Winches self release snatch block problem

[Agvg]

https://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/attachments/318085-my-new-igland-norse-snatch.html

Some pics of mine

 

[Hoobie]

Maybe....


View attachment 628492


Dale

just to clarify that picture I sent is just to show the choker sliders. It coincidentally picked up the snatch block strapped on side of the winch where I store it when not in use.

Hoobie

 

[bcp]

Turn the snatch block over so the cable falls down and away when it comes off.



Bruce

 

[Agvg]

Should not matter, when it hits the realease cable will jump off.

 

[bcp]

I like to have gravity helping me.

Bruce

 

[Gordon Gould]

I like to have gravity helping me.

Bruce

That is what I always thought too. I always put the cable down. But after I watched that Igland video I wondered if maybe due to gravity the heavy snatch block actually falls faster than the suddenly limp and relatively light cable. Looking at their video it seems that it doesn't matter which way it goes.

gg

 

[bcp]

From:
Three Rivers Forestry

"When obstacles prevent direct winching, or when the remaining trees are to be protected from damage, a self-releasing snatch block should be used. The Farmi snatch block releases the cable when the keyhole slider reaches it. The snatch block is attached to an anchor tree with a nylon strap which prevents damage to the tree. The automatic cable release works only when the pulley is turned upside down, which is when the release mechanism is facing the ground. "


Bruce

 

[WranglerX]

How are the ramps on base plate?.... Are sliders catching on base before trippin release?

Dale

 

[Gordon Gould]

From:
Three Rivers Forestry

"When obstacles prevent direct winching, or when the remaining trees are to be protected from damage, a self-releasing snatch block should be used. The Farmi snatch block releases the cable when the keyhole slider reaches it. The snatch block is attached to an anchor tree with a nylon strap which prevents damage to the tree. The automatic cable release works only when the pulley is turned upside down, which is when the release mechanism is facing the ground. "


Bruce

I know - I used to believe that until I saw the video. I am not trying to argue. I just find it interesting food for thought.

Edit: We are talking about an Ingland S/Blk here and if Ingland makes a promotional video showing the open face up it should be safe to assume it is OK the use the Ingland S/Blk that way.

gg

 

[Rustyiron]

View attachment 628427

Maybe that worked

Looking at this pic ^^^ now on a desktop computer, it sure does appear that those sliders are for a much bigger mainline cable than on our 3 pt winches use. Could there be enough "slop" with a small cable in this big slider that the slider is hitting the body of the snatch block, stoping it there instead of releasing the guide in another in or so of travel?
It's hard to judge the size from a photo, but that scenario seems like a possibility. There's a pic on the above link to 3 rivers forestry of the 2 sizes of sliders that they offer illustrating the size difference.