Compact Track Loader, whos the best?

   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #81  
Thanks for that info, I had no idea on the DPF system. My issue with that is that I hate to run engines wide open as I usually don't need that much power and I like to save fuel and wear and tear. The info on that filter is that they like to run warm in order to keep them clean.

Every diesel over 25 hp sold in America and several other countries since approximately 2010 I’m not sure about the exact date has a DPF.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #82  
New Holland is one i think we left of the list. They aren't really one of the more common ones, but if you have a dealer close, I wouldn't rule them out. They do appear to average a bit lighter for the same HP; which can be good or bad,View attachment 2207193
Was curious if Case/NH was going to come up. I have a Case TV450. Weighs in at 11,300 with suitcase weights. 90hp machine. I've looked into trading into the new 620B but the thought of having to move around a 16k lb machine has given me pause. 5 years and 700 hours so I don't use it much but has been a solid machine.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #83  
Was curious if Case/NH was going to come up. I have a Case TV450. Weighs in at 11,300 with suitcase weights. 90hp machine. I've looked into trading into the new 620B but the thought of having to move around a 16k lb machine has given me pause. 5 years and 700 hours so I don't use it much but has been a solid machine.

That’s a 150k machine and you need a CDL to move. I’d keep my current CTL and buy a 953 Cat before I bought one of those.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #84  
Every diesel over 25 hp sold in America and several other countries since approximately 2010 I’m not sure about the exact date has a DPF.
Not true, they simply have to meet Tier IV emissions requirements. My 2019 NH Workmaster 75 uses DOC/EGR technology, not DPF. No regens, not even a mention of emissions operations in the operator's manual. Other tractor manufacturers such as I believe Mahindra and Massey do the same.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best?
  • Thread Starter
#85  
Was curious if Case/NH was going to come up. I have a Case TV450. Weighs in at 11,300 with suitcase weights. 90hp machine. I've looked into trading into the new 620B but the thought of having to move around a 16k lb machine has given me pause. 5 years and 700 hours so I don't use it much but has been a solid machine.
I had not thought about case, I will take a look, but I don't need a big one over 10,000 LBS. Thanks for the info!
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #86  
I had not thought about case, I will take a look, but I don't need a big one over 10,000 LBS. Thanks for the info!
I've been very happy with it after 5 years of ownership. Controls are very tight and responsive. I'm not sure why Case does not come up more often. Maybe just a very low market share compared to the others? My previous Case was the TR340. Bought used and had it for 2 years before trading into a new TV450. So far good luck with both machines and price point was right compared to others.

For a smaller Case the TR270 comes in at 74 hp and around 8,200 lbs just fyi.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best?
  • Thread Starter
#87  
I've been very happy with it after 5 years of ownership. Controls are very tight and responsive. I'm not sure why Case does not come up more often. Maybe just a very low market share compared to the others? My previous Case was the TR340. Bought used and had it for 2 years before trading into a new TV450. So far good luck with both machines and price point was right compared to others.

For a smaller Case the TR270 comes in at 74 hp and around 8,200 lbs just fyi.
Thanks, I will look at it and glad to hear you have good luck with yours.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #88  
Dang, I didn't realize just how much the upper power machines had crept up. $147,031. Yes, it's AC and Heat, and 114hp, but its also 16,100 lbs, and it comes with just a bucket, although it includes teeth...
Screenshot_20250118_170545_Facebook.jpg
Screenshot_20250118_171058_Chrome.jpg
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #89  
Dang, I didn't realize just how much the upper power machines had crept up. $147,031. Yes, it's AC and Heat, and 114hp, but its also 16,100 lbs, and it comes with just a bucket, although it includes teeth...View attachment 2249060View attachment 2249061

I have approximately the same amount in all 3 of these machines combined as what that is. I don’t see how those big machines that cost double what a smaller CTL cost is economical. To make matters worse as far as most of the public is concerned all skid steers are the same. If a 75 is worth $100 an hour good luck getting $200 for the big ones.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8512.JPG
    IMG_8512.JPG
    1.8 MB · Views: 85
  • IMG_6654.JPG
    IMG_6654.JPG
    1 MB · Views: 92
Last edited:
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #90  
I have approximately the same amount in all 3 of these machines combined as what that is. I don’t see how those big machines that cost double what a smaller CTL cost is economical. To make matters worse as far as most of the public is concerned all skid steers and the same. If a 75 is worth $100 an hour good luck getting $200 for the big ones
In 2007-8 I was making $75/hr with a Cat-257 class machine, and honestly, just getting by. At the time, New, they were like $45k. Now, if i could have had it working 30 hrs per week, i would have been doing pretty well, but it was half side hustle, half start up...
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #91  
But I don't believe that New Holland will do 2.2x the amount of work the machine is linked earlier will.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #92  
I like Takeuchi. A Tak on tracks is tough to beat. I rent the TL12V2 regularly and as far as I have seen, it’s the heaviest & strongest and lifts the most. I think only ASV is bigger. There was one for sale at Deere Country for 39K with 2000 hours and Hi-flow that was really tempting to buy, but I’m saving for other equipment purchases.

I also demoed a JCB teleskid and it was nice, but at 79HP it lacked the power you need for those really tough jobs. The side entry and telescoping boom were incredibly nice features.
If they build a 100HP large frame skid loader with the boom and side door, they’d have something special.
 
