10w-40 VS 15W-40

[frank_f15]

DECIDED TO POST THIS QUESTION ON THIS FORUM,probably gets the most hits.my manual call for 10w-30 or 10w-40, very hard to find. can find 15w-40 easily. my question is how much difference can this possibly make? i mean 10w vs.15w cna't make that much diff. tractor is garage kept, average winter temp is 15 to 30 deg. with a few days in the single digits. don't want to start a oil war on brands and such just a simple ans. IS THERE THAT MUCH DIFF?

 

[karmakanic]

no

 

[ScottAR]

nope... Been using 15w-40 in the 1050 since day one. My manual lists different oils for different temp ranges. 15w-40 fits right in with mine which is about 5deg-104deg.

 

[jhburke]

I just had a 200 hr done on my Kubota B7500 today. The dealer used 15-40 when he changed the motor oil. It must be good enough for them.

 

[frank_f15]

thats what i like! short and sweet and to the point. that is what i thought. so today i bought NAPA 15W-40 (made by ashland aka valvoline) and a napa gold filter(made by wix) total cost $13.50. after doing some research decided that the oil and filter was basically the same as the name brands at a more moderate cost+ only 3 mi. from home.agree? disagree?

 

[hwp]

I agree with you Frank. I use store brand 15W-40 diesel in the winter, store brand 20W-50 diesel in the summer and store brand (Fram) filters. Haven't had any problems.

 

[Jeff396]

I think I remember this coming up before. Someone said that the 10w30 and 10w40 motor oils for diesels were commonly available overseas which is why it's in the manuals for our tractors who are headquartered there. I went ahead and used Rotella 15w40 but stuck with the Kubota filters all around along with super udt. Not too bad until you get to the air filters!/w3tcompact/icons/shocked.gif

Jeff

 

[karmakanic]

Agreed on the oil.

Not so sure on the Wix. Try this experiment. Invest the cost of an OE filter and compare the weight. Use both filters, but buy the heavier in the future.

You'll be fine which ever filter you use, as long as you change it often. But you'll feel better.

/w3tcompact/icons/grin.gif,
Dave

 

[NY_Yankees_Fan]

Ok to use the 15W-40 year round??

Tom

 

[karmakanic]

I'd say yes in New Jersey. No in Alaska. I use 20-50 here in Texas year around.

I personally think as long as you're not having any problems starting on cold winter days, your weight is light enough.

(unless you're running a Corvette or Porsche or something else with .0005 main bearing clearances, then you need the 10 or even 5 weight.)

Dave

 

[frank_f15]

DAVE: the filter i took off was kubota, it was slightly heavier but that was probably from the oil that was still in it, also it was marked"made in u.s.a" if so then by whom? i agree, change the oil and filter often, for that amt.of $ and a 1/2 hr work , cheap insurance

 

[ScottAR]

Wix is fine. It's a staple company in the industrial and heavy truck arenas...