Needing advice on tractor size

[RayIN]

I came across this searching for MF 4707 specs: Massey Ferguson 4707 Tractor Data: Specs, Review, Problems

 

[dodge man]

The only advantage of the smaller one is the fact it’s smaller. Is more maneuverable important to you? Is there a building you will keep it in that is size limited? A trailer and truck size limit you have?

 

[LNSTrees]

The only advantage of the smaller one is the fact it’s smaller. Is more maneuverable important to you? Is there a building you will keep it in that is size limited? A trailer and truck size limit you have?

the $20k price difference is probably the biggest motive, but later down the line, being able to haul it with less truck + trailer could be helpful

 

[David in KY]

I bought a 66HP Kioti, and it was the right size for me, but definitely on the larger end of the scale of what I was looking for. I would have regretted anything smaller.

The real pain is in implements. I've easily got 2/3 of the tractor value in implements, with a few more yet, on my list. Yowza!

 

[paulsharvey]

the $20k price difference is probably the biggest motive, but later down the line, being able to haul it with less truck + trailer could be helpful

So, without knowing more, I haven't heard anything that dictates you move to the 4707.

An important note, neither are good at root raking, (you say it was recently timbered), but both can do it to a limited extent.

The 4707 would be good if there is actually tillage/planting planned; but short of that, I would go with a 2860M Power Shuttle, or 2M60. Good mobility, good power to size. Big enough to do light ag work, 8 ft disc, 10 ft mower, 6 ft drill (maybe 8? I dont know, thats pushing it),

 

[GrandpaSmurf825]

Pros and cons to both. Although I would research trailering requirements for the 4707 to see how heavier the trailer and truck would need to be. The base tractor is roughly 3500 lbs heavier and then attachments etc. add to that. Another thing I haven't saw mentioned is dealer support. Drive around the area and see if there are a lot of red tractors. A good dealer is everything but a storefront isn't much use if you have issues and they don't have a good service department. I have no idea where you are located but I know that there aren't a lot of red a silver units around here even though there is a dealer 10 miles away. Is there a particular reason why you want a Massey Ferguson? There are several green options and it appears comparably priced. I'm not going to try to analyze your property because you know what you have far better than any of us. I'm a flat lander. I can see 20 mile on a clear night literally now that all the corn and beans are out and the leaves are off the trees.

I'm going to throw a different suggestion at you. The 2850 or something comparable is a handy size. Have you considered a backhoe for the "heavy lifting"? Instead of grinding out stumps and snags dig them out. For the extra $20k the 4707 would cost you can find some pretty solid serviceable backhoes with a thumb. It wouldn't need to be 4wd. If it's that wet and hard to get around you will have some serious issues getting around with either of the other two choices as well. Plus everyone wants 4wd and it makes getting a decent 2wd for a fair price much easier. I help a farmer friend and we use his hoe far more than you would expect to. The only thing it would be nice to have that is hard to find is a 4 in 1 loader bucket. Something to think about. In backhoes Case, JD, and Cat in that order are the easiest to find and lowest to highest generally. Good luck in your decision.

 

[Suburban Plowboy]

How about a 40-horse tractor and occasionally renting an excavator or bulldozer for the stumps?

 

[LNSTrees]

I'm in central Virginia. The stumps and slash are all loblolly pine...so, soft wood and shallow roots. I've thought about renting or hiring out some of the heavy duty work, but I'm not clearing everything, just trails and food plots. I'm also not 100% locked in on exactly what I want to do and I don't want to be rushed by the deadline of a rental. I kinda just want to go out there and ride around and do stuff at my own pace.

I'm also shopping a 5075e, but it's almost the same price as the 4707 but with significantly less capability. The Deere dealer network is definitely stronger, but Massey has two shops within a reasonable distance.

I went and drove them all today. My gut feeling is that the 2M.50 isn't big enough but the 5075e and the 4707 are. I talked to the mechanics at both places. Both good dudes.

Backhoes and skidsteers near me are really pricey new or really beat up used. Also, my inner 5 year old just wants a tractor to play with.

 

[paulsharvey]

I'm in central Virginia. The stumps and slash are all loblolly pine...so, soft wood and shallow roots. I've thought about renting or hiring out some of the heavy duty work, but I'm not clearing everything, just trails and food plots. I'm also not 100% locked in on exactly what I want to do and I don't want to be rushed by the deadline of a rental. I kinda just want to go out there and ride around and do stuff at my own pace.

I'm also shopping a 5075e, but it's almost the same price as the 4707 but with significantly less capability. The Deere dealer network is definitely stronger, but Massey has two shops within a reasonable distance.

I went and drove them all today. My gut feeling is that the 2M.50 isn't big enough but the 5075e and the 4707 are. I talked to the mechanics at both places. Both good dudes.

Backhoes and skidsteers near me are really pricey new or really beat up used. Also, my inner 5 year old just wants a tractor to play with.

Although physically the same size, the 2M60, or 2860M, has 10hp more, and the power shuttle is putting 47Hp to the PTO. It has pretty good hydralic flow.

 

[Dawg in Fl]

"Also, my inner 5 year old just wants a tractor to play with."

Don't let my wife see that!