Several places including Menards sell the Pleasant Hearth brand and they appeared lighter duty and lower build quality units. The Menards price on this one was $25 -$40 off other places. For example
HD sells the same grate for ~$100. It is supposed to be HD, so went for it due to size, specs., price and web reviews.
Thanks for the input. We will probably burn between 1.5 to 2 chords a year based on this second winter living in our present home. I will continue to look for a heavy duty grate or perhaps get one custom made prior to this one getting totally shot. This hopefully works out for a few years.