Orange 2501 vs Green 3025

/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #1  

Shortl Ne

New member
Joined
Jul 30, 2017
Messages
4
Location
Oneonta AL
Tractor
Kubota L2501 HST 4X4 Craftsman T3300
Probably done to death, but let's go again. I've been reading for days, near pulling trigger. Still torn. Have a Craftsman T3300 currently, to get us by for now-moving from the suburbs of Oklahoma City, where we had 0.22 acres, most of which was house, to Rural Alabama near Birmingham, where we now have 10 pasture acres.

Wife and son have horses, so we bought land with only pasture, trees ring us, and a few growing in the yard. The rest is all grass. It is sloped, with terraces from previous farming. Segmented into one large 5 acre pasture, two 2 +\- acre pastures, and yard around house, and barn areas make up the rest

Paid to get it cut down initially, had been vacant for over a year and was overgrown. It's now cut back, and our neighbor is taking care of the big 5 acres in exchange for letting him turn out his horses. I just mowed the rest again, without new little Craftsman T3300. As you can imagine, that wasn't much fun, but we got it done.

So we need a bigger tractor, I do t want to rely on neighbors much, and Wes have some work to do, moving old RR ties the previous owner used to make an "arena", some gravel work on the road and driveway, of course, mowing, and optimally, spraying the pastures, and eventually spreading manure and fire ant bait.

In my limited knowledge, which has been vastly improved thanks to you all, I've narrowed it down to the John deer 3025E And the Kubota L2501, both HST, with a finish mower on the back, and bucket on the front. Only other MUST have right now, is forks for the bucket to move those **** ties, and other General lifting/moving work.

Both are similarly priced. Bucket/brush hog equipped was around $16,900 for Kubota, and around $17,900 for the John Deer. Sure, I would love bigger, but price is a huge concern-this move already cost us a ton, and I simply can't spend more than around $20k with implements, and I like the no emissions stuff of the 25 HP models.

So-pros/cons for the orange one, or the green one? (And yes I looked at Kioti, Mahindra, etc, but the orange and green dealers are only 6 miles away-I like that. The others, are quite a ways from me. So I will of course listen to other suggestions, but really want a local convenient dealer and service. Thanks in advance!
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #2  
I have the little larger 3301. Very nice machine, and about as basic as they come. I would offer the following advice- get the quick attach for the bucket / forks; get the tires loaded for weight, and consider additional wheel weights, these small L's are light in the rear; consider the gear drive, easy to use, more hp available, and less $... Overall, I highly recommend the Kubota, but ... I am a bit of an orange guy...
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #3  
Which dealer are you more comfortable with. Both are good machines
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #4  
As between those two models, I think the Kubota has two distinct advantages that would mean a lot in everyday operation: 1. Three range HST vs. two range on the Deere. That mid range is a good all-around speed range that covers most of your regular tasks while the two range setup means you will be shifting between the two quite a bit. 2. Easily removable loader vs. non-removable one on the basic 3025e. Detaching the loader improves mowing, for example, by offering better visibility, more maneuverability, better handling, less soil compaction. I think there is an optional kit you can add to the 3025e to detach the loader, but still not as convenient.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #5  
One thing I recently learned on the dealer, after I had already bought mine. If you buy across state lines you can avoid the sales tax and save a decent chunk of money. From what I have gathered as long as you accept delivery in another state it is fine. Between the 2 you listed I like the Kubota better. I test drove the 2501 before I bought my mahindra 2538 and I really liked it. From what I read the 2501 has a very high torque engine that produces beyond its specs but because of the specs it stays under the tier 4 requirements. Also read the Deere in that series has an aluminum rear end, just me but not good if you need use a chain to pull an occasional stump or something.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025
  • Thread Starter
#6  
One thing I recently learned on the dealer, after I had already bought mine. If you buy across state lines you can avoid the sales tax and save a decent chunk of money. From what I have gathered as long as you accept delivery in another state it is fine. Between the 2 you listed I like the Kubota better. I test drove the 2501 before I bought my mahindra 2538 and I really liked it. From what I read the 2501 has a very high torque engine that produces beyond its specs but because of the specs it stays under the tier 4 requirements. Also read the Deere in that series has an aluminum rear end, just me but not good if you need use a chain to pull an occasional stump or something.

