RRR,
Exactly my fear...
I have another thread about an older 18hp Craftsman II with a 42" deck, front blade, rear blade, jake rake, disc, single bottom plow (I think that is all the attachments) that is probably GREAT in the garden, but too small for everything else, and I've likely got too much invested in it to keep it (I'm trying to figure out it's value).
I've already got a nice Deere LX266 16 hp mower for some of the "yard work"...
I'm really looking for that impossible "perfect" size I guess...
Heck, I probably can't afford a 50hp tractor even at 0%...
Maybe I'm in over my head...
It is almost always a balancing act. Some people can "do it all" quite well with one tractor and some can't. My father in law traded a MF 375 open station in on a cabbed Case CX70. I told him he should keep the smaller tractor as there were places we simply could not fit the bigger tractor. About two weeks after he made the trade, he had to go back and buy his old tractor back at a significant cost. We have kept a minimum of two tractors and lawn mower on that property ever since.
A lot of things go into buying the best tractor for any individual, so "go bigger/more HP is not always going to be the best advice just as "go smaller/less HP". I once bought a smaller tractor than I originally wanted and once went bigger and was right both times. The variables you mentioned do not lend themselves to simplistic answers.
Depends on what you qualify as "bigger".....
A too small tractor is pretty much gonna suck EVERYWHERE....
Better to err slightly on the big side than to err on the small side....
Oh....and did I mention I tilled my garden this year with an 85hp tractor....Some would say that's WAY too big. Didn't seem to slow me down, get in the way, or "suck" in any way, shape or form...And I mow the yard with a 47hp/5200lb tractor.....with no "sucking" there either.
I bought a "little" Kubota 7510 last fall, just to have a small tractor. After being used to "bigger" tractors to do the same jobs I bought the Kubota for (the 47hp one I mentioned) that "little Kubota is just about useless.....
Pretty much; think I said that: "Bigger isn't
always better, sometimes, it is just bigger." So it seems by definition, I accept that
sometimes it is.
My brothers live on one of our farms and the M8540 is totally useless as I can't even get close to their yards, homes etc. and would have to drive it through crops to get where they bush hog, so they use much smaller tractors Ford 600s in addition to a couple of open station 70 HP tractors. I have to really watch it taking my
L5030 in there.
I too have mowed my yard with a big tractor, Case CX80 with a cab, but it would tear up the ground on my brothers' yards due to a different soil type.
The biggest tractor we can get in my mother's garden is a
BX2660 and she doesn't even like it in there preferring at the age of 89 to work it up with a spade.
We don't have as many tractors and probably not as much land as you and I know we do different things, so what works for you may not work for us.
Of course I always must leave open the possibility I don't know what the heck I am talking about.