Hi again ppea
You are absolutely right about the Berta being a very solid/heavy-duty flail mower. I think that most of us will never be able to wear one down, but I am happy that I finally got one, and it is a real joy to work with it. I got a Berta snowthrower almost 9 years ago, and upon receiving it, I was very impressed by the way it was build. I therefore felt very confident that the flail mower would be of the same high quality - and I haven't been disappointed
To my knowledge, the mower is the same for most tractor brands, only the coupling vary. Sadly, the companies that manufacture 2-wheel tractors haven't been able/willing to agree on a common PTO-standard, making it almost impossible to swap implements between different brands
In the original Berta
user and maintenance manual, there is a table with recommendations for minimum engine power versus working width:
By 65 cm (26'') working width, Berta recommend a minimum 8 hp engine, by 75 cm (30'') they recommend 10 hp, and finally for 85 cm (34'') they recommend 12-14 hp.
The above combinations are probably pretty good ballpark figures, but mowing isn't rocket science I think. Whether you will be able to mow in 3. gear or not, will depend more on what sort of crop you are mowing, how tall and dense it is, and on how much you overlap, than on the width of the mower. By design, a flail mower is a very power-hungry implement, as it takes a lot of power to keep the rotor rotating at high revolutions, and still have enough torque to not only cut the crop, but also to shred it.
Except for mowing your lawn perhaps, I wouldn't expect you to be able to use the 3. gear that often with any of the flail mowers. I only have 10 hours of experience with my Berta until now, but I did all my mowing in 1. gear. I think that you will be very impressed by any of the Berta flail mowers anyway! If you have a rather easy crop to mow, you will be more efficient with a wider mower of course. Should your tractor struggle with some tougher crops, you might be able to increase your overlap, and thereby reduce the load on the engine.
Depending on your wheel spacing, you want to make sure, that your wheels stay within the working width of the mower! With duals on my BCS 740, I have only 3 cm to spare on each side with the 85 cm Berta!
Finally - depending on the prices in your area - you might get "more mower" for your money by getting the bigger one! A quick look at the prices at Earth Tools for instance, shows that the Berta becomes cheeper per inch, the wider it gets.
You probably have guessed by now, what I would recommend?
Best regards
Jens