4520 0r m6040

   / 4520 0r m6040 #1  

howie51

New member
Joined
Nov 10, 2011
Messages
3
Tractor
john deere 4520
any comments on 4520 versues a m6040
 
   / 4520 0r m6040 #4  
What will you be using the tractor for and how much are you wanting to spend?

Any attachments on your "must have" list?

Please provide a little info for what your going to use it for. Both are suitable tractors though depending on your needs.
 
   / 4520 0r m6040 #5  
6040 pto HP55 utility
4520 pto HP46.5 compact

This is really going to depend on what you gonna be doing like said above..
 
   / 4520 0r m6040 #6  
I went with the m6040 becuase of the 3pt lift capacity and the extra loader capacity (both of which I needed), but I also needed a tractor small enough to be pulled by a pickup. It fits that niche nicely.

If you are doing much yard/landscape type work, the smaller jd would be nicer for that.
 
   / 4520 0r m6040
  • Thread Starter
#7  
hi all i have a 4520 now . i use the tractor to pull boats and to lift the i/o engines in and out. the boom that i use puts the j/d to the limit . i need a bit more on the hyd end . i tow boats to the river which is down hill so i need good brakes and when i return it,s all uphill so more pulling power can,t hurt
 
   / 4520 0r m6040 #8  
So are you asking whether you should upgrade to something such as the 6040 as an upgrade to your 4520? What kind of a slope is it? Dirt/gravel/paved? How large of boats are they?

From what your saying the 6040 wouldnt provide enough boost for an upgrade.
 
   / 4520 0r m6040
  • Thread Starter
#9  
thanks for the reply the grade is about a 500 ft incline the heaviest boat is around 7500 lbs .
 
   / 4520 0r m6040 #10  
This isn't a real practical application for a compact tractor imo. I would consider a wheel loader or large forklift for this work. I would consider a one ton single wheel truck with a weighted bed and large motor and 4.00 + rear differential for towing.

If you still want a tractor for this type work consider an economy type 6140 Deere. This is a case for a high hp version for what ever frame size you settle on.

It takes lots of hp to pull a load up a long grade at a fast speed. This isn't what farm tractors are designed for, but some of the newer pickups and chassis cab trucks are perfect for this task.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2013 Cadillac ATS Sedan (A50324)
2013 Cadillac ATS...
2015 VOLVO VNL TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A51219)
2015 VOLVO VNL...
80in HD Tooth Bucket with Side Cutters ONE PER LOT (A51039)
80in HD Tooth...
1992 New Holland L553 Skid Steer (A50657)
1992 New Holland...
(INOP) CASE IH MAGNUM 180 TRACTOR (A50459)
(INOP) CASE IH...
GARDNER DENVER 480 VOLT AIR COMPRESSOR (A50854)
GARDNER DENVER 480...
 
Top