I buy the Harbor Freight leather/elastic gloves. They fit me the best and I don't feel bad about tearing them up or losing them.
I bought about every pair of gloves I could find, trying to find a really good pair which fit my hands. From $40/pr to $6. The yellow, full fingered, HF gloves are by far the best for me. And by the time I wear a hole in the end of the middle finger, they are usually losing their velcro closure and/or have oil/grease/etc on them to the point that going into the trash is not an issue.
I love them, and buy several pair several times a year. My hands pay the bills... and I wear gloves in almost everything I do.