To Buy or to Rent?

   / To Buy or to Rent? #11  
I used to think the same way. A year later I added the backhoe. Now , without reservation, I WILL admit, I was wrong. It's a lifesaver.
 
   / To Buy or to Rent? #12  
So much depends on what a person's needs are. If you need to do a lot of 3PH work, it can be a PITA to deal with a backhoe. On smaller tractors, the BH can limit what you can do.

I have done less than $700 of BH work in the last 9 years so a BH is not a sensible investment for my needs.

I can see it as essential for others.
 
   / To Buy or to Rent? #13  
As others have said, it depends on your needs/use. I was talked out of a BH by this forum buying my NX6010. It was the right decision. But an also "right" decision for me was buying a smaller, used JD a few years ago with a hoe on it. I use it all the time, it's a smaller tractor so useful for moving things around using the FEL, but most of the use is the hoe. If I had to put the hoe on/off every time, I'd use it 1/2 as much. It's so convenient though, just walk up to the barn, fire up the tractor, drive it where I need a hole, dig, put it back.

I've rented a mini-ex as well for bigger tasks, and it's a wonderful machine, but about 4X the price about 1/2 as flexible as my little 2720. Also digs about 8X as fast. :)

I live where we have red clay as our "dirt". Digging a hole for a 3 gallon tree without a hoe is back breaking. Doing 10 in a day would be a trip to the hospital. I use the hoe all the time to pull out and put in trees, it's incredibly useful.

And, laughably, the tractor with the hoe is worth more today than when I bought it. I did have to put around 2K into it over the past 5 years in maintenance, but I'm still money ahead. And I have a hoe at the ready. Which means I can nearly throw my shovel away! It's saved me a lot of money on rentals, and probably even more on doctor's bills.
 
   / To Buy or to Rent? #14  
As others have said, it depends on your needs/use. I was talked out of a BH by this forum buying my NX6010. It was the right decision. But an also "right" decision for me was buying a smaller, used JD a few years ago with a hoe on it. I use it all the time, it's a smaller tractor so useful for moving things around using the FEL, but most of the use is the hoe. If I had to put the hoe on/off every time, I'd use it 1/2 as much. It's so convenient though, just walk up to the barn, fire up the tractor, drive it where I need a hole, dig, put it back.

I've rented a mini-ex as well for bigger tasks, and it's a wonderful machine, but about 4X the price about 1/2 as flexible as my little 2720. Also digs about 8X as fast. :)

I live where we have red clay as our "dirt". Digging a hole for a 3 gallon tree without a hoe is back breaking. Doing 10 in a day would be a trip to the hospital. I use the hoe all the time to pull out and put in trees, it's incredibly useful.

And, laughably, the tractor with the hoe is worth more today than when I bought it. I did have to put around 2K into it over the past 5 years in maintenance, but I'm still money ahead. And I have a hoe at the ready. Which means I can nearly throw my shovel away! It's saved me a lot of money on rentals, and probably even more on doctor's bills.
What's a shovel? ... My manual labor digging is very little now. Smarter not harder as I get older. That mini has saved me alot.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2018 Ford Explorer AWD SUV (A48082)
2018 Ford Explorer...
72in Bucket (A49251)
72in Bucket (A49251)
10-16.5 Tires on Wheels (A49251)
10-16.5 Tires on...
1998 Kenworth T800 Wet Kit Tri Axle Day Cab Truck Tractor (A46683)
1998 Kenworth T800...
2020 Toro Grounds Master 7200 72in Zero Turn Commercial Mower (A46684)
2020 Toro Grounds...
2018 GMC SAVANA 3500 16FT BOX TRUCK (A45679)
2018 GMC SAVANA...
 
Top