-ft of torque at 1600 rpm, and is rated to tow nearly twice as much as the gas engine. PLUS it has an engine brake so you're not riding the brakes on the way back down the hill.
Only matters to those pulling heavy trailers. Both are 500 hp and both will deliver a similar unladened or lightly-loaded experience, but the gasser will do it for $12k less, and minus the headache of finding gas stations that carry diesel. The diesel will win when towing Hay Dude's hay wagon, but I'm not that guy.

I have a Eaton twin stick 5 and 4 transmission ready for you! If your interested, out of my log truck. Only 1,500 miles on it after a rebuild. LOL!!!
There was a time in my life when I'd have actually considered this, Dean. :ROFLMAO: But I don't have that sort of free time, anymore!

However, the optional diesel engine is $10K, the HO version is over $12K.
source: The Main Differences Between Ford's 7.3 Gas & 6.7 Diesel Engines - SlashGear
Exactly. And that's what several here seem to be ignoring. Why would anyone recommend a $12k option to someone who would derive zero benefit from it?
 
Last edited:
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #43  
Look out west for a decent low mile used. CA gas prices have to be having folks leaving or trading down for better mileage. Not sure how far back you have to go to get a manual tranny (my last was early 90's). Lots of CA pickups are suburban toys or weekend Home Depot runs are extent of the use.
 
Last edited:
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #44  
Last edited:
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck
  • Thread Starter
#45  
Look out west for a decent low mile used. CA gas prices have to be having folks leaving or trading down for better mileage. Not sure how far back you have to go to get a manual tranny (my last was early 90's).
My 2005 Ram was manual. Dodge kept offering manual on the HD's up thru 2019, or thereabouts... but I don't think there are many out there for sale in good condition.

Unless he wants to put up with all the down time his truck will spend getting recall after recall fixed.
Yeah, I've seen a few such threads, and that'd be a real shame. But there's also one recent similar thread about a Ram 2500 on this forum, if I recall. Are any of them really that much worse/better than the other, across the board?
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #46  
What about looking in a different place? As in another country where they sell them, and import. Yes, shipping, emissions, highway safety etc. that will most likely need to be brought to standards. But think about it, you most likely can get what you want. just sayin'
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #47  
If I were to buy a new truck, and I'm considering it now, I'd want this...F250 4x4 work truck, especially no carpet. 6.8L gas.
A truck...nothing more
20260327_182939809.jpg
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #48  
I have an old SUV that I beat around in when the roads are bad. Otherwise we seem to treat our trucks pretty similar. Very low miles and not daily drivers.

My F150 is about as comfy as a Cadillac. Plenty of power and guts with the twin turbo eco boost engine. Crew cab is just awesome for hauling stuff and keeping things dry and locked up. Short bed is adequate for my needs 95% of the time. I picked up a cheap bed extender the other day. That lets me haul 12’ material (within reason) without hitching a trailer. Best of all is the turn radius and how nimble it feels compared to past longer trucks.

Towing is surprising when you consider the engine displacement. Pulls dump trailer, equipment trailer, hay wagons, enclosed 16’ trailer with ease and offers engine brake, integral brake controller, even trailer backing gadgets in case a blind person needs to reverse with a trailer. Pulled a loaded 16’ enclosed trailer from Florida and it was smooth and impressive.

Get at least the Lariat trim. I thought massage seats were a gimmick till I finally tried them on a long drive. Realized that I’m not getting younger. Nice!

I have a 2020 King Ranch with all the options with 21,000 miles on it. When you keep a truck for 10 years or so, you’re really impacted by how much things change and how many new gadgets are available. Glad it has the aluminum body and should age well cause I’m not going to wear it out.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #49  
If I were to buy a new truck, and I'm considering it now, I'd want this...F250 4x4 work truck, especially no carpet. 6.8L gas.
A truck...nothing moreView attachment 5336841
Man that’s crazy! 50K (plus tax) for a stripped reg cab 3/4 ton gasser….
Makes the $74K for the loaded crew cab diesel I was looking at seem cheap (and they would sell for considerably less than 74K sticker).
Ford gets a premium for their trucks, and they have less warranty.