Last edited:
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #93  
Every diesel over 25 hp sold in America and several other countries since approximately 2010 I’m not sure about the exact date has a DPF.
2012
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #94  
In 2007-8 I was making $75/hr with a Cat-257 class machine, and honestly, just getting by. At the time, New, they were like $45k. Now, if i could have had it working 30 hrs per week, i would have been doing pretty well, but it was half side hustle, half start up...
You were underselling yourself. You need to be making $1,000+ a day on a machine like that. I’d want to be making close to $150/hr in today’s high fuel cost, high parts & insurance cost market.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best?
  • Thread Starter
#95  
Dang, I didn't realize just how much the upper power machines had crept up. $147,031. Yes, it's AC and Heat, and 114hp, but its also 16,100 lbs, and it comes with just a bucket, although it includes teeth...View attachment 2249060View attachment 2249061

in price a bunch, I have three prices now and Cat comes in with the best price, and John Deere is the highest. They are not exact comparisons, and I think I am going with the Cat, but John Deere has a few things I wish I got on the Cat. I will share the prices when I am done. I wish I was good at the Art Of The Deal!
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best?
  • Thread Starter
#96  
These machines vary a bunch in price, but I have a few reasonable prices, and the best one I think is from Cat. I will let you know what I decide and the prices. Thanks for all your interest and great input.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #97  
You were underselling yourself. You need to be making $1,000+ a day on a machine like that. I’d want to be making close to $150/hr in today’s high fuel cost, high parts & insurance cost market.
Was talking to a guy Friday at work, and we were talking about exactly this. He said most guys are at $150/hr and 4 hour min. He said he's $300 to show, and $100/hr after first 3 hours. He also said he bills himself at $40/hr. We were also talking about another job he did that i was very familiar with, he bid and won at $12k, and the next closest was $20,000. Didnt knkw how to bring up to him, you got to bill yourself at more than $40... even of the other $60 covers the machine, insurance, fuel, ect, $40 isn't enough for your risk/time/head ache. We also discussed the constant, 2 days or a week later call, "I need you to come grade out some dump truck ruts, that's included in the price, right"

Friday as an example, he had meet client twice onsite, and me onsite, and he didn't even know if he was getting the job... and he's got 3+ hours in it,
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best?
  • Thread Starter
#98  
Was talking to a guy Friday at work, and we were talking about exactly this. He said most guys are at $150/hr and 4 hour min. He said he's $300 to show, and $100/hr after first 3 hours. He also said he bills himself at $40/hr. We were also talking about another job he did that i was very familiar with, he bid and won at $12k, and the next closest was $20,000. Didnt knkw how to bring up to him, you got to bill yourself at more than $40... even of the other $60 covers the machine, insurance, fuel, ect, $40 isn't enough for your risk/time/head ache. We also discussed the constant, 2 days or a week later call, "I need you to come grade out some dump truck ruts, that's included in the price, right"

Friday as an example, he had meet client twice onsite, and me onsite, and he didn't even know if he was getting the job... and he's got 3+ hours in it,
One of my biggest issues in business is the people who weasel a bunch of time out of me as they are either weasels or I am just too nice of a guy. I would have been long retired had I billed out my full hours over the years. I did not mind doing a bit extra, but it gets old after they pull that 3 or 4 times. I tell young people you need to look out for yourself!
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #99  
Was talking to a guy Friday at work, and we were talking about exactly this. He said most guys are at $150/hr and 4 hour min. He said he's $300 to show, and $100/hr after first 3 hours. He also said he bills himself at $40/hr. We were also talking about another job he did that i was very familiar with, he bid and won at $12k, and the next closest was $20,000. Didnt knkw how to bring up to him, you got to bill yourself at more than $40... even of the other $60 covers the machine, insurance, fuel, ect, $40 isn't enough for your risk/time/head ache. We also discussed the constant, 2 days or a week later call, "I need you to come grade out some dump truck ruts, that's included in the price, right"

Friday as an example, he had meet client twice onsite, and me onsite, and he didn't even know if he was getting the job... and he's got 3+ hours in it,
Whenever you bid yourself out by the hour, you instantly enter “the race to the bottom” because I guarantee you there’s a guy who is cheaper.
I tell other guys in these types of businesses we are in to bid by the job, not the hour. Bidding by the job guarantees the customer you'll complete the job, and guarantees you you know what you’ll make.
Let’s face it, even when you do bid by the hour, all customers want to know “ok, how many hours will it take?” If you bid by the job and you don’t tell them your rate, they don’t know how much you are making. You really want to avoid letting your customer find out you are charging them $150/hour because they will think youre making attorney money, because they don’t understand what it costs to own/operate a machine like that.
 
   / Compact Track Loader, whos the best? #100  
Every now and again, I'll see folks doing bush hogging for $35/hr....
 

Marketplace Items

405 (A52706)
405 (A52706)
209202 (A60429)
209202 (A60429)
KIVEL 48" PALLET FORKS 3500 LB CAP (A60430)
KIVEL 48" PALLET...
iDrive TDS-2010H ProJack M2 Electric Trailer Dolly (A59228)
iDrive TDS-2010H...
SKID STEER ATTACHMENT MULCHER (A58214)
SKID STEER...
2007 MACK GRANITE CV713 DUMP TRUCK (A60430)
2007 MACK GRANITE...
 
Top