Welding dissimilar thickness materials?

/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #1  

dragoneggs

Super Star Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
14,548
Location
Seabeck, Washington
Tractor
Kubota BX-25D, Kubota Z122RKW-42
Okay another post to get some chatter going... what are folks thoughts on welding dissimilar thickness mild steel (and aluminum if different). Just wondering about any tricks or techniques that make for an optimum weld in these situations. For instance I am making a stand for my grinder. I have a piece of 12x12x1/2in plate for the bottom and some 2in square tube 1/8in wall for the post. I plan to butt the post against the center of the plate.

So, I have 1/8in edge weld to 1/2in field. Should I just weld as I would putting two 1/8in together, or do I increase volts, wire speed, change angle of MIG gun? Appreciate your thoughts and reasons.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #2  
I would probably have the plate lying on the welding table and the tube standing on it, I would concentrate my weld on the thicker plate and weave into the tube to tie it together.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #3  
I just focus the arc on the thicker part and wash the puddle over to the thinner part being careful not to blow through.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #4  
I run a J pattern. Keep the long side of the J on the thicker material. Let the curl of the J bounce onto the thinner material.
 

Attachments

  • J-motion.jpg
    J-motion.jpg
    12.5 KB · Views: 196
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials?
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Yep thanks, mud and yo! My plan so far... wondering if my voltage or wire speed should be different than if I was doing 1/8 to 1/8? I think I will leave it as I normally do... rather than get cute and risk a blow out.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
I run a J pattern. Keep the long side of the J on the thicker material. Let the curl of the J bounce onto the thinner material.
Makes sense, I will try that motion... thanks SA.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #7  
Best to weld a bit at a time and allow to cool if you intend to have that 1/2" 12"x12" plate sit flat on the floor.

Or you could weld a heavy washer on the underside of each corner (of the base) if needed.

OR not sure if you intend on mounting the plate on something else..?

I welded 1/2" plate onto an angle iron base for my grinder. Photo shows the underside before welding.

IMG_1352.JPGIMG_1462.JPG
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials?
  • Thread Starter
#8  
Best to weld a bit at a time and allow to cool if you intend to have that 1/2" 12"x12" plate sit flat on the floor.

Or you could weld a heavy washer on the underside of each corner (of the base) if needed.
I'm thinking of some hard rubber bushings mounted on some (Click Bond) adhesive bonded studs so I don't have drill in my concrete slab like I did with my compact bender. I'll post some pics if folks are interested in the bonded mounting solution.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #9  
Best to weld a bit at a time and allow to cool if you intend to have that 1/2" 12"x12" plate sit flat on the floor.
Perfect opportunity to play with some heat shrinking. :thumbsup:
 

Attachments

  • Heat shrink 2 gap.jpg
    Heat shrink 2 gap.jpg
    80 KB · Views: 223
  • Heat shrink 3.JPG
    Heat shrink 3.JPG
    237.4 KB · Views: 220
  • Heat shrink spray.JPG
    Heat shrink spray.JPG
    225.8 KB · Views: 241
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #10  
I'm thinking of some hard rubber bushings mounted on some (Click Bond) adhesive bonded studs so I don't have drill in my concrete slab like I did with my compact bender. I'll post some pics if folks are interested in the bonded mounting solution.

I like that idea as opposed to drilling. DO post the pics. That might be a good solution for a lot of applications.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #11  
Perfect opportunity to play with some heat shrinking. :thumbsup:

Done that quite a few times. Actually enjoyable when you're retired and have more patience.
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #12  
Perfect opportunity to play with some heat shrinking. :thumbsup:

OK, you brought it up so now you have to explain it to us amateurs like myself - hows it work, sounds interesting!
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #13  
I like that idea as opposed to drilling. DO post the pics. That might be a good solution for a lot of applications.


Click and Bond is awesome!!! Best way to add lights to a roll bar or places you don't want to weld or drill! GREAT product!
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #14  
OK, you brought it up so now you have to explain it to us amateurs like myself - hows it work, sounds interesting!
Little heat in the correct place, then a little water. Heat = metal expands. Cold water = metal retracts. ;)
 

Attachments

  • Angle Iron fast.JPG
    Angle Iron fast.JPG
    14.9 KB · Views: 139
  • Angle Iron slow.JPG
    Angle Iron slow.JPG
    15.9 KB · Views: 135
  • Beam 1.JPG
    Beam 1.JPG
    220.8 KB · Views: 189
  • Beam 2.jpg
    Beam 2.jpg
    161.3 KB · Views: 173
  • Box tube circle.jpg
    Box tube circle.jpg
    25.5 KB · Views: 162
  • Box tube slow.JPG
    Box tube slow.JPG
    37.5 KB · Views: 148
  • Box tube.JPG
    Box tube.JPG
    29 KB · Views: 145
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #15  
Very interesting - thank you
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #16  
This is a good book on heat shrinking! ;)
 

Attachments

  • Sink or Swim.JPG
    Sink or Swim.JPG
    57.2 KB · Views: 159
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #17  
SA got me onto that book, very comprehensive and it does work. Another trick we used on piping was to place a welding rod under the center of the weld and either weld or clamp the ends. Square plate, put a washer under the center and weld or clamp down the corners.

Ron
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #19  
Mark, its cheap at half the price as my old man used to say. Better than counting sheep and worth it if you only use one idea from it, it covers a myriad of subjects. Bought mine on Amazon. Try the washer idea of mine. Worst case you still have to shrink it.

Ron
 
/ Welding dissimilar thickness materials? #20  
A lot of times, I have used weld to pull a bent piece back in place. Making small beads and cooling works pretty good. A rosebud and a squirt bottle for flat metal. Have to be careful and not over do it. I have seen folks try the heat and cold rag trick to straighten out autobody panels. You look like a genius when it works like you want it, get carried away with the heat and you can also make a mess in a hurry.
 

Marketplace Items

2017 Freightliner M2 106 AWD Terex Hi-Ranger 5TC55 55ft. Insulated Material Handling Bucket Truck (A60460)
2017 Freightliner...
2012 Kia Optima Sedan (A61569)
2012 Kia Optima...
MORBARK WOOD HOG 6400 XT HORIZONTAL GRINDER (A60429)
MORBARK WOOD HOG...
13042tx (A55973)
13042tx (A55973)
2018 Volvo VNL 760 T/A Sleeper Cab Truck Tractor (A61568)
2018 Volvo VNL 760...
Paladin 12in Digging Tooth Bucket Excavator Attachment (A60352)
Paladin 12in...
 
Top