DIY Granite countertop?

[Citydude]

I don't care for that look in a finished house. Maybe a rustic cabin-type home, though.

That's where I seen it. In a mountain type home.

 

[ch1ch2]

The live edge seems like a cleaning nightmare and even worse for sanitation.

I guess sanitation might be a problem for a messy person whom eats off the edge of their counter top, or a clean freak that can't seem to get anything clean enough.

But for average people whom eat in public places and/or people whom clean up after themselves, I can't see where it would be much of a problem.
Touching your mouth, rubbing your eyes, touching your nose, would be a bigger sanitation problem.

 

[4570Man]

I guess sanitation might be a problem for a messy person whom eats of the edge of their counter top, or a clean freak that can't seem to get anything clean enough.

But for average people whom eat in public places and/or people whom clean up after themselves, I can't see where it would be much of a problem.
Touching your mouth, rubbing your eyes, touching your nose, would be a bigger sanitation problem.

I don’t disagree but why make something needlessly worse? I don’t like the looks anyway.

 

[ch1ch2]

I don’t disagree but why make something needlessly worse? I don’t like the looks anyway.

Yes, when I first saw it in my friends house, I did not like it and I wondered why they cut corners or tried to save money. But, in less that 10 minutes I began to like it. I liked it enough to ask my better half if she might want to do that in our house.

 

[s219]

The granite guy who worked on our house was having some sort of problem with drugs/money/women/whatever and was unreliable and did crappy work. Complete loser if you ask me. Among other problems, when we went to install the stove we discovered the opening was about 1/4" too narrow because the granite top on one side wasn't cut to the right size. Between me, the builder, and the cabinet shop, we had to fix several pieces, including cutting them down and polishing edges. I'd say it's well within the capability of a handy person as long as you have the tools.

 

[ch1ch2]

Still waiting for someone to offer the OP some advice on how to do it.

 

[4570Man]

He’s already been offered useful information in post 8, 9 and 13.

 

[ch1ch2]

I missed 8 and 9 some how.
It does not surprise me they were from MossRoad.
He is always helpful and always has good information.

 

[hawkeye08]

Definitely worth a try, take some pics..

 

[CADplans]

After having our kitchen changed to granite,, we wanted it for the vanity's in two bathrooms,,
The shop that does the granite charges a customer for an entire slab, no matter how much or little is used,,

THEN, they keep the drops, and sell them, also,,

They literally have TONS of drops accumulated,,
If they are not "sold", they gotta pay to dispose of them,,

We found two drops that we wanted,, the entire charge for material and finish work was about $150 per sink.
We even had a 4 inch high trim piece added for the two parts of the top that touched the wall.

I installed them,,

Then we found another piece that we had cut and finished to replace the glass top on a coffee table,,
I think that one was $50,,,

 

[4570Man]

After having our kitchen changed to granite,, we wanted it for the vanity's in two bathrooms,,
The shop that does the granite charges a customer for an entire slab, no matter how much or little is used,,

THEN, they keep the drops, and sell them, also,,

They literally have TONS of drops accumulated,,
If they are not "sold", they gotta pay to dispose of them,,

We found two drops that we wanted,, the entire charge for material and finish work was about $150 per sink.
We even had a 4 inch high trim piece added for the two parts of the top that touched the wall.

I installed them,,

Then we found another piece that we had cut and finished to replace the glass top on a coffee table,,
I think that one was $50,,,

The local shop or at least the best of them comes out and measures and builds a template to achieve a perfect fit on walls that aren’t usually square. Then they give an estimated by the SF based on the slab you want. There’s a big price difference on one slab to the next. I’m sure they’d give your drops back if you asked but how many people want those laying around. They’ve given me several sink cutouts. They make a good pizza store for a grill and a good base to attach sandpaper for sharpening.

 

[EddieWalker]

I do a fair number of kitchen remodels every year and most of the time it's one of two different granite companies. Usually it's a simple install that doesn't take a lot of modifying at the location, but every now and then, they run into an issue and they have to cut and polish it right there. They do all of it with a hand grinder. Cut it with a diamond cut off wheal, and then shape and polish it with a variety of different disks. One guy does all the grinder work, the other guy holds the shop vacuum right next to it.

I bought a wet polisher grinder that I attach my hose to keep everything wet while polishing concrete counter tops that I made once. The mess was beyond anything that I expected. It would probably do a really good job for this. I'll never use it again, so if you are in the Tyler area, I'll sell it to you for a good price. I just don't want to deal with shipping it.

