Hmmm, seems that everyone in this discussion must be relatively new members. When the BX24 came out, these things were cracking left and right. There was thread after thread on this forum about this. First, Kubota balked, then they made a retrofit reinforcement piece, then they made a new fender that was beefier and had structural reinforcement ribs in the mold for the fender. The later BX24s had this beefier fender put on them when manufactured and anyone with a broken older one got it replaced for free. In doing this, they have already established that they had a flawed product and they have established extensive precedent in remedying the problem.
When the BX25 came out, the plastic had been done away with and the BX came full circle back to metal fenders. Several of the engineering section heads who had pushed so hard for plastic were even fired during a small reorganization.
Perhaps they wanted this replacement to have a closure of time period. Quite a few folks got hurt when they stepped on the floorboard, the fender cracked, the floorboard fell, and there was an injury. This was a very big problem for them. Maybe they think you don't know about all this history. Go back, search the archives, and read how bad it was. Then let them know that you are aware of it and that you have plenty of ammo to play legal hardball if needed. I would not go in guns blazing, however let them know you know the full story now, then start to slowly tighten the screws until there is enough pressure for them to cave.
Does anyone know if Kubota is replacing the floorboard/fender units out of warranty. I fell off of mine today after the floorboard gave way. I asked about this at the dealer about a year ago after a friend's cracked. {They replaced his} I was told that some were built with reinforcments and some without, If I did not recieve anything from Kubota I shouldnt worry about it. Well, I took them at their word and today I fell flat on my back, if not for the snow behind me it would have been much worse. Monday I am storming to my dealer to insist on replacment even though out of warranty by 6 months or so. Anyone know if Kubota has a "secret" warranty to replace these?
Dokako