The 250/350’s are steel right? Or are they aluminum now, too?
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #50  
The dealer we've dealt with a lot. I looked at one like that in the low $40Ks.
The F150 I have now has 300-six, 4x4, '93 with 206K miles has been great...just bolt on stuff, water pump, alt., brakes but nothing major.
Biggest thing I'd tow would be a 2 horse trailer, so the F250 would work.
I much prefer no carpet, vinyl bench, manual. Wish I could get no radio or screen. AC is OK.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #51  
My 2005 Ram was manual. Dodge kept offering manual on the HD's up thru 2019, or thereabouts... but I don't think there are many out there for sale in good condition.


Yeah, I've seen a few such threads, and that'd be a real shame. But there's also one recent similar thread about a Ram 2500 on this forum, if I recall. Are any of them really that much worse/better than the other, across the board?
I have a 24' RAM 2500 w/ the Cummins. So far I really like the truck. I was a Ford guy but kept having issues with them. Tried Chevy for a brief time and then decided to look at RAM. As soon as I test drove it, I knew I was I buying it. Are they without issues? No, but I think it's the better choice out there right now.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #52  
I much prefer no carpet, vinyl bench, manual. Wish I could get no radio or screen. AC is OK.

LOL. Hard to find a buckboard wagon stripped down that bare these days.

No carpet is easy -- you just use the all-weather floor mats. Pretty much everyone does.

Does anyone still do vinyl? If you don't get leather, then it's usually a "pleather" or performance fabric material. I do like the "cloth" seats in modern cars. Very tough and comfy and wears well.

Bench seat? Yikes! No arm rest?? No console to stash stuff and hold drinks and manage a shifter and buttons and . . . .

Manual -- I get it. Some still like it. Apparently not enough for anyone to offer one.

You are hardcore, Fuddy!

Edit -- forgot to add -- Standard Cab???? Could never go back to a standard cab where you can barely shove a windbreaker behind the seat. A full crew cab is SO much more utilitarian and versatile.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #53  
LOL. Hard to find a buckboard wagon stripped down that bare these days.

No carpet is easy -- you just use the all-weather floor mats. Pretty much everyone does.

Does anyone still do vinyl? If you don't get leather, then it's usually a "pleather" or performance fabric material. I do like the "cloth" seats in modern cars. Very tough and comfy and wears well.

Bench seat? Yikes! No arm rest?? No console to stash stuff and hold drinks and manage a shifter and buttons and . . . .

Manual -- I get it. Some still like it. Apparently not enough for anyone to offer one.

You are hardcore, Fuddy!

Edit -- forgot to add -- Standard Cab???? Could never go back to a standard cab where you can barely shove a windbreaker behind the seat. A full crew cab is SO much more utilitarian and versatile.

Loaded trucks cost thousands more up front, but make the day so much more pleasant through the years of ownership. Then when it comes time to get a new one, loaded trucks are much easier to sell.
Only bad thing is I get pretty dirty at work and you feel guilty getting the interior messed up lol
One of my buddies was reminding me that my truck smells like a chainsaw and B.O.
 
Last edited:
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #55  
Loaded trucks cost thousands more up front, but make the day so much more pleasant through the years of ownership. Then when it comes time to get a new one, loaded trucks are much easier to sell.
Only bad thing is I get pretty dirty at work and you feel guilty getting the interior messed up lol

Definitely! We're off-topic, but that does happen sometimes on here . . .

I don't think you lose anything by going for at least the middle trim levels. And there's no financial reason not to get all the new options / features that are coming standard on other vehicles. I've been driving an old Ford SUV with 200K on it as my daily for 9 years. I like it and don't worry about throwing the dogs in the back. But I'm getting kinda spoiled and now I don't think I'd buy anything without Adaptive Cruise, Heads-up Display, Lane Keep Assist or ADA, and all the other bells anymore. Self-parking and Hands-Free are the "fringe" options these days. (Self parking is really slick, in case you haven't tried it.) We've recently bought two cars and it's amazing how much the technology has advanced. I won't spend much on cosmetic stuff, but I do appreciate comfort and functionality.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #56  
Definitely! We're off-topic, but that does happen sometimes on here . . .

