Need some help with a decision

gkyork · Nov 14, 2013

Hi all!!
I have an older JD 317 that is in need of some TLC in order to be usable again. Typical stuff- gas tank, hydraulic lines replaced, tune up- basic stuff. My dilemma is this, is this unit better RESTORED and used , or simply brought back into service by any means possible? I also have a push-pull blade for this unit. Budget is of course limited, I would like to be able to use this critter to actually MAKE money(grading drive ways, bushhogging fields etc) Any ideas? Thanks in advance!!!

murphy1244 · Nov 14, 2013

For me if I were going to do it, might as well do it right or don't do it at all.

Wrenchin · Nov 14, 2013

How's trany? If in any doubt can get pricey if you do all that work and first driveway you do,you end up with a transmissions parts yard sale right there.

gkyork · Nov 15, 2013

To the best of my knowledge, trans is OK..... When I was gifted the JD it ran and generally worked- but 18 or so months sitting isnt good for NEW equipment.... much less something 25-30 years old. Anybody aware of JD vintage parts sources? Sourcing parts and minimal budget may make my decision for me, it may end up a rework instead of RESTORE

Wrenchin · Nov 16, 2013

either way you go good luck still good to see older models being used in 25 years I don't think you will see any tractors from this generation in operation .all made to replace not repair:ashamed:

js5020 · Nov 16, 2013

Basically you have few options but I would look at a similar sized machine (a new one) and get the price of it,,, now can you make it (the old one) as usable/reliable for less coin? Is the coin you saved worth a month or three of your time and frustration/enjoyment? If so, used is for you, if no, then new is for you.

I had the same question/decision this summer,,,,,, I wanted a new X530/540, with a blower, blade, price,,, better part of 10,000. I was able to aquire a 70's GT free in decent condition, repaired/replaced everything that was an issue, rebuilt the engine, replaced tires, repainted, new decals, bought a like new blower, like new blade,,,, end cost, around 1,500 due to Very very fortunate shopping.

Is the old machine as nice to use as a new one,,,,, no its not, I much prefer a foot controlled hydro, the new one doesnt vibrate, the new one isnt as loud and a few other things,,,,,, However for the cash savings I would do it again, I dont use it everyday if I did it might be a different story, but if I can do the same work in similar time with 1500 as 10000 Im pickin 1500 everytime.