Dealer A bit of a dilemma

   / A bit of a dilemma #1  

gregfender

Gold Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2011
Messages
390
Location
Marion, NC
Tractor
Kubota L2501 HST
I've been in the market for a new, smaller tractor. I loved my JD 1070, but it was 20 years old and a bit too big for what I needed now. While looking for a replacement, I posted the tractor on Craigslist while I began my search. I looked at most colors, Liked the Kubota, B3200, really liked the Kioti CK27 and CK30, and also looked at the Massey Ferguson 1529.

The problem was, how my tractor eventually got sold. I told all the dealers what I had, why I was trading, and what I needed. Always a good place to start, right? While at the MF dealer looking at the 1529, the owner tells me, "no worries at all, I can get your tractor sold, in fact, I'm going to be in your town (40 miles away) tomorrow and I will pick it up and put it on my lot so folks can see it and it will be inside the fence. I made absolutely no commitment to him and the next day he calls and says he has a guy that he thinks wants the tractor and could he pick it up. I say sure...and tell him the bottom price I will take. He calls me a couple of days later and says he's waiting on the guy to come pick it up, its sold. I also notice he has a Craigslist ad for my tractor listed at $500 more than I told him my bottom price was. Hmmm....anyway, I wait and wait...he tells me its sold but the guy hasn't had a chance to come and get it.

Since it hadn't been picked up yet, I kept my ad active on CL and told folks if they wanted to see the tractor, it was at the dealer and what I would take for it. I get another call this week and one of those guys apparently bought it and financed it through the dealer and I can come pick my check up Friday. Today, I verified with the dealer that I could pick my funds up Friday and he still wants to sell me a MF 1629. Of all the tractors I tested, I like it least. Ergonomics are not for me. Besides, Rick Wallace found me a deal on a Bobcat CT225 (same as the Kioti CK27) for $4000 less than the best price on the MF. Today the dealer tells me he really wants to sell me a tractor since he wasn't making anything on mine.

Should I feel guilty at all for not giving him any business? There is a piece of me that was actually kind of annoyed when I saw he listed my machine on CL. Anyway, bottom line is I'm picking up the check and buying what I want. I suppose I just wanted to vent.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #2  
Don,t feel guilty, and get the tractor you want. Do not let him sell you something you don,t want. You,ll be sorry, forever, until you get rid of it, to get what you wanted in the first place.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #3  
You are under no moral or legal obligation to the dealer. He made his money off of your old tractor. I agree, buy the tractor you want.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #4  
Go get your cash fast, I think he is taking advantage of you .
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #5  
Get your money then find the tractor you really like.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #6  
Buy what you want....he was hoping to make a double deal, it just didn't work out.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #7  
If he financed it, he IS making money on your old tractor.
The casino ALWAYS wins.
Tell him thanks for selling it, and you will consider buying from him, but you have more shopping to do.
Jonathan
 
   / A bit of a dilemma
  • Thread Starter
#8  
It's a done deal. I picked up the check with hardly a word (I did get a bit of a glare from the dude). I did throw him a bone...bought a couple of straps so I could tie down the tractor I am gonna pick up tomorrow!

Yes, I'll post pics when I get it!
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #9  
It's a done deal. I picked up the check with hardly a word (I did get a bit of a glare from the dude). I did throw him a bone...bought a couple of straps so I could tie down the tractor I am gonna pick up tomorrow!

Yes, I'll post pics when I get it!
If I would have gotten the glare, I would have mentioned the 500 he made on the deal as per his craigslist add.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #10  
Good for you, and glad to see your getting the tractor that you really wanted. Looking forward to seeing the pics.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #11  
It is my opinion that you owe him "ZIP, NOTHING". If it were me, and I am seriously stating this forthcoming comment, I would sit in his Office until he gave me $250.00 which is HALF of the $500.00 that you previously stated that he listed it for above your bottom line price. Yes, I would definitely do this personally. Do what you think is best. You owe him no respect. Best wishes.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #12  
I don't have an opinion on this because I was not there. The problem I see is some people forming opinions on this sale without being an actual participant who is/was present for all that transpired. The dealer evidently had a buyer, sold the tractor and paid the seller what he expected. Sounds like everyone came out decent anyway.

The OP can buy the tractor he wants and hope he is happy with it.
 
   / A bit of a dilemma
  • Thread Starter
#13  
Here she is...all tied down and ready for the ride home.

image-1142469894.jpg
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #15  
Yeah you can't criticize the dealer for asking $500 over your asking price. Has anyone ever gone on craigslist and actually offered the asking price? I never offer more than 10% under the asking price! That is why it is an "asking" price. By offering less, you are taking a risk that no one else will offer more...
I think the dealer acted hastily thinking he might get two sales out of it, and that you would be guilt tripped into buying from him.. But either way I think you both made out OK.
Congrats on the new tractor!
Jonathan
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #17  
Tied down where , the rubber band on the front ?

Whats wrong with a 10k lb. rated rubber band. Should of had another one in the back. Besides the rubber band won't hurt the paint.
Congrats on your new ride!!!:thumbsup:
 
   / A bit of a dilemma #18  
Most dealerships don't have a paid sales staff working for free. And, driving out and picking up the tractor too.
A $500 markup on a several thousand tractor isn't much to shake a stick at.
And, you don't know exactly what it sold for.

Never trust a used car dealer that says they have a cousin that is looking for exactly what you are selling.

What I find a little odd is that the dealer didn't pay for the tractor when he brought it to his lot, nor did he have some kind of a written comission agreement. Perhaps he was expecting you to buy the Massey, but apparently didn't have a contract for that either.

What gets me is when I see something like this.
LANDINI 6560F on Craigslist for $4500
65hp tractor
Searching for details on the tractor, I found the SAME TRACTOR sold for auction 3 months ago for $700.
http://www.auctiontime.com/OnlineAuctions/Details.aspx?OHID=7314061&lp=th
Obviously someone thinks a 6x markup is a good idea.
 

Marketplace Items

International S1900 (A61306)
International...
2019 CATERPILLAR  XQ60 GENERATOR (A58214)
2019 CATERPILLAR...
2015 Dodge Journey Van (A59231)
2015 Dodge Journey...
(10) 10'-6" PVC CONDUIT PIPES (A60432)
(10) 10'-6" PVC...
DEUTZ MARATHON 60KW GENERATOR (A58214)
DEUTZ MARATHON...
TPL MECHANICS BODY LUBE SKID (A60429)
TPL MECHANICS BODY...
 
Top