JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks?

/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #1  

Carl Bert

Platinum Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2010
Messages
852
Location
Rockland county, New York
Tractor
Kubota B26, John deere X595
Thinking about purchasing a mulching kit for my 62" deck. I was just wondering if it's worth the $225 that it costs. Also does it effect the quality of the cut at all?

Any input would be appreciated, thanks
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #2  
In terms of cut quality they are pretty good. You do need to look at the pro's and con's of mulching which can very depending on your perspective. Mulching promotes growth so may find yourself mowing more often, Mulching does not work all that well when you have to cut more than 1/3 height of your grass as it can clump,you may find yourself mowing slower than before, In the future you may need to look at de-thatching or aeriation as the thatch level builds up. I have always preferred mulching over bagging because I hate handling the grass an extra time and then finding a place to put it.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #3  
I have always bagged! Here in the South we have fungus issues with fescue.

When I picked up the new mower (54" deck), couldn't get the bragger right away so I am mulching. Love it!!!

Grass is cut so fine that it's hard to fine on the driveway.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #4  
I have the mulch kit on my X740, 62" deck and like it.
The first few years I had this rig, I used Gator blades and they did ok. I added the JD mulch kit nearly two years ago and have not removed it since.
I love not having to worry about where the cut grass is being blown (the kit blocks the deck chute) and the yard looks cleaner after mowing. The Gators would leave some visible cuttings, while the mulch kit doesn't UNLESS the grass is too tall.
I do have to go slower with the mulch kit. A little too fast and the deck won't cut the grass: just presses it down and the blade cutting edge passes over before the grass stands back up. My yard is nearly 3 acres and it takes me about 20 minutes longer to mow with the mulch kit but the yard looks nicer. You do have to use the special blades supplied in the mulch kit. Gator or standard blades would cut into the baffles of the mulch kit.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks?
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Thanks guys, I do believe I will be adding the mulching kit. I just bought the lawn striping kit. Not very happy with it. I thought it was set up on a spring mount, where you can engage and disengage it when you want to use it. This thing takes the place of the rear deck wheels, and whats worse you can't raise it up as high as the deck wheels because it runs under part of the deck. I have a rocky ramp that I have to climb to get to my back property. As it is the deck wheels get in the way, if I don't raise them. This thing will be catching on to everything in its path. I guess its going back.

Thanks again for the mulching advice.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #6  
I have the mulch kit and have used it for a couple of years and had decent results. This spring I bought the MC 519 cart and a set of standard blades. I had planned on bagging two or three times a year and mulching the rest of the time. Now I think I will bag the entire summer and add the clippings to my top dressing pile along with the pine needles I collect. After this breaks down properly I plan to apply it in the late fall in a thin layer 1/4 to 1/2" thick. I don't need any lime but do need the acid so the pine straw will be a plus for me. By next year in the fall I should have about 50 yards of top dressing available and each year thereafter. This way the clippings are not hauled away and are reused instead. I get steer and chicken manure from a neighbor and lots of green manure from the landscape projects too. I am payed $10/yd for the pine needles hauled off customer lawns, I in turn use this money for fertilizer. The hauling fees take care of the transporting costs.

That said I can see where most people would want to use mulching blades to reduce handling and still get a nice appearance. I would do that too but it seems to take alot longer to break down in the arid climate here.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #7  
Once your set up for mulching, how hard would it be go back to bagging? How hard is it to remove the mulching plug? Do the blades have to be changed back as well?
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #8  
Once your set up for mulching, how hard would it be go back to bagging? How hard is it to remove the mulching plug? Do the blades have to be changed back as well?


The mulching plug bolts on the lower deck easily, blades need to be changed too. Maybe a 20 to 30 minute job at most.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #9  
The mulching plug bolts on the lower deck easily, blades need to be changed too. Maybe a 20 to 30 minute job at most.

