linuxman51
Gold Member
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2012
- Messages
- 300
- Location
- Montgomery, AL
- Tractor
- craftsman lt1000/jd 717a/ mahindra max26 hst
what is the anticipated price hike for tier iv? (vs say the same model machine prior to)
what is the anticipated price hike for tier iv? (vs say the same model machine prior to)
I can't believe people are still arguing about SCUT vs CUT vs full CAT 1 capable, etc...
From a marketing point of view, what Mahindra did was brilliant. In marketing, people make decisions based on comparisons. Therefore, if you can control how your product is compared to other products, you can control the value proposition to your advantage.
Kubota's brand/reputation is hard to overcome. Compared to a B series Kubota, the MAX is just "cheaper" but about equal in capabilities. But compared to a BX, the MAX series appear to be MUCH more capable at a similar price. For many people, this would be a better deal.
Myself, I'd probably buy a Kubota. I like knowing I can get most of my money back if needed. Plus, FOR ME, Kubota's engineering expertise, and large service network with experienced technicians are worth a premium. But this MAX series looks like a heck of a deal. If I knew for sure every part on the machine was designed and build by Mitsubishi....it would be hard to turn down.
As Don was saying, it should not affect 25HP and down units, so I expect there will be more <25hp units. Most 26-28HP tractors could be rated at 100-150rpm less and be legitimately called 25hp, so I expect we will see some of that. Cost will be significant on models for which technology must be added, not just a few hundred $$, maybe $2500-$4000 range depending on HP and brand and the technology used.
I think Don is suspecting a Max28XL that will be rated at 25HP? Seems reasonable to me. I don't think there will be 26HP machines, if you are going to have to spend a bunch on Tier IV, you might as well make those machines start at 30+ HP.
I can't believe people are still arguing about SCUT vs CUT vs full CAT 1 capable, etc...
From a marketing point of view, what Mahindra did was brilliant. In marketing, people make decisions based on comparisons. Therefore, if you can control how your product is compared to other products, you can control the value proposition to your advantage.
Kubota's brand/reputation is hard to overcome. Compared to a B series Kubota, the MAX is just "cheaper" but about equal in capabilities. But compared to a BX, the MAX series appear to be MUCH more capable at a similar price. For many people, this would be a better deal.
Myself, I'd probably buy a Kubota. I like knowing I can get most of my money back if needed. Plus, FOR ME, Kubota's engineering expertise, and large service network with experienced technicians are worth a premium. But this MAX series looks like a heck of a deal. If I knew for sure every part on the machine was designed and build by Mitsubishi....it would be hard to turn down.
It was a smart marketing move, and it does take some strategy to make inroads into a market that Kubota has dominated. Kubota is a smart company and they build a nice product. I have a lot of respect for Kubota.
The Max tractors, as well as the 16 series and the previous 15 series are entirely Mitsubishi. They are shipped directly from Japan to the final assembly/distribution points in the USA. Tires, wheels, loaders, mowers, batteries and backhoes are sourced elsewhere, mostly in the USA. Final assembly is in the USA. Quality is top notch. It is not a step down in quality, in any manner, from the other Japanese made units like Kubota. Just like JD sourced most of their under 40HP tractors from Yanmar in Japan for decades and NH sourced most of their small tractors from Shibaura in Japan. Quality is excellent, the only issue is keeping cost down as Japan is not a cheap place to build stuff and the Yen to Dollar exchange has been problematic. But besides price concerns (which Mahindra has managed well) it's hard to beat a compact (or sub-compact) Japanese built tractor for quality.
I'm thinking from a business standpoint, price will go up on everything across the board so it doesn't exaggerate prices on tractors alone. Loaders, backhoes, and branded implements will have to go up. If mfg's spread the cost among everything, it will be an easier pill to swallow. If I was in the market, I would purchase now. For the price reason but also because historically, new technology brings new complications. Ie. 2007 diesel pickups.
I'm thinking from a business standpoint, price will go up on everything across the board so it doesn't exaggerate prices on tractors alone. Loaders, backhoes, and branded implements will have to go up. If mfg's spread the cost among everything, it will be an easier pill to swallow. If I was in the market, I would purchase now. For the price reason but also because historically, new technology brings new complications. Ie. 2007 diesel pickups.
Yen has been devalued, Realtive to US dollars, Japan has become competitive to get their Manufacturing back on track. Mitsu is good company.
