I'm kind of in the same boat and contemplating swapping my setup. I have a 2013
L3800 w/FEL, BH and 5' rotary cutter with 700hrs. The place I'm looking to buy has a JD 4044R with FEL and 6' rotary with 85 hours that they're willing to sell with the property.
Although the HP between the two isn't very different, the capacities are, including hydraulic GPM, FEL lift, 3-pt lift etc. The
L3800 has been great, but the FEL capacity is anemic and has always disappointed me.
Although the new place would be more acreage 20 vs. our current 7, it's fully developed and really doesn't have many projects left to do, outside of getting our garden set up. It mainly just requires periodic brush hogging and box blading the gravel drive. I'm leaning towards just staying with the
L3800.
I'll be gaining a son-in-law soon that has a 100hp skid steer, so he can handle any of the larger stuff.