Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.

   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #1  

oldpilgrim

Elite Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
3,080
Location
SE Ma
Tractor
2014 Mahindra 3016HST
After much more deliberating and going back and forth to a Kioti and a Mahindra dealer, checking every aspect of both the CK27 HST and the Mahindra 3016 HST , and driving both, I've decided on the Mahindra 3016 with FEL and BH.

The 3016 is almost 2 feet shorter overall, it looks like the BH was made to be on it whereas the Kioti looks like it was an after thought and hangs out considerably off the backend. The BH also seems more ruggedly made/ heavier duty than the Kioti.

The bucket loader doesn't stick out so far as the Kioti. Both have the 60 inch quick connect bucket. The 3016 has a 50% higher FEL lift capacity.

I like the 2 pedal trans vs the kioti rocker, the engine seemed smoother and easier starting than the Kioti,the transmission was the smoothest and quietest of the two, (or of any I've ever driven), the hydraulics were smoother, quicker and more responsive, the joy stick seemed much more refined. The R4 tires seemed wider than the kioti, although I didn't actually measure them.

The bucket on the kioti is much deeper and more desirable in my estimation. :( It was the one thing that disappointed me on the 3016.


The 3016 is $1500 more than the CK27 but I think it is worth the small difference...at least to me.

Don't get me wrong, this is not a knock Kioti thread. The kioti appears to be a fine tractor, it has a lot of real nice features. Based on my needs/desires, the 3016 is just a better fit for me.

My brother has a Kioti and until today, I was leaning toward the CK27 based on my familiarity with his. He is very happy with it.

He came with me today, and examined both units closely, and drove them. I asked him if he was buying, which would he get.

He said he'd get the 3016. :D This from a Kioti owner!

Now if I can speed up the bank in releasing some of my own invested money for me........

I should have it in a couple of weeks.

Will report back then. It's going to be a long cuppla weeks.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #2  
Only you have to be satisfied with what you pick, Good Luck with your fine machine.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #3  
I think you would be happy with either.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #4  
The ck27 will not come close to lifting what the 3016 can. 1650 lbs. is a lot in the 30HP. class.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #5  
I recently picked up a 3016 HST but was looking at the LS tractor line prior to buying a Mahindra. So far I'm very happy with the comfort and features of my 3016 and like you mentioned, it's a few feet shorter which means I can park it in my shop. The only design feature I'm still a little concerned about is, how the FEL lines are routed under the platform to reach the fender mounted controls. They really should have transitioned to hard steel lines to avoid getting hung up or abraded. I have some ideas on how to protect them but haven't done anything yet. Good luck
with your purchase.

Sent from my iPhone using TractorByNet
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#6  
that's something I didn't notice at the dealer. I'll have to review the situation when I finally get it.

thanks for the heads up.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Went today and finalized the sale. Dealer will be closed for vacation until after the 4th so I wait until then to get it.

:bawling:

I added a thumb and a 10inch bucket.

Got myself a Mahindra measuring stick and a nice baseball style cap. (no buyer's regrets here :) )
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #8  
Go take the bucket off of the Kioti and swap it with the Mahindra no one will notice! .:shocked: Just kidding.. Congratulations on your new machine. I am sure the waiting will be difficult.!
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Go take the bucket off of the Kioti and swap it with the Mahindra no one will notice! .:shocked: Just kidding.. Congratulations on your new machine. I am sure the waiting will be difficult.!

I thought of that ! They're both quick connect buckets, the swap would be easy.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #10  
I thought of that ! They're both quick connect buckets, the swap would be easy.

Yeah, but then you would have a MahKoti. or somthing:laughing:
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#11  
maybe a Kihindra.
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #12  
I liked (preferred?) the 3016, too. At some point some of us have to finally say, "this exceeds my budget". (No Mahindra dealers within 200 miles didn't help Mahindra's cause, either. Bought Kioti locally.)

$1,500 isn't all that much. But then I could spend just a little more and get the cabbed DK45SE, ad infinitum.

Sure liking my Kioti CK27 though. :)
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#13  
I've got one dealer about 8 miles away, then the one I ordered from who is 13 miles away and another just over 25 miles away. I've been doing business with the company I bought it from for about 25 years, they've been in business for over 50, still run by the same family. I used to get Fergie parts from them. The old man that started the business sold Fergies and liked them so he went out of his way to help me get parts. At that time they were primarily a Deere dealer but said they couldn't keep up with the repairs, so dumped them and went to Mahindra a few years back.

I agree with you that there's a point where you just have to say "whoa" enough is enough when it comes to buying one and it's accessories.

I ordered the smaller BH bucket and the thumb with the tractor. I will add a RhinoHide canopy and a backblade, and bucket hooks, and clamp on forks when I get it. I'm considering a Piranha tooth bar, but I'm not sure how well that will work with the modification I want to make with the FEL bucket.

I mentioned the Kioti bucket is much deeper than the Mahindra and I want to make the bucket deeper. I can do it ok but I'm concerned about the fit of the Piranha after I mod the bucket..

It's ironic that Kioti puts a larger bucket on the 27, but the Mahindra has about 50% more lift capacity. Go figure.

I like the idea of a cab, but it would only be for winter snow use as during the rest of the year it would be in the way as I spend a lot of time in the woods.

I can see me adding some more hydraulics to both the front end and the rear sometime. A grapple would be nice.

I'm 68, retired and I've been telling my brother that I've really been looking forward to getting a new tractor for some time. It's been a dream of mine, I told him, everyone needs something to dream about.

Now he says, well, the tractor is on the way, now you've got nothing to look forward to anymore. :confused:
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #14  
Not true. The many implements/remotes/grapple etc.. you have plenty to look forward to!:)
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #15  
[snip]
I'm 68, retired and I've been telling my brother that I've really been looking forward to getting a new tractor for some time.
[snip]

Well, Pilgrim, I wouldn't call 68 old these days! More like the new 48. Congratulations on your new tractor!
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided. #16  
I mentioned the Kioti bucket is much deeper than the Mahindra and I want to make the bucket deeper. I can do it ok but I'm concerned about the fit of the Piranha after I mod the bucket..

It's ironic that Kioti puts a larger bucket on the 27, but the Mahindra has about 50% more lift capacity. Go figure.
Couldnt you have just ordered it with the Kioti bucket or another that meets your requirements?
larry
 
   / Mahindra vs Kioti....I've decided.
  • Thread Starter
#17  
The mahindra dealer didnt have any kioti buckets handy :)
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2009 IC Corporation PB105 School Bus (A59230)
2009 IC...
2017 Freightliner M2 106 AWD Terex Hi-Ranger 5TC-55 55ft Insulated Material Handling Bucket Truck (A60460)
2017 Freightliner...
2019 CHEVROLET SILVERADO 11FT FLATBED (A59905)
2019 CHEVROLET...
Unused 2025 CFG Industrial H15R Mini Excavator (A59228)
Unused 2025 CFG...
MORBARK WOOD HOG 6400 XT HORIZONTAL GRINDER (A60429)
MORBARK WOOD HOG...
2024 Timpte 40ft Hopper (A56438)
2024 Timpte 40ft...
 
Top