New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator

/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #1  

Orangecrush68

New member
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
8
Location
East of the Sun, West of the Moon
Tractor
Johndeere
Hi. I hope you can advise me of how to handle this. Or at least tell me if what I'm about to do is the best way to go. Thank you in advance! :)

I own a home that I will be living in the rest of my life. I absolutely love it here. I do have a shared driveway that, including me, has a total of 4 homeowners that share a driveway.

My home is out by the road, so when you pull in the driveway, my house is right in front on the right side , then you drive down a little ways and further down you'll see my next door neighbor, further on down from there on the left is neighbor number three and then at the end of the driveway is the owner I am going to be talking to you about. He has an excavation business, and has a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator, a dump truck and a trailer that he hooks onto his truck or dump truck that transports his equipment in and out regularly.

Let me state at the outset I have no problems with this driveway in terms of sharing it, because for one, I don't even use it. I have a tiny driveway I made that is directly in front of my house and I just park there. In the 9 years I've lived here, I've never used the shared driveway once. The driveway goes along the side of my house so there would be no reason to use it.

I own the first part of the shared driveway all the way to where my next door neighbor is, then he owns til further down til the next neighbor's starts, and then at the end of the driveway is neighbor number 4, the heavy equipment operator.

I do not begrudge my neighbor number 4 and his heavy equipment in terms of the noise etc. In fact, I like the activity. And for 9 years there has never been a problem between me with any of the neighbors. Everyone is cordial to me. Not friends, but the customary hello and wave.

This is what is going on. I don't know what is happening to the driveway but there has been this growing "low spot" that's been growing for a couple of years. Every time it rains there is a puddle. This year it's turned into a pond. A BIG pond. Like 20 feet long and 6 inches deep. It goes right along my property in a curve that denotes how he turns left all the time as he turns to leave. This neighbor drives right through the "pond" thinking nothing of it as it gets bigger and bigger. He has no problem since he drives a pick up truck and dump truck.

The driveway is a Y at the beginning and then branches off eventually into one single lane, it turns into one lane at the point where my property line ends. There is a triangle of grass that separates the 2 lanes that make the Y. 2 of the neighbors use the left lane going in, and the heavy equipment guy uses it as well, but he uses my lane several times every day when he has jobs where he has to turn left going out because he has to make a wide turn. Let me be clear the ONLY person who has ever used this section of shared driveway that I own is this guy, not me or the other neighbors or even the friends and family of those neighbors.

He is the one making this disaster and not only that, over the 9 years I've lived here he has eroded our property to the point that this 12ft wide driveway is now 20 feet across, because he is slowly driving over my grass. You can easily see what he's done on the satellite map.

I kept thinking this guy would fix this spot. He alone created it, and I know he knows it. His father owns the gravel pit around here and he could easily fix this. He fixes all the holes in his driveway but only on HIS part. Which is maddening because since his property is the furthest back he drives over everyone's separate sections with his heavy equipment, damaging the gravel driveway, but only fixing his area.

It would be different if it was a shared driveway with someone who owns a car/truck etc, but to share a driveway with these heavy equipment and the toll they take on the driveway and then have to be financially responsible for it is frustrating.

If anyone is still reading this I'm sure you are wondering why I don't just talk to the guy. My thought is he already knows he is eroding our property and that he is damaging the driveway and he doesn't care. So what would be the point. If he felt responsible he'd have already fixed the low spots already.

So yesterday I called our local town highway supervisor and asked him if he could look at this spot because it starts in the town's right of way and then goes down our driveway. He came right over. After looking at the gigantic low spot he said I'll do you a favor, but only one time. He said I'll bring you a load of "milling" in the morning, and you'll have to spread it, and I said okay.Then he said to take his advice.

He said make that driveway back to 12feet as what shows in your deed and do it NOW. He said he is taking away your property bit by bit and you have to stop it. He said to next spring get a boulder and put it on the property line up to where it makes the shared driveway exactly 12 feet. He said to right now build a temporary fence (I have an orange snow fence) to make the driveway perfectly straight, instead of curving left along my property. He said that way the guy will not want to use your side anymore to turn left because since he can't curve left anymore into your property he'll have to drive straight out in the road and make a wide left, and he won't have the incentive to use that side anymore.

So last night overnight I put a pump into a bucket with holes all around the sides near the bottom, and put the bucket into all that water and pumped out the hundreds of gallons of water in this man made pond in the driveway. Then today the guy brought a huge load of milling at 8am and I spread it. It filled the giant hole and then some. I put stakes all around it, and then put caution tape around the stakes. This little set up I have going completely blocks access to my lane. It can't be driven on for 48 hours. I'm sure my heavy equipment neighbor is not bothered by it, and is probably pleased I got the low spot fixed.

