We are a dealer for Diamond C and also FabForm so we are surely biased. I'll state that upfront. But we like them a lot. High quality, innovative, and very customizable. Diamond C has been undergoing huge growth, greatly expanding their facilities, changing the paint system, making its own engineered beams for the bigger trailers, and things like that. They are really innovative. They aren't perfect, but we like them a lot. Rapid growth comes with the associated need for hiring and training new employees and anytime that happens a company needs to be really careful to stay on top of quality.
We haul with ours every day and my son has one, a tandem dually and he pulls his 16k excavator on it daily and it has been very good. He had a PJ before and after the 4th time taking it back for fold-down ramp problems he sold it. The trailer itself held up, but the ramps were terrible for loading a rubber track excavator which puts a big point load on ramps. From our perspective Diamond C is top-notch.
I note that one poster mentioned how the dump trailer doors do not fold flat against the sides when open, that is not an issue for me on my Diamond C dump, but I can see how it could be if dumping right next to a fence or building. And the comment about how the doors are held open I must agree with. The Diamond C system isn't much of a system, just a chain with a clasp on it. It is simple and won't break, but there are better methods. No doubt the perfect trailer would be a mix of the best features of several brands.
I think there are a lot of very good brands out there, but for us we are pleased with what we use in our own fleet and what we sell.