Thank you all. Frankly, I kinda was hoping there would be a reason to go John Deer......always saw them as kinda Americana. But, I agree, for all the reasons stated above, Kubota seems to be the pretty clear winner. The only downside, is I like the dual pedal better than the treadle, but it's not a huge deal. I did find out however, there is also a Massey Fergusun dealer near me. (I'm new here, and frankly didn't think to look for them online).

So, let's add a twist-clearly the Kubota seems to beat the JD. How does it compare to the MF 1526? Not a lot of info on that compact, that I can find. Just some promo video, and a few small references. It seems to spec close to the Kubota. Thoughts?
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #7  
Thank you all. Frankly, I kinda was hoping there would be a reason to go John Deer......always saw them as kinda Americana. But, I agree, for all the reasons stated above, Kubota seems to be the pretty clear winner. The only downside, is I like the dual pedal better than the treadle, but it's not a huge deal. I did find out however, there is also a Massey Fergusun dealer near me. (I'm new here, and frankly didn't think to look for them online).

So, let's add a twist-clearly the Kubota seems to beat the JD. How does it compare to the MF 1526? Not a lot of info on that compact, that I can find. Just some promo video, and a few small references. It seems to spec close to the Kubota. Thoughts?

I don't know the specs off the top of my head but will submit that when everything else is close, for me it will always come down to comfort on the machine so if you preferred the dual pedal as I do take the time to look at the MF. Buy the machine that fits you the best as they are both good machines.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #8  
. The only downside, is I like the dual pedal better than the treadle, but it's not a huge deal.

The dual pedal vs treadle won't be an issue once it is yours and you've been on it a few times in my opinion. I'd suggest the other aspects of the brands/models are more important. I have all three brands you are looking at and would go with Kubota in that size, but that is me. You really can't go wrong though with one of these three brands.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #11  
Comparing tractor brands is like comparing Ford, Chevy and Dodge. No matter which brand you go with each particular brand is going to have some features you love or hate.

The one thing the JD tractor layout has is it very simple. fwd/rev pedals and automotive style parking brake. The tractor is very user friendly. It might be worth your time to ask your wife and son's input on which tractor they feel most comfortable with. Sooner or later they will probably inevitably be using the tractor as well.

I wouldn't worry too much about permanent loader attachment. It takes me less than 5 minutes to remove the loader off my JD but hardly ever do. I do mow quite a bit with the bucket removed because that can be done in less than 30 seconds and the advantage of turning radius without the loader verses loader with no bucket is nominal.

I had an older Kubota L2500 and it was a great tractor for me but my wife and her small size had difficulty operating it. Ended up getting a JD 4310 and she loves it and puts as many hours on it as I do. I looked at a 1526 MF at a county fair a few years ago and was very impressed with them as well.


Go with any of the brands you and your family decide upon. They all are good tractors and a huge step above what you currently are using. Also these tractors are capable of running a 5' bush hog all day long so don't let the dealer try to sell you a 4 footer saying thats all it can handle.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #12  
I like both brands, but the Deere E models are economy models, made to hit a low price point. They cut some corners to do that. The Deere R models are great, but I wouldn't get an E model.
 
/ Orange 2501 vs Green 3025 #13  
I went with the L2501 after looking at the same options you did. The build quality of the MF wasn't as nice as the Kubota and the loader lever on the MF was a pain to use which was a shame because the dealer was closer and a real nice guy. The JD E series isn't worth it. I would get a JD R if I was going JD but as nice as the L2501 was I didn't see the need to spend more. I would get the HST for sure on the L2501 because the DT version has the most base transmission they make and if you are doing any loader work it will be very tedious.

I also like having top and tilt especially if you plan on getting a box.
 

Marketplace Items

2015 INTERNATIONAL PROSTAR+ (A67714)
2015 INTERNATIONAL...
KUBOTA ZD1511 ZERO TURN LAWN MOWER (A65057)
KUBOTA ZD1511 ZERO...
FOUR RACKS OF MISC FILTERS (A67714)
FOUR RACKS OF MISC...
2001 THOMAS-INTERNATIONAL 3800 SCHOOL BUS (A64280)
2001...
2022 JCB Fastrac 4220 217HP 4WD Agricultural Tractor (A66734)
2022 JCB Fastrac...
2016 KUBOTA SVL75-2 SKID STEER (A65056)
2016 KUBOTA...
 
Top