I don't think you lose anything by going for at least the middle trim levels. And there's no financial reason not to get all the new options / features that are coming standard on other vehicles. I've been driving an old Ford SUV with 200K on it as my daily for 9 years. I like it and don't worry about throwing the dogs in the back. But I'm getting kinda spoiled and now I don't think I'd buy anything without Adaptive Cruise, Heads-up Display, Lane Keep Assist or ADA, and all the other bells anymore. Self-parking and Hands-Free are the "fringe" options these days. (Self parking is really slick, in case you haven't tried it.) We've recently bought two cars and it's amazing how much the technology has advanced. I won't spend much on cosmetic stuff, but I do appreciate comfort and functionality.
We have an X-5 with all that stuff. Adaptive cruise, self parking, lane dep warning, massaging seats, etc.

One feature my Ram needs that it doesn’t have was power folding mirrors for all the branches hanging into our back roads.

I would suggest that upgrade for anyone buying a new truck with towing mirrors.
 
Last edited:
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #57  
If I were to buy a new truck, and I'm considering it now, I'd want this...F250 4x4 work truck, especially no carpet. 6.8L gas.
A truck...nothing moreView attachment 5336841
I have a 2015 F350 that is showing a lot of rust in the bed. I have been looking at the same standard cab 350 with 6.8 or 7.3 and 4.30 gears. Been driving Powerstrokes/Cummins since they came out, but with all this emissions crap and the $11k upcharge, it's a fairly hard pill to swallow. And finding one with 17" wheels to keep the bed low. I have used a 6.2L F250 grossed over 45,000 hauling hay and wagons, always ran out of traction before the engine.
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #58  
In 1992 I ordered a '93 Chevy 1/2T, 8' with no carpet, vinyl bench, 4 speed 350 V8. Day 1 I removed catalytic converter putting in a "test pipe" it was called. It was stripped except AC.
First inspection I'm at the dealer, look out and there's this 80s farmer in bib overalls sitting in it. He wanted it and a few years later I had kept it like new and went to trade it in (I shouldn't have). That guy shows up buying it with cash.
20260327_212015.jpg
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #59  
In 1992 I ordered a '93 Chevy 1/2T, 8' with no carpet, vinyl bench, 4 speed 350 V8. Day 1 I removed catalytic converter putting in a "test pipe" it was called. It was stripped except AC.
First inspection I'm at the dealer, look out and there's this 80s farmer in bib overalls sitting in it. He wanted it and a few years later I had kept it like new and went to trade it in (I shouldn't have). That guy shows up buying it with cash.

Funny how fast things change.

I had a '92 Chevy Silverado Extended Cab, medium bed, cloth seats, automatic, 350 V8 that I bought used in '93. Prior owner was the KY Secretary of Agriculture. At that time, it was considered a "Country Cadillac." Extended cab pickups were a recent thing.

It was a good old truck and served well to haul stuff and pull some boats around, etc. But there's just no comparison to those 35 year old trucks and today's vehicles. We've come a long way, Baby!
 
/ Pick WinterDeere's next truck #60  
OP, is a used pickup to your spec from the South West desert states a realistic option?
 

Marketplace Items

2009 IC Corporation PB105 School Bus (A64194)
2009 IC...
GOOSENECK SPOOL TRAILER (A65643)
GOOSENECK SPOOL...
2007 BIG TEX 16 T/A UTILITY TRAILER (A65643)
2007 BIG TEX 16...
New/Unused Wolverine Sickle Bar Mower (A65583)
New/Unused...
2007 Load - Max Loadmaster Gooseneck Trailer (A66285)
2007 Load - Max...
Landhonor Livestock Chute w/ Scale (A66408)
Landhonor...
 
Top