Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used

   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #1  

mf40diesel

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
27
Location
western, ME
Tractor
Massey Ferguson 461, mfwd
Hello All... Need some advice.

I am a pretty sizeable tractor lover.. been in love with them my whole life. Have had two now... first a '52 Ford 8n... and now a 1971 Massey Ferguson 40 Industrial. The massey was a disaster when I bought it, still looks horrid- needs a painting really bad, however it runs perfect. Rebuilt the engine, brakes and countless other things. Some big things are still bad, and the loader is totally hammered to death. I want to upgrade again. I really want 4wd, as the Massey is clearly 2wd and therefore about worthless in the woods. ( I mostly use the tractor for gathering firewood (hauling tree length trees) then moving cut wood, Landscaping in the summer, road maintenance, I have a micro small business bushhogging some friends fields, and moving snow in the winter.

I am currently looking at a 1994 John Deere 5200, 4100 hours MFWD (turf tires so I need to swap them for some R1 or R4's) previously owned by a golf course. Allegedly they take really good care of their stuff. It has the 9X3 synchro tranny. I am having a great repoir with the guy selling it, and quite honestly would really like to shake the guys hand.

On the other hand... a really late model Massey Ferguson 2615. Power Shuttle tranny (I really like that).. I guess really thats the best part. That and the fact that its super new and would likely last years and years.

The other aspect... Although I am really not happy about alot that our government is doing, I do love the USA. The deere was made in the USA... the Massey (like the new deeres of the same size) made in India. While I have no problem with India.. I seem to really want the US made machine more..... but I really want that power shuttle!

The big problem: Can I really justify the new Massey simply cause I want it? Any advice would be great.

Probably the quality-control of the massey from india is better than the Deere from the States... probably the sad part.

Thanks in advance.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #2  
the 4100 hours on the deere would be a deal breaker for me. I recently bought a Kubota L3200 and really love the little beast. I'm not sure how you can justify the shuttle shift, but thats my first choice as well.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #3  
No contest. Get the Massey.

(Many US manufacturers source their tractors world wide.)
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used
  • Thread Starter
#4  
I know.... Pretty much all of them are. Built overseas. The ship I work on.. US co. Japanese made ship... Currently in a Korean shipyard.

The Massey wins... I kinda hoped it would. I really love my Massey, if it were 4wd drills, and in much much better overall condition I'd keep it forever.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used
  • Thread Starter
#5  
How bout a deere 5045 vs massey 2615???? Both Indian made.. Pretty close specs.
 
   / Buying advice... Utility Tractor New vs Used #6  
Difference for me was that Buying used allowed me to get my wants while new would have only covered my needs. I found my current tractor with a cab (want), hst+ (want), auto throttle advance (want) with only 290 hrs for what a stripped down open station new tractor would have run me.

YMMV
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2017 Ford Explorer AWD SUV (A51694)
2017 Ford Explorer...
JOHN DEERE CP 770 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE CP 770...
2020 KUBOTA RTV X1100C UTV (A51406)
2020 KUBOTA RTV...
SELLICK S80T4E-4PS ROUGH TERRAIN FORKLIFT (A51246)
SELLICK S80T4E-4PS...
2011 CATERPILLAR 140M2 MOTORGRADER (A51246)
2011 CATERPILLAR...
PALLET OF PORTABLE AC UNITS (A51248)
PALLET OF PORTABLE...
 
Top