My other 2 neighbors came out and talked to me about the low spot while I was working on it. They completely agree with me doing this, ie: making the driveway back to 12 feet. It's a perfect 12 feet on the other lane that makes the Y, but that's because the neighbor only turns left from my lane. They were amazed the county supervisor actually did that for me.

Anyway, I was wondering what you all thought of this, being heavy equipment operators. Please understand I have no problems with the idea of a shared driveway, nor the noise or activity, or anything. And if this guy just filled the darn hole I would not be doing what I am about to do, but it is hugely frustrating that this driveway that runs along the right side of my property is being used by only one person, and he''s damaging it and not thinking twice about it. He's doing it to the other neighbors too apparently since when they walked over today they both commented on the guy's equipment and how he ends up driving on their grass too, and slowly making their part of the driveway wider and their grass area shorter.

Since I am concerned about adverse possession I want to get this taken care of immediately.

Once the stakes and caution tape come down I am putting up the snow fence. I'll put topsoil and grass seed down in the spring to fill in the area behind the fence and make it grass again. My heavy equipment neighbor is not going to like this at all. He will not be able turn comfortably left anymore. But I shouldn't have to subsidize his turning left in a comfortable manner at the expense of my property being eroded.

I've read your forum for almost a year now. From reading it I don't think there's a single guy or girl on here who would use someone else's property, damage it, erode it, and then leave the homeowner to deal with the aftermath.

As heavy equipment operators, what do you think of what this neighbor has been doing? What do you think of what I am about to do? Any tips or ideas? Thank you to anyone who read this.
 
Last edited:
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #2  
I think he should respect your concern and what you've done with it and stay on the 12 foot wide access road. If he can't make the lefthand turn with a trailer with equipment, then he'll have to go right and do a turn around somewhere.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #3  
There's a lot of truth in the old saying "Good fences make good neighbours". It's your property and you have the right to put up a fence on the property line. If he doesn't like that, clue him in, nicely.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #4  
Welcome to the forum!

Given what you know of your neighbor, you may end up constructing a reinforced concrete barrier as your fence because his equipment will take out anything less. Be sure to have a survey done so you know exactly where your property line is. Your neighbor will eventually widen the driveway opposite your property once you protect your line.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #5  
I thought someone was writing this post for me. The more I read, the more it sounded like my situation with my shared road. It is very hard to understand how difficult it is to try and correct a situation like this when the other person could care less. I hope your plan succeeds!
Dave
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #6  
I agree about the fence, it will only save your property and keep it from being eaten little by little.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #7  
Although I am not in the shoes of the OP, it seems that an assumption regarding neighbor 4 is being made without even a brief conversation. Certainly move forward with your plan as you have every right to protect your interests. But I'd flag down the neighbor as he drives by and let him know what is coming and why.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #8  
I see no problem with what you are doing and I would do the same only like MikeInEburg, I would have already discussed it with the man. If he is a jerk or insensitive to the situation nothing will be lost and maybe just maybe you will get some help or at the very least avoid any misunderstanding or hard feelings.
 
Last edited:
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #9  
Agreed you should talk to neighbor #4, if only to inform him of what's happening. He might not even be aware of your concerns.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #10  
All of the heavy equipment operators I have ever known have been sensible, friendly people. Why don't you just walk down the driveway with an apple pie, say hello, and discuss the situation. I predict he will be more than accomodating. I am sure he is aware of the problem. But, you know how it is...the painter always has the house that needs painting, the landscaper always has the lawn that is a mess, etc...The last thing he thinks about when he gets home is the problem at home!
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #11  
This is just the beginning of a life long feud and the neighbor has all the weapons. I would think about getting out. You can't win. Been there.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #12  
I was the owner of a shared drive for 25 years, sold that home 6 years ago and never looked back.

You are doing the right thing. You must protect your property as your inconsiderate neighbor is obviously taking an "I do not care" attitude. You may wish to present him with a bill for the work also. He most likely will not pay it but it will set a precedent for future issues.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #13  
Like others said, talking now probably doesn't hurt anything. I would also put down some dirt and seed now, or sod it. It's not a bad time for sod and then you are done with it.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator
  • Thread Starter
#14  
Good morning everyone and thank you for your replies.

There are 2 reasons I am not talking to him about this. The first is because of me. I suppose it's pride.... I am not going to go up and ask someone to pay for my financial obligations when they are my legal responsibility. He doesn't own my part of the driveway, and he has no legal obligation to pay for that up keep, only his part of the lane, but because of where his house is at the end of the driveway, only he uses HIS owned portion of the driveway. He has all the benefits, but none of the risks.

