ericm979
Super Member
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2016
- Messages
- 5,735
- Location
- Santa Cruz Mountains CA, Southern OR
- Tractor
- Branson 3725H Deere 5105
I think that wireless sprinkler valves aren't going to exist. You'd still need to run wires to them for power. They might as well be both power and signal.
I recently replaced my old sprinkler controller with an Orbit controller with a remote. NOT the b-hyve internet connected model! I found an older non internet model with a remote. I know how bad the security is on internet connected stuff and I don't want the company turning off my controller when they decide they need more revenue.
The remote is great when checking individual sprinkler settings. No cell phone needed, it's all older RF tech. It has at least a 200' range and can hit the controller that's on the other side of the house from the lawn.
The cell phone ones don't talk RF directly to the controller. They send IP packets to a server the company runs, and that then talks to the controller via internet. This means that A) the company's controlling what you do and can decide to charge a fee or turn off your system B) it depends on your cell connection and your internet connection and C) the sprinkler controller is on your home network but is accepting packets from the company's servers. Since they probably did a terrible job of securing that connection and the app in the controller, it's got a good chance of getting hacked. If you're lucky it'll just be put in a bot net and used to harass people on the internet. OTOH you can control your sprinklers from anywhere that has cell service. For some people that outweighs all the negatives, some of which they probably don't know about.
I recently replaced my old sprinkler controller with an Orbit controller with a remote. NOT the b-hyve internet connected model! I found an older non internet model with a remote. I know how bad the security is on internet connected stuff and I don't want the company turning off my controller when they decide they need more revenue.
The remote is great when checking individual sprinkler settings. No cell phone needed, it's all older RF tech. It has at least a 200' range and can hit the controller that's on the other side of the house from the lawn.
The cell phone ones don't talk RF directly to the controller. They send IP packets to a server the company runs, and that then talks to the controller via internet. This means that A) the company's controlling what you do and can decide to charge a fee or turn off your system B) it depends on your cell connection and your internet connection and C) the sprinkler controller is on your home network but is accepting packets from the company's servers. Since they probably did a terrible job of securing that connection and the app in the controller, it's got a good chance of getting hacked. If you're lucky it'll just be put in a bot net and used to harass people on the internet. OTOH you can control your sprinklers from anywhere that has cell service. For some people that outweighs all the negatives, some of which they probably don't know about.