recommendations on new air compressor, pancake Y or N ?

[tstex]

Great comments and thank you to everyone...I would have responded earlier but my email notifications stopped 2 days ago, ??

I am going to do some research and get back to you guys...really appreciate the experiences you have had and why you buy what you did, what has worked and what has not. W products today, nothing is made like it was 2-50 yrs ago. Yes, technology may be better today, but quality and parts availability sure is not. Therefore, I have resigned to the longevity factor and just want to get something that is as hassle free as possible and reliable..

Many thanks again !!

 

[repete]

You stated you fill many tires. Are any of them needing more than 100 PSI? If so, you may want to consider a two stage compressor. Frustration is when you have a single stage compressor and need to fill a tire to 120 psi.

 

[tstex]

You stated you fill many tires. Are any of them needing more than 100 PSI? If so, you may want to consider a two stage compressor. Frustration is when you have a single stage compressor and need to fill a tire to 120 psi.

Thanks pete - no, all of my tires max out at 50 or so psi...I have 2 tractors, 2 4 wheel trailers, multiple cars, 4 & 6 wheelers, riding lawn mowers, etc. It's a good thing chainsaws don't have tires, but I use my compressor often to clean/blow them free of oily-caked debris. I have few air-impact tools and a nail-gun and few more similar. All my work is at the ranch outside and noise is not a consideration.

 

[Rdrcr]

I like California Air. Super quiet and a good value.

Mike

 

[boatmoter]

Hello to all and Merry CHRISTmas,

My 15 gal and prob 20 yr old porter cable compressor is almost ready for the graveyard. Can you pls tell me what pancake compressor [one's they sell today] are the most reliable and versatile? I have a PC framing nail-gun that I use from time to time, do not have a paint spray gun...It's primary use will be for filling tires on tractors, trailers, 4 wheelers, hosing down dirty engines and things, etc. and filling a portable air tank. My usage frequencies varies but it seems like I am filing one or two of 20-30 diff sets of tires, so it's never idle for long periods. I mostly fill a portable air tank to go to the tire source(s).

I received an HD gift certificate so just in time.

Thank you in advance and pls let me know if you have any questions.

keep in mind that all oil less compressors are not continuous duty. if you want a compressor that will run and be used for long periods of time I would get a non-oil less pump

 

[jjp8182]

If you already have cordless tools, then checking to see if the manufacturer also has a cordless tire inflator (or compressor) could be an option worth looking into .... or if you're having to frequently fill tires a cordless tire inflator might be worth looking into anyway.

While I have a compressor and a portable air tank, after I picked up a Milwaukee M12 tire inflator I find myself going for that more than the portable air tank as it's much smaller & lighter than the air tank. Also have a lot more air with a single battery than is in a single fill of the air tank, so it's also lead to less "that tire isn't that low"

The same could likely be said of any of the other major cordless brand's tire inflators at this point as well (though I would probably consider the Milwaukee M18 or Makita XGT tire inflators for large volume or higher pressure tires -- though I'm already using other tools in those lines too).

May not be the cheapest option, nor a single solution for all your needs, but it's something to consider (especially if you're frequently having to fill/top-off tires).

Otherwise the cordless compressors may also be worth a look if you need more air in a portable form factor - probably wouldn't be enough for long periods of run time with most air tools, but they're marketed/intended for running pneumatic nailers/staplers.

 

[MESSMAKER]

I picked up this one at Home Depot, I like it. Very quiet, powerful and the price was right.

Husky 4.5 Gal. Portable Electric-Powered Silent Air Compressor 3320445 - The Home Depot

Do the work without the noise with the Husky 4.5 Gal. Portable Electric Air Compressor. This quiet compressor operates at less than 65 dBA, but delivers 3.0 SCFM at 90 PSI. Ideal for household inflation

www.homedepot.com

 

[Bentrim]

Personally I do not like oil less compressors. Noisy, slow and short duty cycle. although easy to replace the pump parts. Oil compressors are quieter, longer duty cycle and have a longer life.
I worked for a shop that repaired small engines including air compressors. Most air compressors were brought in for won't shut off. Yes they were oil less and some had been used commercially. Of course most needed the piston, cylinder, and valve plate replaced, and a few motors. The oil compressors usually were locked from lack of oil or a bad pressure switch. Just my 1 1/2 cents. (not adjusted for inflation)

 

[charlessenf]

" hosing down dirty engines and things,"

No idea what the CFM Required for that task might be, but for filling / toping off tires I use a Porter Cable Pancake Compressor that has to be pushing 40 years of (less frequent use than your tire demands)! Also have a similarly ancient Craftsman vertical tank thing and a cheap ($39?) HFT smaller pancake and a little LOWES Hot Dog (wheels!) I got for $99 or so a couple years back 'cause the Porter Cable, small as it is, was a pain to shift about the various places I was needing it.