I had an 850A with mulch kit. Took me 5 minutes to remove the discharge chute plug and about 45 minutes to remove the under deck baffles. Greg
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #10  
Just purchased a x720 with a 54" deck with the mulch kit. Has worked great with no clumping and the lawn looks great. I have a sandy garden and the mulch help hold the moisture in and I don't have to fertilize as much. Kit is real easy to remove. Paid $196 and the dealer installed it for me but believe me the hardest part of the installation is changing the blades. Make sure you keep the orginal blades.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #11  
I had the mulching kit on my 54. Hated it. Have to cut to often. I took the shoot cover off and changed blades. Left the rest on it. Works good now and I don't have to rake or bag.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #12  
Had the kit on x740 w/54c for 6 years, mowing 3 acres. Was a little concerned with being made totally of plastic, but little to no wear to date. Wanted to try the mulch kit to see if it helped with the stuff being sucked up to the operators area to the radiator! Seems to have helped that area and not as "dirty" mowing, etc. Pros=good cut with no wind rowing or bagging, less cleanup, mow in either direction because of no side discharge, mulches leaves. Cons= Frequent under deck clean outs, can't let grass get too tall (1/3 grass height). Removal not too bad but only do maybe once a year, couple wing nuts and a wrench for clip on outside deck edge. I am blessed to have a lift in my shop, so clean out under deck not a big deal, other than time/effort. I have gone to mulch blades only whether kit is installed or not, you CAN'T use regular blade with kit! BTDT I guess I like it because it's on 95% of the time. Only times I've had to remove is during spring when rains were coming often enough to tighten mowing window plus turf growing like crazy. EASY ON THE FERTILIZER!
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks?
  • Thread Starter
#13  
Ok I bought and installed the mulching kit. Tried it today and was very impressed. Grass actually disappears. I'm not concerned about what the other posters said about having to mow at a slower speed and mowing more often. I already mow at a moderate speed, and as far as mowing more often, well as far as I'm concerned, I can't wait for the grass to grow. I love mowing the lawn, it is very relaxing to me. I always thought I should do it as a side job, but I guess that would take the enjoyment out of it.

I went into the dealer looking to purchase a 7 iron deck. I heard that they have a much higher blade speed giving you a finer cut. Plus I love the drive over feature. The dealer wasn't able to find the deck speed on my 62C, but what he did find was that it didn't fit my X595. Very disappointing. So I bought the mulching kit. Thanks everyone.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #14  
Carl,
Man that is the important thing, if you are happy with the results then all is good.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #15  
I mowed my lawn while the grass was still wet, so I removed my deck with the mutch kit installed. This was the first time I removed the deck on my x720 and was surprised how easy it was. Only problem is, the deck is heavy. I found that the mulch kit is super easy to remove and reinstall. It does protect some of the bottom of the deck and even though it is plastic, it is heavy plastic. The kit works great and doesn't leave chippings that I can see. I have lots of sand that love to eat the blades but my mulching blades were good as new. By the way, when the manual suggests that you wear gloves when handling the blades, it is a great idea.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #16  
Has anyone tried mulching blades with the power blower/bagger system attached?

Has anyone tried just putting mulching blades and making a tin plug for the deck? It sounds hillbilly, but I did it many moons ago on a cheap mtd non mulching walk behind mower decks, I got pretty good results. Thats when I lived in the city.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #17  
Has anyone tried mulching blades with the power blower/bagger system attached?

Has anyone tried just putting mulching blades and making a tin plug for the deck? It sounds hillbilly, but I did it many moons ago on a cheap mtd non mulching walk behind mower decks, I got pretty good results. Thats when I lived in the city.

I was thinking the same thing and am looking for people who have tried that. I will regurgitate this and maybe someone will have an idea about just putting a plate on the chute before I actually mess around a lot trying it.
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #18  
I have an x540 with mulching kit & was dissapointed in what the "kit" consisted of when it'd been fitted. I used to run a billygoat 33" pedestrian mower that had a simple blanking plate to convert to it from a side discharge to mulching, and it worked great!
I'd Go with the tin sheet option!
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #19  
On my cheapo LA145 with 48" deck, the JD mulching adapter included is just a molded plastic blanking plate that has two bungee cords with hooks to hold it in place. It's well made: rounded to the deck shape, fits above and inside the deck's flared bottom, has heavy duty rubber bungees and mounting hardware.

I just used this last week on 1/2 acre yard and noticed that the grass and leaves were mulched up into a fine particle size. It does take a couple of slow passes to get full mulching accomplished, and the deck needs to be down low at around 2" so the leaves and grass don't escape the deck before being chopped. However, this simple feature along with the combo JD blades work very well on my leaves. The only places I rake leaves is out of flower beds and tight spots where I can't go with the mower. My wife even commented on how nice our yard looked when I finished.:thumbsup:
 
/ JD mulching kits, are they worth the bucks? #20  
548088164. My wife even commented on how nice our yard looked when I finished.:thumbsup:

Good Evenin Jim,
Its allways good to keep the wifey happy !

To add something too this thread, I have the mulching kit on my C-125 Wheel Horse and it works great, it really chops the leaves up into very small pieces ! Worth the money IMO...
 
Last edited:
 
Top