Yeah, it's a pain to work on... but it runs great now!
Pretty sure it was just a weak spot, knowing the full history of the saw the coworker that had the saw originally (bought new) a tree fell on it not too long before it started idling high which broke the outer handle only (3 rubber isolators), was the first thing the new owner changed, then tried to tackle the high idle issue... started with an Amazon carburetor then an intake boot just for good measure... then of course the crank pan... Apparently the idle got progressively worse over time as the crack progressed I'm sure... probably started from the stress of the crushing spreading the crankcase a bit...
Put it together tonight since the part showed up today, started right up, adjusted the idle screw and it idles down real nice now