I have an assortment of nail guns from teensy pin nailers to 3.5" Full Head Framing nailers, a 3/8" ratchet wrench, a pneumatic filer and a nibbler and a couple of automotive spray guns.

The smaller compressors work fine for the tires (one Tractor, one trailer, one car, one sm PU an ATV and a couple of utility wagons). I bought an air tank several years back and do not use it - which likely tells you something about the demands of the tires I'm responsible for.

I'd buy another PC Pancake again and same for that Craftsman and, though I've not had it a decade, I like the little LOWES Hot Dog. Even though the HFT's hanging in there, I wouldn't want it to be the only compressor I owned.

 

[sunandsand]

I'm in agreement with Bentrim (above). Biggest problem with oil-less is they don't seem to be designed to last very long or survive much more than casual, occasional use. I've had several on which the reed valve was broken or cracked so they wouldn't make or hold pressure, and there are no parts available, so the only thing left is the scrap heap.

Another problem on ALL compressors is that nobody (except us, of course) ever drains the water out of the tanks and they rust. You do not want to have a tank burst because of rust perforation - that's a *lot* more excitement than we bargained for.

So here's my spec list for the "ideal" compressor (YMMV). 1 - The compressor body should be cast iron and HAVE oil, that way it will last a long time. 2 - Aluminum tank - no corrosion and lighter so I can move it around fairly easily. 3) Minimum 25 gallons, better 40 gallons, I want the capacity. 4 - Vertical tank to save floor space. 5 - motor and compressor are separate units so can be replaced individually. 6 - 1,750 RPM - QUIET please. 7 - 110v so I can move it around in my hangar and not have miles of hose strung everywhere. 220 volts will be OK once an air distribution system is in so I won't have to move the compressor any more. Then it gets a small, removable enclosure with sound deadening material.

This will feed an air distribution system along one wall of my workshop. I was going to use black pipe, but I was in a big-bucks-cost-no-object boat manufacturer, and they used the aluminum (blue pipe) system that Summit, eBay, Amazon and others sell for about $300 or so. They're a billion dollar business (not an exaggeration) and if that system works for them, I strongly suspect it will work for me. (When I make my first billion, I'll have my compressor gold plated.)

Until I set that up, I'm using a 20 gallon Craftsman "has-oil" compressor connected to its 110v motor with a v-belt. I've owned it over 40 years, it just keeps soldiering along, with proper maintenance of course. I am starting to get a bit nervous about tank corrosion, so I stop it at 80psi which is adequate for everything I do.

That takes care of air-intensive jobs, working on cars, air drills, paint work (maybe, I have an HVLP system that doesn't use compressed air).

I also have a small, portable compressor that gets used to fill tires and on small jobs outside of the workshop.

Best regards and have a happy and safe new year!

Mike/Florida

 

[not2old]

Try this one.

Senco 1 Gal. 1/2 HP Portable Electric Air Compressor PC1010 - The Home Depot

Finish your home and auto projects faster and easier by possessing this lightweight and portable Senco Portable Electric Air Compressor.

www.homedepot.com

I have a decent sized compressor in my shop, but it is 220V only and too big to lug around. My 30 year old Makita 2 gal. oilless is about to quit so I bought one of these, (reconditioned for $130.00) mostly due to the light weight. It works very well for the stapler, bradnailer and nail gun, is extremely quiet and so easy to lug around, both at home and to my rental condos.. I love it. You might consider buying two compressors, in different sizes.

 

[BubbaG65]

Hello to all and Merry CHRISTmas,

My 15 gal and prob 20 yr old porter cable compressor is almost ready for the graveyard. Can you pls tell me what pancake compressor [one's they sell today] are the most reliable and versatile? I have a PC framing nail-gun that I use from time to time, do not have a paint spray gun...It's primary use will be for filling tires on tractors, trailers, 4 wheelers, hosing down dirty engines and things, etc. and filling a portable air tank. My usage frequencies varies but it seems like I am filing one or two of 20-30 diff sets of tires, so it's never idle for long periods. I mostly fill a portable air tank to go to the tire source(s).