It would take a lot of nerve, even in a polite way, for me to walk up to him and try to appeal to him about fixing the damage he is causing. I have known him a very long time, over 20 years. I bought my home from his sister. His grandparents actually owned all the land around here on the lake at one time that everyone's houses now sit on. I believe it is likely if I talked to my neighbor's father about this, they would make their son do the upkeep on the low spots his equipment is causing, but my neighbor isn't a child; so I am not going to treat him like one.

The 2nd reason I'm not talking to him is because he is someone who retaliates, in very negative ways. If I ask him to stop doing what he's doing and he doesn't and THEN I put up the fence I think he'll be more mad than if I make it look like what is happening is more organic in nature ie: The low spot begat the fence to keep the low spot from happening again. My other 2 neighbors I know do not like him. I think that is why they both came out to talk to me yesterday. One doesn't like him because he planted some trees on the other neighbor's property and mows part of that neighbor's lawn, and that makes the one neighbor mad. My next door neighbor doesn't like him because after a dispute the heavy equipment operator reported to the health dept my next door neighbor's septic system (my heavy equipment operator does septic systems all the time and knows all the inspectors) to the health department and he had to get a whole new septic system. Not only that but the heavy equipment guy stopped at my place when I was outside one time and said my neighbor's addition was too close to my property and to get something from the county to stop it. i can't remember as I sit here this morning not having had coffee yet what it was, but he said if I got this thing it would stop the addition in progress and force the neighbor to tear it down.

So that is what I'm dealing with. He is now divorced and lives alone so I can't appeal to a wife or anyone that may have influence over him. Funny enough, the way his sister, who I bought the house from, got to own this part of the shared driveway is because when the sister owned this house it was just her and her brother here, the other 2 neighbors didn't have homes built here yet. The heavy equipment neighbor hadn't sold part of the land yet to the other 2 neighbors. So it was just brother and sister living here. Well, sister was parking her car on the driveway and brother was getting ticked off because again, he likes to turn left on my part and her car was blocking that. He I guess told her he'd smash her car if she did it again, so she called up grandma and grandma changed the deed or did something so that sister owned that part of land so he couldn't tell her what to do. However she made it a shared driveway. I don't see how it helped because one neighbor can't block ingress and egress of a shared driveway. However, brother never threatened sister again.

So here I stand today. I have to do something or I am going to have no grass left on the one side of my house. If he retaliates at least the town knows what is going on. I keep my property up, and pay my taxes on time, so I don't know what he can do, we'll have to see.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #15  
In that case just fix your property and put up a fence with tank traps behind the posts in case he runs over it ;-)

Sure sounds like a jerk to me. Maybe he'll go out of business. Not likely but we can hope.


Btw: I do commercial work and wouldn't drive over anyones lawn unless I had permission. He's pro ably just too lazy to swing wide. Maybe he doesn't like to use both hands on the wheel because he is on his cell phone! Don't let him bully you.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #16  
You really should follow the advice of others and get a survey done. You should not draw a line without knowing where that line should be. He has more history on the property and may know exactly where the line is and intentionally destroy what you put up. Allowing him to see the surveying stakes would be reinforcement on your part that he knows where the line is.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #17  
You certainly know your situation better than any of us and we all have our ways of dealing with or avoiding conflict. When working, I did conflict resolution on a daily basis, so that's just my inclination.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #18  
I'd do my best to keep that supervisor in office.
Dealing with property line issues myself survey first then stand firm.
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #19  
Yup... survey, mark line with fence.. row of trees.. bushes... whatever you want to mow around... But be prepared that the 'drive' may not be just 12'.. could be wider than that. Whatever it is, live with the survey and protect what is yours... :)
 
/ New here. Shared driveway issues w/someone who owns a backhoe, bulldozer, excavator #20  
I'd do my best to keep that supervisor in office.
Dealing with property line issues myself survey first then stand firm.

Always a good idea. When we bought this farm the person from whom we bought it and a neighbor took us up and showed us their property line. For over twenty years we both took care of our side and we erected a mutually agreed upon fence and we reforested our side.

A few years ago the land owner sold three acres to a relative on which to build a house. The new land owner hired a surveyor and everyone was wrong and we had to take our fence down. Neither of us gained or lost, he just now has trees on part of his property and his lawn is on part of ours. Fortunately we get along and are going to just leave it as is, but it could have been a problem.
 

Marketplace Items

20FT X 12FT LIVESTOCK SHELTER (A58214)
20FT X 12FT...
2018 ALLMAND MAXI-POWER 45 GENERATOR (A58214)
2018 ALLMAND...
2018 JOHN DEERE 323E SKID STEER (A60429)
2018 JOHN DEERE...
Redirective Crash Cushion Guardrail (A59230)
Redirective Crash...
2014 AMERITRAIL LAY FLAT HOSE TUGGER TRAILER (A58214)
2014 AMERITRAIL...
2015 Ford Escape AWD SUV (A59231)
2015 Ford Escape...
 
Top