Rockbadchild
Elite Member
Its opinionated driven... for disclosure I have a civil engineering background but it doesn't mean I am 100% right and it's not because he is a contractor that he is ether. If you notice in my illustration above the top is seal with clay to minimize water coming from the surface. The concern is ground water and water fallowing the wall and going under, I would argue that if the soil clog the fabric it will clog the pure stone and the pipe as well so the longer I can keep that clear the better it is... I didn't show it but the fabric should go down along the undisturbed soil (left looking at the picture) and the pure stone and up the wall to separate the stone from any fines. some pipe comes with a filtration sock on it but I usually still put fabric to separate fines and pure stone. Water eventually make it through any soil the one it has the hardest time going through is clay.I built one small wall using fabric. Then I saw a video by a landscape contractor vehemently criticizing the use of fabric. It got be to rethinking the use on my second larger walls. I think landscape fabric is designed to lay on top of the dirt and let water through. If it is under the dirt I think it might clog up and act as a barrier and not pass any water.
And that is the problem with the internet. You can find someone to justify whatever you decide to do.
On my second wall, no landscape fabric, back filled with 2 feet of gravel, sock covered pipe at the bottom, several levels of geo grid. After a rain I evidence of water weeping out of all levels of the wall. I think that is a good thing, to me it means the water is not trapped behind the wall.
Doug in SW IA
You can get away without fabric, not saying it's a must but to say its a bad idea I disagree... If doing it without fabric I would used screen sand (coarse beach sand) to make the separation around the pure stone. or simply pipe with filtration sock and sand around it. But I like using pure stone it had a lot of void and flow capacity if the pipe get clog and less chance for it to clog.
Last edited: