Narrow bucket vs Trencher

/ Narrow bucket vs Trencher #1  

Komrade

Silver Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
213
Location
Western Morgan County, WV
Tractor
Kubota L3430 HST
I have a Woods BH9000 Backhoe.

I am in need to create some trenches (wires, pipes, etc).. I expect a number of projects over the next few years.

I looked online, and anything decent used is $2000+, including any attachments to the tractor.

In addition, our ground is VERY stoney. One of the properties is on a mountain, and another is in the delta of a creek by the name of Stony (and they don't call it Stony for nothing).

I have once rented a ditch witch (before I had a tractor), and it really struggled to ditch a packed road (for a french drain) on the mountain.

The main plus to the ditch witch from my perspective seem to be maneuverability. I can't think of anywhere i need to ditch of space being an issue, and while no mini-x, the hoe has about 9ft reach.

edit: another benefit would be 'walkability'--backhoe has to move for every 6 feet of trench or so.

Additionally, I believe a narrow bucket will be a few hundred $, tops.

2 questions

am I thinking right?

how do I find compatible buckets to my backhoe?

P.S. apparently I posted on this topic before
http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/parts-repairs/317183-buckets-fit-bh9000.html
 
/ Narrow bucket vs Trencher #2  
If there were no rocks or big roots, a trencher would be much faster and neater- BUT- you have rocks.

I have a full size backhoe and have a 20" and an 8" bucket- the 8" works well for trenching unless the ground is a little wet- then it is hard to get material to fall out. The other drawback to a narrow bucket is that my depth is limited to about 36" because the end of my dipper arm and the pin are about 12" wide- so I can only dig a trench as deep as the bucket is long. Just keep that in mind if you go with a really narrow bucket.

The 8" also works well for digging out tree roots.
 
 

Marketplace Items

2007 Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD (A60462)
2007 Chevrolet...
JLG E300AJ (A60462)
JLG E300AJ (A60462)
2008 Freightliner Allegro Bay Class A Motorhome (A61574)
2008 Freightliner...
UNUSED WOLVERINE 3PT QUICK HITCH (A64281)
UNUSED WOLVERINE...
UNUSED WOLVERINE BUCKET (A64281)
UNUSED WOLVERINE...
New 5/16" G80 Double Chain Sling (A62679)
New 5/16" G80...
 
Top