I received an HD gift certificate so just in time.

Thank you in advance and pls let me know if you have any questions.

No. I have a Porter Cable pancake, and it worked fine for years, but where the regulator and hose connections come out is kind of exposed, and I'm not exactly the most careful guy, so over the years with constant banging around etc. the regulator now leaks and I can only get up to about 75 psi, plus of course it runs almost constantly because the air keeps leaking out. Still good enough for finish nailing though. What I've seen other guys use for mini compressors is kind of like 2 air tanks stacked vertically and then a big handle up over the top which I assume also provides mechanical protection. I would check into those over the pancake style.

 

[two_bit_score]

Hello to all and Merry CHRISTmas,

My 15 gal and prob 20 yr old porter cable compressor is almost ready for the graveyard. Can you pls tell me what pancake compressor [one's they sell today] are the most reliable and versatile? I have a PC framing nail-gun that I use from time to time, do not have a paint spray gun...It's primary use will be for filling tires on tractors, trailers, 4 wheelers, hosing down dirty engines and things, etc. and filling a portable air tank. My usage frequencies varies but it seems like I am filing one or two of 20-30 diff sets of tires, so it's never idle for long periods. I mostly fill a portable air tank to go to the tire source(s).

I received an HD gift certificate so just in time.

Thank you in advance and pls let me know if you have any questions.

A Jenny or a Rol-Air will provide long, trouble free service.

 

[two_bit_score]

Jenny Hand Carry Air Compressor Repair Parts

Jenny Hand Carry Air Compressor parts on sale. Jenny Compressor parts lists and photos online to help find parts easily.

www.jennyparts.com

 

[two_bit_score]

Portable Air Compressors - Hand Carry Air Compressors | Rolair Systems

A Wide Variety of Direct Drive Hand Carry Air Compressors.

www.rolair.com

 

[varmint]

I have a 26 year old oil-free 30 gallon compressor which works fine, with only the pressure switch and regulator requiring replacement after all those years. Plus a smaller jobsite DeWalt I can move to where I need air, like into the house for a trim nailer... If my big compressor, in the shop, died, I think I'd probably get something a bit larger, since air tools, which I seldom use, but still appreciate, require serious air. A good tank drain valve, which you use, is key to a long life.

 

[two_bit_score]

My usage frequencies varies but it seems like I am filing one or two of 20-30 diff sets of tires, so it's never idle for long periods. I mostly fill a portable air tank to go to the tire source(s).

Rolair has a nice portable unit with a Honda engine that would handle almost any need in the field.

GD4000PV5H 4 HP, 4.5 Gal, Small Air Compressor | Rolair Systems

GD4000PV5H is the right choice when you need a small air compressor, but don't have the luxury of electricity on the job site. The fuel-efficient 118 cc (GX120) Honda engine combined with the high-output direct drive pump produces 4.6 CFM @ 90 PSI.

www.rolair.com

 

[two_bit_score]

Deere has a really neat compressor- generator combo unit.

GD4000PV5H 4 HP, 4.5 Gal, Small Air Compressor | Rolair Systems

GD4000PV5H is the right choice when you need a small air compressor, but don't have the luxury of electricity on the job site. The fuel-efficient 118 cc (GX120) Honda engine combined with the high-output direct drive pump produces 4.6 CFM @ 90 PSI.

www.rolair.com

 

[Same35]

Get a Pacific Air low noise compressor and you will never look back. No noise and phenomenal performance, I have 3 or 4 older noisy compressors around. I bought a Pacific Air about 6 months ago for the shop. Amazing is all I can say! Almost no noise..

 

[repete]

Selecting the compressor that suits your specific needs can be a difficult task. Not only do you need pressure but you need to decide how many CFM you need.
If you use a sandblaster you absolutely know CFM at PSI is critical and tank size is rather irrelevant as you will use the tank capacity pretty darn quickly and the compressor kicks on and does everything. Blow nozzle to clean stuff? Once the tank runs down it is ALL pump CFM @ PSI . A little tiny pump on a 60 gallon tank will disappoint you after maybe less than a minute blowing stuff off.
If you only plan to fill a tire, nearly anything will work.
I have four compressors, each filling a particular niche.