One question I do have for you dealers who are nice enough to come on here and offer expertise and answer questions. I have 2012 Husqvarna GTH27V48LS with just under 50 hours on it. Love the machine, but it's become quite clear that I need more capbility than what it has to offer. I bought it thinking I would mow, clear snow, and till a garden with it and just rent a larger machine to do the actual property maintenance projects I have planned. Well needless to say that after only completing a few of my projects via rental that it just isn't cost effective in my case to do it that way, not too mention having to pray for good weather when I rent. Anyway what realistically would the ball park trade in value be for my Husqvarna, if I were to order a Max25 or 28XL with a loader and the 60" MMM? I guess what I'm after here is if it makes sense to order the Max with FEL and MMM and trade in my current tractor to offset the cost of the MMM. Or would it make more sense to keep the Husqvarna and then just order the Max 25 or 28XL with just the loader. I don't expect exact number just a ball park to give me an idea on how the trade in process works and if it would be worth it. Thanks in advance, and it's awesome that you guys at least try to be somewhat accessible on here. Feel free to message me if you would rather do it that way. Thanks, Chemteck
I really don't know what your Husqy is worth, but the idea of two machines appeals to me. I'm a tractor dealer with literally hundreds of tractors at my fingertips, but I still own an Exmark Navigator for some of the nicer lawn areas at our home, then use a tractor for when I am mowing acres of grass/weeds out back. They both have their place in my opinion.
Thanks for the kind words. This is a great community here.
Max's have been awesome. I've sold a bunch and they have been near flawless. The Max28XL actually uses the same engine as the Max25, so power is very close in reality. The Max25 has the mid-pto standard, so that saves a little $$. Ground clearance is better with the Max28 as it uses a taller tire. On the flip side, the Max25 is super easy to get on and off as it is lower. The Max28 has tilt wheel and is a little longer in the operators area, so >6' folks prefer the space I think. You get more FEL capacity with the 28, yet the Max 25 quickly lifts a full bucket of wet sand, so it is enough.
Rim Guard in the rear tires on a Max25 adds 258 lbs, vs 321 lbs for the Max28. I'd sit on each and drive each. If the Max25 fits you well, I'd buy it.
Hmmm, didn't realize the Max25 had Mid PTO standard and the 28 did not. So that's a good heads up on that. Even if I don't get the MMM, I'd pretty sure I still want the mid PTO just to have the option down the road if need be. Just a ball park figure (I know you are in California) but just to give me an idea how much is the Mid PTO upgrade on the 28XL? PM me that info if you'd rather, if you would please. I could aways run a 3pt finish mower I suppose if I went without the mid PTO on the 28XL, but it wouldn't be near as maneuverable as an MMM. And of course I could always keep the Husqvarna to mow. Sooo many variables, but I'm going to take my time and get it right this time....I hope! As far as the extra room, I'm only 5'6" so I'll fit either machine I'm sure. What is the difference in ground clearance between the two, I didn't see that listed on the Mahindra site but I might have overlooked it.
What is the deal with the Shuttle Shift tractor on the 28XL? I've never had one. Are they durable? Do they have any advantages over the HYDRO? How bout the P.T.O. how does that work with the SS trans? Is it live or does it stop when the clutch is pressed is what I'm really after I guess. How bout mowing in High Range, I've heard that some tractors in this class don't like to move if you stop on an incline with the 2 range Hydro. That is part of the reason for my inquiry into the SS Trans. Has the Max experienced this issue? Most of my slopes are gentle, but I'm just curious about it. Thanks in advance! Chemteck
You are asking good questions. MSRP on the mid-PTO kit is $525. If you go with the rear-mount, you'll never need it. Ground clearance might not be listed since each tractor has three different tire options and all are different heights. I'd say roughly 2 inches. The shuttles are durable, but if you mow a lot, especially precise mowing, you will appreciate the fact that an HST by nature has ground travel and PTO independent of each other. The PTO spins away regardless if you are going forward, backward or stopped. On the Max28XL shuttle, if you push in the clutch to stop ground travel, your PTO winds down. That isn't the case with the 3016 and larger shuttles, but is the case for the 28. Tractors were that way for decades and we all got along fine, but having a PTO that is independent of travel really is better. In summary, go with the HST for your application.
I use a Max25 mostly at home. It does not lack for power. I do have to shift to low range for some things I do. I have a big drop-off that I fill with grass clippings and leaves and other yard debris. Sort of like a huge compost pile. It is soft, and the sides are steep. I generally have to go to low range when I am playing in that area. Otherwise all mowing is done in high. When the Max25's first came out I mowed my 10 acres of pistachios with my 6' flail mower and it did great. I'd generally recommend a 5', but the 6 footer never even thought of bogging the engine down. I do mow often though, so I wasn't mowing tall thick grass.
It is easy to keep stepping up in size. The Max22 would work fine for you, but the Max25 isn't much more and has a larger engine. From that point, the Max28 is a little heavier and lifts more and has larger tires and isn't that much more. But then the 3016 is a real step up in size...and isn't that much more. Soon enough I'll have you in a mPower 85 with a cab...for not that much more. So figure what you need, and try to keep your focus and do not step up in size needlessly. Just my thoughts.