Arc weld, I'm wondering if the biggest issue my Ford 917 has is the "rough cut" blades I'm using?? Maybe I'd have been better served buying the "fine cut", upside down Y looking blades?? I went for the rough cut thinking they would last longer hitting rocks, etc., cutting roadside banks??
Great story concerning your Dad's history. Wish he were here to join this discussion.
I can only speak to my experiences.
I paid $100 for my old beatup 7' 917 flail. I dumped about $400 into it for a new PTO shaft that was long enough, most of a new set of knives & mounting hardware, belts & some heavy sheet metal to patch the hood. It still has a huge crack in the hood where it meets the support spar between gearbox & belts & I should probably replace the bearings this winter or in a year or 2. This old beatup flail in need of repairs has caused me to park my 5' Landpride rotary cutter I bought brand new with my tractor 2 years ago. The rotary is in excelent shape, but with the flail, the cut is better & its a lot safer. Having the offset, the roller & not hanging way back means it much more manuverable & never scalps.
I pull the flail slower than the rotary cutter with my 32hp
L3200 , but it's also 7' compared to 5'. All in all my mow times are equal or faster with the flail. The hood on the flail is only half the height of my field grass lots of the time, but that doesn't slow it down. I have the inverted Y side slicers & they rotate forward with the tires when going forward.
The main drawback I've run into so far is when mowing my well head in heavy grass. The rotary is right behing the tractor & has a low deck, so wouldn't be a problem. The 1.5' tall opening on the flail & offset meant It went right over the well head. Lost a handfull of knives, the mounting hardware & the well head cap.
If your hammers were backwards, I'm sure you'd have a crap cut. With the inverted Y knives, there really isn't any way to install them backwards. Worst case scenario, you have a dull edge cutting moderately well instead of a sharp edge cutting really well. If you could mount em I'd suggest trying a set of inverted Y knives, which would cost you $200-300 if I recall. My inverted Y's bounce off landscape timbers easily with no damage. Landscape timbers are chewed up a bit. The well head destroyed a handfull, but I doubt any other knive style short of a forrestry flail would have done any better.
As others have noted, it doesn't suck, it won't vacuum stuff off the ground, but it does give a good even cut. When mowing high grass I end up with tire tracks that are uncut as the tires bend the grass over & it takes hours or days to spring back up. Not an issue with greener shorter grass though, mostly a brown high grass problem.