Buying Advice Small CUT or large SCUT Advice

/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #1  

Olympus

Platinum Member
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
763
Location
Cape Girardeau, MO
Tractor
LS R3039
I just sold my JD 750 and I'm on the market for a replacement. I need a loader, hydro tranny, and independent PTO. I have a max budget of $13,500 for the tractor. I'm okay with coming up with sales tax if necessary.

I have about 4 acres of woods that I keep mowed down. I did all the heavy work of cleaning it out already so it's nice and open. I brush hog the weeds about once a month. Nothing heavy duty anyone. I also have a long gravel driveway that's uphill that I have to grade frequently. It's chat rock, so it doesn't pack well and turns into a washboard easily. But that's the extent of my daily work for a tractor. We occasionally cut down small trees and a loader would be used to push brush piles together for burning.

I know a SCUT would probably be sufficient for my needs, but I really don't want one. Compared to my 750, they just feel and look like beefy lawn mower. I'm talking about the Kubota BX models, JD 1026 models, Massey GC models, etc. I want something that's a little heavier duty if possible on the off chance that I expand to more acreage. I can't afford to be trading tractors every 5 to 8 years. I need something I can grow into if necessary.

I need some suggestions on models in the 23 to 30hp range that can be bought for $13,500 max, preferably less. If I'm spending my max budget, I want maximum HP and a larger tractor size. Right now, my top contender is the 2014 LS tractor J2023. It's bigger than other SCUTs, a lot bigger hydro pump, 1270lbs of loader capacity, 5 year warranty, for $12,200. Dollar for dollar, I've yet to find anything that has the same for better specs within $1000 of that price.

I live in ag country so there are all kinds of dealers close to me. JD, Case, Massey, New Holland, Kubota, Kioti, LS, Mahindra just off the top of my head. I really want to have an idea of what models I should be asking about and what ballpark prices are before I start shopping with dealers. I typically hate interacting with salesmen, so the more I know ahead of time, the better.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #2  
Well, the next size up from BX in the Kubota lineup is the B-series, and they run small (2320), med (2620,2920), and large (3200/3300). Equivalent Deeres are the 2-series. But with front loader and HST, you will be beyond $13.5K with Deere and Kubota for sure -- more like $14-16K at least. Am not up to speed on the other brands, but I would definitely shop them myself. It will be hard to beat LS on price/value.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #3  
I haven't spent a lot of time researching SCUT prices, but I think you're going to have to work to find anything (new) less expensive that will match the performance of the J2023H without going to a Chinese tractor like a Photon or Jinma.

You may want to look into pricing on a TYM T223HST...same size/power ballpark.

The big knock I have with the smallest SCUTs is the 2-range HST. In many ways, they could use a third range more than the bigger machines (you can get away with lugging bigger engines) but that would increase the cost.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #4  
Im not very familiar with the LS tractors but both the J series and G series look like great tractors and good value. I like the quick attach loader capability for growing into additional needs. You've got some good brands near you. Im signing up to read the discussions and learn some.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I'm leary of the Chinese tractors. Rather not go that route.

I'm not opposed to buying used if I can get a bigger tractor for that budget that's not been abused.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #6  
OP sounds pretty knowledgeable. But, there just isn't much at that budget available in CUTS. Might look at Kioti CK2510, Mahindra MAX, or a BC CT225. Maybe a TYM T293. They might all exceed your budget by a few dollars though.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #7  
Its hard to find used thats low hours. I lucked out big time and found my B2620 with about 110 hours, and that was almost exclusively mowing. But if you have the time to wait a few months like I did you might find one. But you already sold your 750. Try search tempest for Craigslist and check it for for a few weeks maybe?
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#8  
OP sounds pretty knowledgeable. But, there just isn't much at that budget available in CUTS. Might look at Kioti CK2510, Mahindra MAX, or a BC CT225. Maybe a TYM T293. They might all exceed your budget by a few dollars though.

The Max 25 is out for me. A lot more expensive than the LS, same approximate size, less loader capacity, and smaller hydro pump.

The Kioti CK20 is also similar size to the LS.

I did find a local dealer who has a few of the Bobcat 225 models from 2012. He wants $14,000 for them. Now they are a true CUT size. Bigger than the J2023, Kioti CK20, and Max 25. I'm just concerned about the possibility of lack of service since Bobcat stopped producing tractors.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Its hard to find used thats low hours. I lucked out big time and found my B2620 with about 110 hours, and that was almost exclusively mowing. But if you have the time to wait a few months like I did you might find one. But you already sold your 750. Try search tempest for Craigslist and check it for for a few weeks maybe?

