Re: Mark in Minn.
Mark, It sounds trite, I know, but I really do "feel your pain." Perspective is a terrible thing to lose as your "neighbor" obvioulsy has. Some folks can't/don't differentiate between can and should. In many rural areas you can shoot ANY dog on your property, period, and you don't have to explain squat to anyone. Discression is at the volition of the property owner. Many of the nicest folks I know would shoot any dog on their place, theirs included, if it chased stock or did mischief above a "certain" level. Your neighbor apparently has no discretion and did confuse can with should. At a minimum, since he wasn't being harmed by you or yours, he should have warned you. Not required by law but common decency unless a dog was doing something destructive right then and couldn't be detered with sub-lethal force. It just flat irritates me to have jerks like that who so easily spoil the peace of the country.
On the bright side, Mark, he could have actually filed charges on at least your wife for assault and battery. Seems ridiculous, I know, but it seems to go with the territory. When you find someone like your neighbor who would do what he did, I mean the whole scene, lies, attitude, deceit, etc. are often part of the package. The guy ain't right!
Take care with the replacement animals as it would not be surprising to find that he would do it again or not even wait for an animal to tresspass and might take a shot or toss a poisoned piece of meat onto your or other adjacent property. Cyanide bombs such as are used by pros to exterminate coyote will kill a dog in a single breath and unfortunately seem to be available to the demented bozos with the will to kill.
Sorry this wasn't a real uplifting, feel good message but if it keeps y'all from a similar repeat, it is worth saying.
Patrick