Yes, dirt is getting in the tank, bypassing the gasket. Hard to explain but it can't be over tightened, it is just a half turn deal.
It's just the gasket does not seal. Eventually I'm going to have to get the carb cleaned. Luckily it has 2 years of warranty.
I was just wondering if anyone else has this problem or if mine has a defect.
I will tell you now as a small engine mechanic, ANY and all fuel related issues are not covered under warranty. Warranty is only for a defect in the product when it was being made. My question to you is, how clean is the fuel source, and how clean is your fuel container? If dirt is truly bypassing the gasket, then replace the gasket.
I will give this piece of information for all consumers who read this. Manufacturers are becoming EXTREMELY fussy with warranty claims, so much so that way more claims are denied than approved. Me, as a small engine mechanic, if someone comes in claiming warranty, I have to prove to the maker of the product, that it was a result of their manufacturing process. The truth is, 95% of the time, the product is not at fault but the user. So before you think you have a leg to stand on, you starting making phone calls, driving all over town wasting fuel and time, truly ask yourself if it's worth it. If the mower does not run because of a dirty carburetor, that is in no way John Deere's fault. You can try and blame the gasket all you want, but the dirty fuel caused the engine issues, and the fuel has nothing to do with mother Deere.
People come in our shop all the time claiming warranty because something won't start. 99% of the time it will not start because they used bad fuel, or let their ethanol blended fuel rot in the machine all winter long. How on earth is that the product's fault? That's strictly a user issue and lack of maintenance or care. When you purchase/own something, you are responsible for learning how to use it and maintain it correctly.
I am not trying to be rude about this, but having experience with this every single day, people need to know that warranty in today's world is not on your side. It's just a "comfort" term to get consumers to purchase something. Depending on your local John Deere dealer, you may or may not receive this kind of answer.