I’ve had the rubber mat which wasn’t bad. Plastic liner which was my favorite. It’s easy to slide stuff out and it’s easy to clean. Plus it has shock absorption when I throw wood in. My current truck has spray in and I hate it. Yes it does look good but I hate it being textured. Nothing slides on it at all. I suppose that could be a positive or a negative depending on the person. For what I do I will never put a spray in on my truck. I need to replace this bed and I’m either going to do nothing or go plastic.