I'm looking daily. There is a nice JD 3023 with loader, HST, and 250 hours for $13,500. It's a long drive away though. That model is a lot bigger than the other models I've been looking at. Definitely could grow into it. I just can't decide if I should spend my max budget on something used thats bigger or spend the same on something smaller but has warranty.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #10  
Not having warranty is a concern but one that I let go off for the savings I got. Plus no sales tax. I rolled the diced on warranty based on Kubotas reputation. Others may have ideas on LS's quality reputation and the idea of foregoing warranty.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#11  
I agree. If I could find used that was not my max budget, I would definitely lean that way. Especially if it was a JD or Kubota. I just haven't found one yet. The LS would be $12,600 after tax.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #12  
LS' quality is fantastic... And the J2023 might be enough for you. I had a CK20 HST before, and I worked it hard. It did a great job, but I mainly used it as a little loader tractor and only used the PTO fir post holes; do a YouTube search for "digging a pond with Kioti Ck20" & you'll see what I did with it.

Knowing how tough that tractor was, pound for pound, and being that the J2023 has more HP, hydraulic flow, and lift ... it makes me think that little J2023 will do fine.

I don't know how much "growing into it" you'll duo tho, alot of the things you'll do well be limited by the tractors wheelbase & weight, just depends on what you're doing with it.

Good luck!
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#13  
LS' quality is fantastic... And the J2023 might be enough for you. I had a CK20 HST before, and I worked it hard. It did a great job, but I mainly used it as a little loader tractor and only used the PTO fir post holes; do a YouTube search for "digging a pond with Kioti Ck20" & you'll see what I did with it.

Knowing how tough that tractor was, pound for pound, and being that the J2023 has more HP, hydraulic flow, and lift ... it makes me think that little J2023 will do fine.

I don't know how much "growing into it" you'll duo tho, alot of the things you'll do well be limited by the tractors wheelbase & weight, just depends on what you're doing with it.

Good luck!

I watched that video several weeks ago. Nice to meet you so to speak. That was a great video. I couldn't believe how much work you did with that little tractor. Very impressive.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #14  
I watched that video several weeks ago. Nice to meet you so to speak. That was a great video. I couldn't believe how much work you did with that little tractor. Very impressive.
Thanks. Wow, I just checked that vid, it's up to over 43000 views! Hopefully it helped some folks get an idea on tractor sizing & capabilities.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #15  
That CK was one tough SOB.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#16  
Does anyone know if the CT225 has rear remotes? It might be worth the additional cost to have a remote or two. I would like to have a tilt/angle blade.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #17  
You do know that the Bobcats are white Kioti's?I wouldn't worry about parts for a Bobcat.That sounds like a decent price for a brand new tractor.We just paid $9500 for a 11 year old Kubota.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#18  
Yes, I know that. Not worried about parts. Just curious if the CT225 has a rear remote.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice
  • Thread Starter
#19  
Man, that Bobcat CT225 is looking enticing. I see where there are a lot of options for cab enclosures for that tractor. After this winter, that would have been awesome to have. I may have to go take a look at them. It's outside my budget, but maybe the dealer will come down considering they are already 2 years old.
 
/ Small CUT or large SCUT Advice #20  
I don't think the CT225 comes standard with remotes. Could be wrong; maybe BC includes them. Why not call and ask? I think I paid like $400 for one set with my Kioti at time of purchase, in a package deal. I love having the remotes. Wish I had a second one for tilt.
 

Marketplace Items

John Deere 6140R Tractor (A64047)
John Deere 6140R...
2020 INTERNATIONAL MV607 26 FT BOX TRUCK (A59905)
2020 INTERNATIONAL...
Hydraulic Breaker Excavator Attachment (A59228)
Hydraulic Breaker...
UNUSED WOLVERINE QC5-26-2DG QUICK ATTACH (A62131)
UNUSED WOLVERINE...
(INOP) BROCE BW260 SWEEPER (A62129)
(INOP) BROCE BW260...
KUBOTA BX23SLB-R-1 TRACTOR (A62130)
KUBOTA BX23SLB-R-1...
 
Top