I have to say that I was impressed by my rear scoop when it came to cost ($300 CDN) but less when it came to ease of use. It certainly makes moving soil & gravel much easier (than wheelbarrow), especially over long distances. I suspect that I get more spillage (ie rocks on lawn) than I would with a FEL because of the difficulty tilting scoop. Dumping scoop is not always easy, depending on where in the scoop the load is situated. Unlike FEL, don't have ability to smooth surface unless I switch to rear blade. Using the scoop for hours on end results in sore neck unlike FEL where you are looking forward most of the time.
Faced with the cost difference, $300 scoop vs $4500 FEL (priced last week at dealer), I suspect that I will continue with the scoop for another year or so. Despite some of the drawbacks listed above, i would recommend a rear scoop as a cheap interim measure until you (and I) can get a FEL.
Lyle