Just watched Pale Rider.
mark
50 years late is better than never!
I love all those old Eastwood westerns. Josey Wales, Pale Rider, For a Few Dollars More... but I'd guess it's debatable whether they're "good movies" in some regards. They're infinitely enjoyable, but there sure are a lot of holes in plot and historical accuracy.
Of course, there's the mother of them all, "The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly". IMO, that one really set the type for all the rest, and really
is an objectively good movie.
"Good" might have to be defined by the audience. I was just talking about an older animated film called Leap with my daughter, it was her favorite movie when she was little, and it is quite good. I wouldn't watch it alone as an adult, but it was a great movie to watch with kids.
On the far end of the spectrum is Deliverance, which many hold up as a "great movie", but I never want to watch that one again.
Speaking of westerns, I think Kurt Russell's Tombstone has to be one of the best westerns ever made, for a very good mix of historical accuracy, set and scene, script, acting... that one sort of hit the perfect compromise of all factors, for me. Val Kilmer's Doc Holiday was so different, and so perfect, in that movie. The more you read about Wyatt Earp's story, the more you realize how every part of the script of that movie was based on true history, rather than dramatization.
Then again, Clint was a better "tough guy" than Kurt Russell, every day.
