trying to decide

andre · Apr 6, 2004

I'm looking to purchase my first small tractor. I'm trying to decide between the Kubota 2230 and the jd 2210. Should I be leaning to either one. So far the Kubota is coming in at A $1000 cheaper. Please help. I have 2 1/2 acres I just bought. Thanks

GerardC · Apr 7, 2004

What price range are you looking at?

andre · Apr 7, 2004

I guess there is no thoughts on this subject.

andre · Apr 7, 2004

2230 with fel for $10800 and the jd 2210 with fel for $11700

BigAl · Apr 7, 2004

Ok ,we need more infor /forums/images/graemlins/confused.gif ! What will you be using it for ? Different tractors have different advantages over each other . And lets get that home page filled out ! /forums/images/graemlins/confused.gifInquirering minds need to know this stuff . /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
Big Al

andre · Apr 7, 2004

grading a driveway 50 feet long clearing and leveling land and maintance

andre · Apr 7, 2004

150 ft long

MarkV · Apr 7, 2004

Andre,

Both of the tractors you are looking at are fine machines and will do the tasks you have listed. Over the life of a tractor the price difference is very little. That is a round about way of saying which dealer do you feel better with. And, which tractor feels best to you as you drive it. You will be dealing with the comfort level and dealer for a long time to come so that is what I would look at.

MarkV

theboman · Apr 7, 2004

I seen the JD over the weekend displayed in a local mall and it's a fine looking machine.
I'm like others I'm sure both tractors will handle the tasks listed so I agree that assuming both tractors have the same options/attachments and there's only a $1000 difference, go with your heart and dealer. Talk to both, invite them over to see your spread and demo each machine on YOUR LAND.
See how it fits then and decide.

jpr62902 · Apr 7, 2004

These 2 subCUT's are pretty comparable. The BX has a little more torque, but the JD has slightly stronger hydraulics. I will say that Kubota significantly underestimates its loader capacity. I've lifted 600 lbs. easily with the FEL on my BX22, though Kubota only rates it at around 460 lbs.

paco · Apr 7, 2004

Can't comment on the Deere, although a good machine i am sure. I have the bx and it is a fine machine. I would purchase the one I felt the most comfortable with. Dealer support is a big issue for me. Local Deere dealer not very friendly here.

Junkman · Apr 7, 2004

Since you haven't given us much to go on, I will give you my unbiased opinion. If you have a wife or girlfriend, have her sit on each tractor and see which one matches her complexion, hair color and eye color best. That is the tractor to go with. In the event that you don't have a wife or girlfriend, then pick the color tractor that doesn't clash with the color of your car or the color of your home. Remember when all else fails, color co-ordination and fashion will always win out over reason and common sense. Don't believe me?.... ask any woman /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif I know that you want the Kubota, because if you really wanted the JD, you would have asked this question on the JD forum. /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif You just want us to validate your good thinking and logic. I approve, and all you need now is the blessing of Henro and Bird and all will be well. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Poppa · Apr 8, 2004

( I know that you want the Kubota, because if you really wanted the JD, you would have asked this question on the JD forum. /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif)

I think you nailed that one Junkman and I bet if he thinks about it he'll realize it also. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

Mike

andre · Apr 8, 2004

Well I did post on the JD forum but got no answers. I'm leaning towards the bx 23 with backhoe

TresCrows · Apr 8, 2004

( I guess there is no thoughts on this subject. )

The reason people are relunctant to answer is that you require an opinion and whenever Kubota owners express the opinion that they like their tractors it turns into an anti-import unAmerican Kubota hate thread. It is not PC to like Kubota, you can like JD or Massy Ferg or even Adolf ****** but not a Kubota /forums/images/graemlins/crazy.gif.
My opinion, get the Kubota, pocket the left over money--be happy /forums/images/graemlins/laugh.gif. J

theboman · Apr 8, 2004

( These 2 subCUT's are pretty comparable. The BX has a little more torque, but the JD has slightly stronger hydraulics. I will say that Kubota significantly underestimates its loader capacity. I've lifted 600 lbs. easily with the FEL on my BX22, though Kubota only rates it at around 460 lbs. )

It's all for safety and warranty purposes. Lift 600 lbs bend a hydro arm, or a frame part (it can happen) and you're SOL on getting it repaired under warranty.

Poppa · Apr 8, 2004

( ( I guess there is no thoughts on this subject. )

The reason people are relunctant to answer is that you require an opinion and whenever Kubota owners express the opinion that they like their tractors it turns into an anti-import unAmerican Kubota hate thread. It is not PC to like Kubota, you can like JD or Massy Ferg or even Adolf ****** but not a Kubota /forums/images/graemlins/crazy.gif.
My opinion, get the Kubota, pocket the left over money--be happy /forums/images/graemlins/laugh.gif. J )

Actually TresCrows I think he was or is just in a big hurry to make his decision so he can get and play with his new tool. Poor guy couldn't even wait a whole hour for a reply.

Andre: The best advice is already out there. The tractors both appear to be good so go with the dealer who talks to you. Answers your questions and generally makes you feel ok with the idea of spending 10 to 12 grand on a tractor.

I like Kubotas. I also like Bratwurst, Tacos, and Osso Bucco. LandRovers, Toyotas and Dodges. But if I can't find any of those then I'll eat a cheeseburger in the back of my Ford. I always say, buy American while you still can /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

Mike

Henro · Apr 8, 2004

Andre,

One shortcoming on the BX is the 3PH being a little on the small side for CAT1. I don't know about the 2210.

The BX will work fine on your 2.5 acres. How much would a B7500 be? Would it be in the ballpark with the JD2210 in price? Maybe a little more $.

Depending on your needs, maybe you should price the B7500, compare it to the JD, and then make a decision.

If I were to have only one tractor I would rather have one that had a more standard 3ph on the back so I could buy standard implements. Or borrow from a friend sometimes (I never do, but you never know...).

The BX is a very nice tractor. As a bx owner I am no knockin' it. Since I have another CUT with a more standard 3PH I see the limitations of the BX 3PH each time I hook something up.

If I did not have something to compare to I would not be typing this.

Just a thought... /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

stevenw · Apr 8, 2004

I had a similar post a while back. ( 2230/2210 ) I analyzed both these tractors extensively. As for price, I had the dealers $100.00 apart. It came down to the fact the JD does not have a good bagging option for mowing so I ended up purchasing the BX2230. The BX2230 did not have a tachometer so I added the Tiny Tach ( Tach )…problem resolved. Also the Kubota dealer is 4.5 miles from my home and they have a good Service reputation. That should really weigh more on your decision than the price. These tractors are very comparable with each other. You need to drive them and see what you like best. The JD doesn’t have cruise control either if I recall correctly and that will be important if you are mowing large parcels.

TresCrows · Apr 8, 2004

I have crusie control on the 2410 and never used it--mowed for hours on the BX and it and never missed it.
I also think the dealer thing is over rated. It is good to have an honest dealer but I am not going to buy a lesser product just because the dealer or store is nicer--and that goes for Kubota or JD or whatever. What I am saying is I think--for me--my opinion--I just never see myself on a green tractor. Maybe a red one someday but not a green one so if a green dealer was going to put me on a green unit he would have to really be special and have a really good price and maybe if I was younger and needing a wife a real pretty daughter /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif. Now that might be a good package deal--otherwise, just give me the 'bota and send me on my way. /forums/images/graemlins/smirk.gif. J(biased, opinionated and proud of it)