 

[sandman2234]

Most of the slabs cut around here are done with a CNC cutter using a lot of liquid to keep the dust down. Granite is too expensive to risk doing it by hand on a commercial basis. For a one time deal, if you can't get it done by a local shop, then doing it by hand is an option. I cut a single piece and rounded the edge for a shower install, where a short wall was topped with glass. It wasn't as hard as I would have thought. As far as a sink opening, if sawing it isn't an option, a diamond hole saw would be a good start, I would think. Requires a very steady hand to feed it slowly enough to cut without burning up the bit. Slower speed than a typical drill press will turn also may be a problem. I am sure I could drop it on one of my milling machines and manage a reasonable hole, in case you want to come to Florida for a few days, lol.
Before you cut off the outside edge, use that as a test area for the type of cutters you want to try. It will make holding them easier.
David from jax

 

[STx]

I do a fair number of kitchen remodels every year and most of the time it's one of two different granite companies. Usually it's a simple install that doesn't take a lot of modifying at the location, but every now and then, they run into an issue and they have to cut and polish it right there. They do all of it with a hand grinder. Cut it with a diamond cut off wheal, and then shape and polish it with a variety of different disks. One guy does all the grinder work, the other guy holds the shop vacuum right next to it.

I bought a wet polisher grinder that I attach my hose to keep everything wet while polishing concrete counter tops that I made once. The mess was beyond anything that I expected. It would probably do a really good job for this. I'll never use it again, so if you are in the Tyler area, I'll sell it to you for a good price. I just don't want to deal with shipping it.

Thanks Eddie, I'm only about 6.5 hours, one way, from Tyler...lol. my dad is in DFW but, I bought the one off eBay, seems a good price for a tool I only need a few times.

Wet cutting/grinding/polishing is always a huge mess. I'm planning on doing it all outside.

 

[tjkubota93]

Theres a place called floor and decor that sells the tools for granite fab here.

I did alot of rough cuts on ours with an angle grinder and a turbo wheel. I even re-did the seam where I was unhappy with the discount guys we paid.

The cuts they made were with a little saw that looked like a mini skil saw with a diamond blade and a coke can full of water with a pencil size hole poked in the bottom.

You should be fine.

 

[ustmd]

STx,

I have been following your build.

I say go for it. What is the worst that can happen? You buy a $200 tool and spend 6-8 hours figuring out that you should have found a different solution.

The only thing I would be prepared for is that you may ruin the piece of granite you have.

Good luck and remember nothing counts unless you post pictures of it.

 

[Jchonline]

That's where I seen it. In a mountain type home.

No way my wife would let that jagged edge in our mountain home.....I guess everyone has their preferences!

 

[4570Man]

Most of the slabs cut around here are done with a CNC cutter using a lot of liquid to keep the dust down. Granite is too expensive to risk doing it by hand on a commercial basis. For a one time deal, if you can't get it done by a local shop, then doing it by hand is an option. I cut a single piece and rounded the edge for a shower install, where a short wall was topped with glass. It wasn't as hard as I would have thought. As far as a sink opening, if sawing it isn't an option, a diamond hole saw would be a good start, I would think. Requires a very steady hand to feed it slowly enough to cut without burning up the bit. Slower speed than a typical drill press will turn also may be a problem. I am sure I could drop it on one of my milling machines and manage a reasonable hole, in case you want to come to Florida for a few days, lol.
Before you cut off the outside edge, use that as a test area for the type of cutters you want to try. It will make holding them easier.
David from jax

I’m sure a milling machine and a diamond holesaw would work but I wouldn’t be big on the granite dust all over the mill.

 

[STx]

STx,

I have been following your build.

I say go for it. What is the worst that can happen? You buy a $200 tool and spend 6-8 hours figuring out that you should have found a different solution.

The only thing I would be prepared for is that you may ruin the piece of granite you have.

Good luck and remember nothing counts unless you post pictures of it.

Pretty much how I see it. If it works, I come out way ahead, if it doesn't, I still have a new tool and all I'm really out is a piece of scrap granite and some time.

 

[STx]

The local shop or at least the best of them comes out and measures and builds a template to achieve a perfect fit on walls that aren’t usually square. Then they give an estimated by the SF based on the slab you want. There’s a big price difference on one slab to the next. I’m sure they’d give your drops back if you asked but how many people want those laying around. They’ve given me several sink cutouts. They make a good pizza store for a grill and a good base to attach sandpaper for sharpening.

That's what they did for our kitchen and my plan. This bathroom is in the original part of the "house" that was once a storage building, the walls in there are not just put of square, they're more like freeform.