The same thing happen to me a few years ago when I was installing a rotary mower on my old Farmall. When installing the quick disconnect over running clutch on the Farmall's PTO, I noticed that the spring didn't pull the locking pin all the way into the circumferential slot encircling the pto shaft. I thought that there must have been a burr on the pto shaft and the pin would work its way into the slot during initial moments of operation and thus lock the clutch onto the PTO shaft. WRONG!!! Without the pin fully seated, the clutch worked its way off the PTO shaft in just a few minutes, and the shaft went flying around, breaking the spring retainer off the end of the locking pin and throwing pieces of the locking mechanism everywhwere.
Of course, I lost the pin , spring, and retainer in the field. I didn't have time to get new parts, so I drilled the hub of the overrunning clutch in line with the existing hole in the PTO shaft for a cross pin (actually a bolt). Twenty years later, the clutch is still on there.
So, at least in my case, the problem was not equipment failure, but operator error.
Frank Z.