Scooby, how much oil do you currently have to supply a saw motor?
I have been gathering parts for a processor for about 2 years now, and just about have everything I need. Having done a lot of head scratching considering a saw motor, I decided to just look at chainsaw spec's and work from there. Using a 3120 husquvarana as a base line, this saw uses 8.7hp to turn a .404 chain at 9000rpm and has a chain speed of just under 4000ftmin. Chain speed is determined buy chain pitch, X 2 X Number of teeth on sprocket, times rpms / 12.
Much is to be said of using a parker f11 motor, but cost is prohibited. While the F11 motor will turn speeds of 10,000rpms, to get max power, you also need a very high volume pump with 4-5000psi pressures. This means a very expensive pump and a high hp engine to pull it with. In other words, the cost associated with the f11 motor also comes with the extra cost of the proper pump and engine assemble to get it to function like it would on a harvester type machine. I guess saw motor selection really comes down to just how fast you want the saw to run and how deep your pockets are.
I have decided on a 1.3cuin proline motor. I can run 25gpm of 3000psi oil, a 13pin sprocket, .404 chain and get over 4000ftmin cutting speed out of the chain. It should produce around 29hp. This puts it in line pretty close to the cutting speed of the husquvarna 3120 gas powered chainsaw with about 3 times the hp. Should be a pretty hot saw setup resulting in pretty fast cut times. Of course, I havent built it yet, so this is all just theory. Hopefully, I will be able to get started on this project this winter. I have already bought a 27in .404 bar and chain, as well as the sprocket and hub to mount direct to the motor. I am stilll looking for a good pump. I also already have a 58hp diesel engine for a power plant, 8in hbeam, and trailer to mount it all on. I just found a couple of 12" belt conveyors, but need to convert them from electric to hydraulic driven. Mostly, I just need time and a little steel.
MS, I have 22 GPM on the low pressure side of the pump (under about 650psi), and about 7.5 GPM on the high pressure side @3600RPM
I did a bit of research and found the brochure for the saw motor.
Bondioli & Pavesi - QH013
The HPL MA 1 36 breaks down as follows. Its a HPL series, Motor, Group 1, Type 36. Checking the chart, that is, 0.23cu/rev, 3046 PSI, 4000RPM max. Checking the ole speed/volume chart for that motor, Ill need a bit over 15l/min to get 4000rpm out of it. Around 12l/min for 3000RPM. And around 8l/min for 2000RPM.
15l/min is 3.96 US GPM. I should have all kinds of flow for that. My pump rarely even shifts into HP mode, so Id be pulling from a 22gpm flow. Id have to have some sort of flow divider I think...
Sounds like you have quite a build there. Significantly more than what Im looking at, and considerably more machine than the Ergo35 Im basing off. Im keeping my log lift
IF I make my processor. If I get some large wood, I can cut it manually, and load it into my splitter with the lift. Best of both worlds.
Building a splitter to handle all potential wood size, brings this into another price bracket for sure. One thing about the Wallenstein chainsaw processor is the ability to run a larger bar on a gas saw, vs gearing up a hydraulic system capable to turn a long chain. I can run a 20" maybe even a bit more on my Husky 562XP and it is a very fast saw. Probably faster than all but the fastest hydraulic processors with a f11.
I guess it comes down to what your typical load of logs looks like. A couple years ago, much of what I got was larger, 18"+ stuff, no good for a 16" processor

, but then last year, I only had a dozen "large" logs and lots of small 4" and under.. Its real hard to know what size to design to.:mur:
The f11 is the holy grail, but its a $3000 motor, and as you say, it requires quite a bit to get the most out of it. Perfectly acceptable on a (tree) harvester where they came from and maximum production is the goal. Im not sure for a firewood processor that will likely do under 20 cd a year, like mine.
Palax is a very well respected company, so Im going to trust their engineering that says a 4000 (max) RPM, 0.23cu motor can run a 16" saw at reasonable speed (as evidenced in the above video). I couldnt determine sprocket size on the machine I looked at, so I have no real idea what chain speed would be. I cant find it in any of their literature either. I imagine it is a 3/8 pitch which seems reasonable.
Horsepower wise, the Palax is putting about 4.5 odd HP to the bar via the Bondioli motor. The bar is 15", so that means they figure about 0.3hp/inch. For your 28" bar, that would be 8.4hp, so it sounds like your 8.7 hp figure for the husky is right on. With 29 odd hp at the saw that thing will be a
BEAST:thumbsup:
The more I think about this, the more I lean to the Wallenstein system, it seems like a cheap way to get a "decent" processor. I certainly have enough flow to run a 16-18 bar, no problem, but I think the Wallenstein system for my uses, will be a better, CHEAPER end result. I cant wait to see your build though!