I have had all 3 Direct TV, cable and Dish Network. No mater what you choose, consider a digital recorded. They make watching TV much easier. NO COMMERCIALS, nothing on when you want to watch TV, just record something you want to watch BUT you are doing something else, makes tractor seat time much easier /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif. It is so simple with a digital recorded to record a show, just pick the show off the guide of shows, and push one button, done recored. You are watching a show, phone rings, no problem hit pause and you can stop live TV and pick up where you left off. You like one particular show, you can record every show and watch it when you want. A show starts you like, record the show, wait 23 minutes ( the time an average 1 hour show has in commercials) and start from the beginning, and just zip by the commercials. Like movies, record them and if you really like it record it to a VCR or a DVD, no loss in quality. Most units can record 40 hours and some in the 80 hour area.
I think the Dish units are better for recording. They have a button you hit and it jumps 30 seconds ahead, hit it 2 times, 2 commercials gone, do not even have to watch them. When too far, press the back button and you go back 15 seconds. Direct TV has a button to fast-forward the commercial, BUT you still have to watch the commercial , but at a much faster rate. The Dish unit would freeze up a lot, no problem just unplug the unit for 15 seconds, reboots the computer and off you go for another week. The Direct unit does not freeze up. Someone told me Dish used their own software and Direct uses a Microsoft product. Dish has less problem with storms interruption, Direct is more sensitive to storms, snow, heavy rain, lightings. Direct has the YANKEES Dish does NOT!! Only reason why I switch from Dish to Direct.
Cable TV, no comparison in picture quality, although I hear cable digital looks good.
Cost, all about the same, Direct and Dish. Cable the most for what you get, and the price keeps going up. Also with cable we had outages sometimes for hours. Satellite outages are for as long as a storm is at its peak as it goes by, a few minutes at most.