Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade?

   / Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade? #1  

BadDecisions

Silver Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
142
Location
Wittmann, AZ
Tractor
Ford 8N
Old Wagner WM-3 loader on an 8N. Before anyone says it, yes, I'm aware that loader on Ford *N is bad. I've already had this tractor and loader for years, and I rarely use the loader. 99.9% of the time, I used it as a crude crane, and I don't even do that any more since I put an actual crane on my utility truck. Rare enough that it doesn't make sense for me to go buy another tractor for the once every few years I need the loader, and it's simple to install/remove the loader with the crane, so it's only on the tractor when I need it.

A project has come up that I need the loader for...last time I used it, all 3 cylinders were leaking, and it wasn't holding height...so I'm rebuilding the whole dang thing. I see replacement control valves are available with and without float, which I understand make so the loader has neither up or down pressure on it for things like dragging the bucket to grade with it.

I already have a large back blade and box blade that I use for those things, and I THINK the Wagners floated naturally even without a specific float position. The few times I tried back dragging the bucket, it seemed like it would just bounce over the ground, but it's been years since I tried that. I quickly decided the rear blades worked far better than the bucket for grading.

All that said, is there some other reason I should consider getting a float capable control valve?
 
   / Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade? #2  
No.
 
   / Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade? #3  
Unless there is a huge price difference I would get the valve with float capability. Better to have it and not need it, than need it and not have it.

Doug in SW IA
 
   / Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade?
  • Thread Starter
#4  
Unless there is a huge price difference I would get the valve with float capability. Better to have it and not need it, than need it and not have it.

Doug in SW IA
About a $300 price difference...that's beyond the "well...maybe I'll find a use for it...someday..." break point for me,lol.
 
   / Do I really need loader float if I have a box blade/rear blade? #5  
Does your loader have single acting cylinders for the boom?
If I recall correctly, most of those loaders had single acting cylinders in which case you wouldn't need float, but would recommend a single acting valve for the loader lift.



Sent from my SM-S921U using TractorByNet mobile app
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

IRanch Dump Hopper (A55851)
IRanch Dump Hopper...
2023 Stryker GN3614 36ft. 5 Ton T/A Gooseneck Flatbed Equipment Trailer (A51691)
2023 Stryker...
2021 Cat 259D3 (A53317)
2021 Cat 259D3...
2003 VOLVO VNL TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER TRUCK (A56138)
2003 VOLVO VNL...
2004 Jeep Liberty Limited SUV (A54815)
2004 Jeep Liberty...
2010 MAXEY WELDING 20 T/A GOOSENECK TRAILER (A55745)
2010 MAXEY WELDING...
 
Top