Hi there! I'll preface this response with the acknowledgement that I'm not a real machinist, not really even a fake one.
I would say anything over 0.005 or so would be well outside of manufacturing tolerance. That's just the size of that gear, a new one will be the same dimensions.
I'm not a gear expert... but with a bevel gear, if you can keep the meshing of the gears within spec I would think things would be ok. 100+ thou over diameter would move that new gear a lot higher in mesh with the mating gear than the old one. I can think of positives and negatives from doing so, but if the gear is still fully meshed.... I would probably run it
For the OD of that gear, again if everything meshes I wouldn't be too concerned with grinding 0.050 off the edge.
The 0.060 thicker could present a challenge. I ended up using ~0.060 in shims to set the gear backlash. Which means you could get lucky? A surface grinder could take 0.010 off of that gear face without any issue.
Out of morbid curiosity, what killed your old gear? I bought mine without knowing that the gears and shafts had been removed. I also didn't have the old gears to compare to.
I would say anything over 0.005 or so would be well outside of manufacturing tolerance. That's just the size of that gear, a new one will be the same dimensions.
I'm not a gear expert... but with a bevel gear, if you can keep the meshing of the gears within spec I would think things would be ok. 100+ thou over diameter would move that new gear a lot higher in mesh with the mating gear than the old one. I can think of positives and negatives from doing so, but if the gear is still fully meshed.... I would probably run it
For the OD of that gear, again if everything meshes I wouldn't be too concerned with grinding 0.050 off the edge.
The 0.060 thicker could present a challenge. I ended up using ~0.060 in shims to set the gear backlash. Which means you could get lucky? A surface grinder could take 0.010 off of that gear face without any issue.
Out of morbid curiosity, what killed your old gear? I bought mine without knowing that the gears and shafts had been removed. I also didn't have the old gears to compare to.