Close to buying MX5100

[cdnt]

After considering a L3800 (or deal on a L3400), I think I've decided on a 2011 MX5100. I have 50 acres of both field, pasture and wood and a 1,000 foot drive and decided the 5100 is generally a better fit for my needs. Discing fields, cutting small fields, tilling for veg crops, maintaining trails, some bush work, maintaining drive, snowplowing, etc.

For me the added size, weight, 3PH telescopic adjustments, better loader, added HP, cruise control, etc made for a relatively easy decision. I was able to look at the 3800, 4400 and 5100 side by side which made for an easy comparison. The incremental $5000 seems reasonable, especially w 0% 60 mos financing option (vs 48 mos for L)

The other bonus is the tractor is in the yard spec'd to my preference and basically ready to go. HST, R1 tires, quick detach bucket, rim guard loaded tires, rear remote, block heater, rear work light. I'm also buying a LP tiller, LP rear blade and a 6' Bush Hog Squealer cutter. I think he's giving me a fair price (similar to what people have posted for prices in the USA for tractor - I'm in Ontario).

I like the dealer, they're local which is great. I went to JD dealer yesterday about 45min. I have a JD400 garden tractor too - but found the options really expensive (4000 series have better specs, but they look small and are literally $8,000 more. The 5045e is a much stronger tractor for a similar price but no HST). The dealer has also offered a 3 day free rental of a grading scraper to help reshape my drive.

Decisions, decisions!

 

[bigbull338]

you wont be sorry going with the MX5100 HST 4x4 w/fel.an itll do everything you ask of it an more.mine lifts an moves 5 by 6 bales with ease on back an front.

 

[StanR]

I just got a MX5100 hst 4x4 with loader, rear remote, draft, sun shade, and rear work 6 ft LP shredder, LP 6 ft disk, 6ft box blade and front hay fork..

I only have about 22 hours but I love the tractor. I have a new 28 Hp compact I sold the get the Kubota..

 

[WishinIwasFishin]

I just bought a MX5100 4x4 with loader 3 weeks ago.It has the shuttle shift.I have used it about 4 hours and am very pleased.I bought a Woods BrushBull 720x last week and it handles it no problem.That cutter weighs over 1100lbs.I am looking forward to many hours in the seat.What part of the country are you in?

 

[TripleR]

The MX 5100 appears to be a very good basic tractor with a few extras to make it really easy to use.

 

[cdnt]

Here are some pics for those that are considering a L3800 vs. a MX5100. Pics show the front (L3800, MX5100, MX5100 with LA844 FEL), rear and the 'improved' 3PH on the MX5100

 

[cdnt]

Few more of L3800 3PH and differences in level of 'exposure' on front end

 

[k0ua]

Man that is one "tough" looking tractor. I really like the extra features it has over the L3800 series. Not to mention what I could do on these big ole Branson rocks with that La844 loader. Dont get me wrong, I love my L3400HST, but there is always something you come up against and want "more". How much more in real money is it over the L3800?

James K0UA

 

[cdnt]

In my part of the world, about $3400 or $2100 more for the mx4700. Reasonable in my mind for 35% increase in HP, added features, more than double lift capacity on fel and 35% more bucket capacity, etc.

My sene is now that this model has HST, Kubota will really be pushing this vs. The L4400 (which I believe is being discontinued?)

 

[k0ua]

In my part of the world, about $3400 or $2100 more for the mx4700. Reasonable in my mind for 35% increase in HP, added features, more than double lift capacity on fel and 35% more bucket capacity, etc.

My sene is now that this model has HST, Kubota will really be pushing this vs. The L4400 (which I believe is being discontinued?)

Thanks. Yes it does kinda make your mouth water, to get that much more capacity and some nice features like the 3pt extending links and telescoping sway bars, looks like a bargain to me.

James K0UA

 

[ejkessler]

I love my Grand L and need a cab. But for what you are describing for what your needs are I think the MX5100 is a very sound choice. A lot of tractor for the money and will be a great work horse for you. Just as an FYI though the L's are 0% for 60 months also. I just got my L delivered 3 weeks ago with that financing.

 

[cdnt]

T-7! Just getting the insurance - hope to have it dropped off next week! Dealer loaded the tires this week and is installing the other dealer options. Waiting for the tiller to arrive.

Exciting!

 

[Kyle241]

Congrats! That is one nice tractor, I'm jealous as I have to put my MX4700 on hold for a little while.

 

[k0ua]

Congrats, show pictures, and keep us informed how you like it, I think you made a great choice.

James K0UA

 

[ejkessler]

Congrats, hope to see some pics.

 

[rogersmithiii]

I too have decided upon an MX, but I'm likely going to go with the 4700. The only difference that I can see is that the 5100 eeks out a few more HSP by using a turbo. I know that countless discussions swear that the turbo is ultra reliable, but if it ever does go, it's going to be incredibly expensive to fix. I'd just assume save $500 or so by skipping the turbo.

 

[TripleR]

I too have decided upon an MX, but I'm likely going to go with the 4700. The only difference that I can see is that the 5100 eeks out a few more HSP by using a turbo. I know that countless discussions swear that the turbo is ultra reliable, but if it ever does go, it's going to be incredibly expensive to fix. I'd just assume save $500 or so by skipping the turbo.

Is the only difference between the MX5100 and MX4700 the turbo?

 

[flatlander 2500hd]

Is the only difference between the MX5100 and MX4700 the turbo?

There are a few differences between the MX5100 and the MX4700. The 5100 has the turbo, a handle on the right fender and the deluxe 3 point hitch.

 

[TripleR]

There are a few differences between the MX5100 and the MX4700. The 5100 has the turbo, a handle on the right fender and the deluxe 3 point hitch.

Thanks, I thought had seen the telescoping 3-point adjusters mentioned elsewhere, but wasn't sure. I really like them. I know they can be added, but I "think" the cost is pretty high; may be wrong..

 

[cdnt]

Hmmm, that's interesting. One of the main reasons I went with the MX vs the L series was the improved 3PH including the telescoping lower link ends and stabilizers. I thought both models had this but upon closer review I see that the brochure does note this is for the MX5100 only (and the 4x4 model at least according to the 2009 brochure I have)