looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD

   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #1  

DeliriumTremens

New member
Joined
May 10, 2016
Messages
7
Location
Cohutta
Tractor
none currently
I'm new to the forums and have been viewing many articles for some time, expecially since we're closing on some land today. It's a modest 6 acres, 4 of which are cleared and the other has some pines. Its been a while since i've been around tractors and grew up on a Massey 231. I initially thought a garden tractor would cut it but i'm thinking otherwise, especially with the unkempt nature of the lot and some of the rough terrain that needs leveling. I know the MMM is expensive, but I plan on using the tractor to cut my grass at my current residence and once the area is tamed, I'll use it to cut my new yard as well.

So I've decided a tractor is the best as opposed to a lawntractor and have been shopping around. I've went and sat on these tractors and drove them around to get a feel for them and have some opinions on them. I know there is more to a tractor than the initial price and the dealer is important as well, but I don't plan on visiting him too often (i hope).

So i'm down to a few tractors but would be open to other opinions. I know some of these aren't apples to apples comparisons but I did the best i could. SO this is what i've been quoted so far and have not made 1 attempt at negotiating yet. I really wanted to see what all everyone was offering and which one i liked first
all prices are out the door prices. all are hydrostatic trans.

Kioti CK2410, with FEL, MMM $20,167, 0% for 60months
Kioti CS2410, with FEL, MMM $17,390, 0% for 60months (the dealer did not have this on the lot but this was what I was originally after)
Mahindra MAX24, FEL, MMM $20,865, 0% for 84 (this is a year or two old that has been on the lot) (they would take $1600 off if i went 0%/48, or $2600 if i paid cash)
Mahindra EMAX25, FEL,MMM $20,533, 0%for 84, this is factory fresh. also -$1600 if i went 0%/48), or for cash price, 17,751, but also have to factor in interest until i pay it off.
Branson 2400H, FEL, MMM $17,869, with 3.5% interest.
JD1025---FEL, MMM. the guy didn't appear interested in selling this as I practically had to beg him to ride it. he ballparked the price @ $23k

I'm figuring I can pay if off in 12 months so interest vs no interest isn't that big a deal, but I still have to factor in at least 1 year of interest that I'll have to pay.

Personally, I thought that CK2410 was the best riding tractor with the smoothest operating bucket and particularly loved the loader joystick right by the seat and not on the dash; and it looked more tractor-like than the others. The others seemed small in comparison to it. I liked the Branson but it didn't wow me like the Kioti. I thought the Mahindra was ok but didn't fall in love with it.

I'm wanting opinions on the prices quoted and what kind of wiggle room I can expect to get when negotiating. I figure if I'll ultimately try to get $1000 off the CK2510 with a free rotary cutter and I'd be happy.


sorry so long.
DT
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #2  
http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/showthread.php?t=353157

Here's a thread I did on my Max24. Check it out, I really like mine, mine came in fresh of the truck, and wasn't out on the lot ever. All the manufacturers are great, just not sure of the Branson. Good Luck buy what you like and fits what you need. Welcome to TBN. Donnie
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #3  
I'd say it comes down to dealer and personal preference. If the dealer's good and you like it the most, there's nothing wrong with a kioti. 0% for 84 months is nothing to turn your nose up either. I looked a used Mahindra 2516, the predecessor to the max 24, and it was to small for me, but you may not have that problem.
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD
  • Thread Starter
#4  
So as the plot thickens, I've been steered away somewhat from the original choices. I've called around and now determined just to pay cash for a tractor just to save the extra $2-3K. I'm also sold on not getting a MMM and probably will just buy a finishing mower at some point in the future

Kioti ck2510 with FEL- 14,900+tax (i'm not sure what our tax is honestly, maybe 5-6%)
Mahindra MAX 26 with FEL- 15,800 (out the door price)

I personally think both machines would do the job, but I really like the joystick and seat of the kioti.....I guess it'll all come down to whoever makes the best deal on a bushhog. Any thoughts on these numbers?


DT
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #5  
A cuppla things...... both are excellent choices btw.

I don't have either exact model but my brother has a kioti and I have a Mahindra so I've done some comparisons.

Check the lift capacity of the fels on both machines. Kioti is historically very weak in the fel lift numbers. Mahindra is known for strong lifts.

I think the Max comes with a quick attach SSQA bucket, don't think the Kioti does.

Check the number of geared speeds on the kioti. I think it's 2 and the Max is 3. I could be wrong but you should find out.

You will be happy with either, just compare them closely.
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #6  
"Kioti is historically very weak in the fel lift " Where you get that?? One of the stats that made me buy my DK-40 was that fact that it can lift 2764 lbs? The things a beast in that department.
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #7  
"Kioti is historically very weak in the fel lift " Where you get that?? One of the stats that made me buy my DK-40 was that fact that it can lift 2764 lbs? The things a beast in that department.

dk series yes, strong. ck series are lightweights and are the ones I'm referring to.
 
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #8  
   / looking to buy- Kioti v. Branson v. Mahindra v. JD #9  
My Max 24 is a pin on bucket, and 2 speed hydro and does fine. Neither are deal breakers for me.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2013 Ford Explorer SUV (A51694)
2013 Ford Explorer...
(4) STEEL CARTS W/ WHEELS (A51248)
(4) STEEL CARTS W/...
40ft Shipping Container (A52377)
40ft Shipping...
MILWAUKEE 52" HIGH CAPACITY MOBILE WORKBENCH (A51248)
MILWAUKEE 52" HIGH...
2025 K0720 UNUSED Metal Farm Driveway Gate Set (A53117)
2025 K0720 UNUSED...
2010 Ford F-150 4x4 Pickup Truck (A51692)
2010 Ford F-150...
 
Top