Well then be frank Tres Crow. First if we're going to separate myth from fact let's talk about anyone that has some real experience working with cattle and living out where there are only cattle and wild animals. To make your assertion that those of us that have seen coyotes take calves are wrong you must first of all have some firsthand experience. I can tell you that it is certainly not urban legend about coyotes killing calves. While I cannot comment about the midwest I can say for fact I have witnessed, tracked, and killed coyotes that were in fact trying to take down calves or a cow that was having a breech birth or other complications. During calving we were never without a rifle and a handgun when we checked calves. As far as tracks from kills yes they certainly can be confirmed as to what killed the animal. Noone jumps to conclusions. We want to know exactly why that cow or calf died. If it was from disease, mountain lion, coyote, etc. We don't jump to conclusions. That's your living dead there on the ground and the way ranching is these days you need to know exactly why that cow or calf died. We have sat out with infrared scopes at night, WITH THE IDAHO FISH AND GAME DEPT., and killed as many as 25 coyotes in a night that were stalking cattle. Once the calves get bigger they don't bother them near as much but around calving time they go into a frenzy. Probably from all of the blood and such from birthing. Also when we get droughts and the deer population, rabbits, ground squirrels, etc. go to our irrigated fields and the coyotes, cougars, bobcat, etc. follow them. That's why you get such a high concentration of them in the west.
Just be careful about who you say is not telling the truth especially when you have no real life experience with it. Those of us that either live it or have lived it know that statistics and someone's opinion has very little if anything to do with the real world. That goes for everything, books and real life are usually two totally different scenarios many times regardless of the statistics.