Mike,
Semper Fi!! I was in from 83-88 and loved it.
I don't know if I'd recomend to anybody to build there own lake unless you have allot of patience. When I first started it, I thought I'd do a little hear and there when I had some extra time. It was just clearing the land and outlinine the area it would cover. At most, I thought 3 acres would be about it with a small dam. Around here, stock tanks have dams on them that are barely four feet across at the top and a foot or two above wateline. I thought that would be easy.
Things changed after I started and it sat for awhile. Then things changed again and I started getting the itch to start on it again.
It took a full year longer to finish then I imagined. It's much bigger, deeper and better too!!! I took out more trees then I thought possible and moved more dirt then I can calculate. The dozer is what made it possible. I both hate it and love it. It wouldn't have been possilb without having it, but I can't wait for the day that I sell it.
I also have a smaller 3/4 acre pond that started out as a low mud hole from some guys who were stealing dirt from the land before I bought it. It would hold a foot or so of water for awhile after a rain, but othewise, it was an ugly low spot.
I spent two solid months digging it out with my backhoe. I hauled dirt out of it one yard at a time and dumped it right next to the pond. In two months, I built up a huge pile of dirt. Then the rains came and filled it up and my digging stoped. Overall, it's 5 feet deep with two holes that are over 8 feet deep. I had one area that was too soft for the backhoe, so I made it into an island. It took half a year to move the dirt pile to where I wanted it.
The problem the you'll have first, is what to do with the dirt you dig out? Making the dam bigger and thicker is the most common aproach to getting rid of dirt, but selling it is another good option. Hauling it to another location is the worse way, but also it's the only choice allot of the time.
When I was digging my lake, I had some local people come out and check out my progress. many of them suggested digging out the ground next to the creek and creating the lake that way. If I had a way to do this, I might have worked, but that would have meant moving four times as much dirt and finding a place to put it. It would have also meant working in mud as compared to hard packed clay. There is nothing worse then wet, muddy clay to work in.
If you can, daming up the canyon will be your cheapest and easiest way to create your pond. The next problem is creating your spillway. Imagine the most water possible coming down your creek and the build a spillway that can handle twice that amount. From what the news is saying, you guys in New York just went through one of the worse rains in history. Build for that and then some.
Looking back, I sort of rushed into building Lake Marabou, but delays and breakdowns slowed me down enough to made changes and improvements to my original plan. Take your time and get a solid plan. Check it out and be flexible in changing it. Go to
Pond Boss Magazine Home Page! and read up on leaking dams and ponds that leak. Just do a search and you'll get a small idea of the nightmare a bad design, or a rush to build can create. I got lucky, very lucky.
Good luck and keep us posted. As you can tell by the size of this thread, people like ponds and all that goes into building them!!!
Eddie